The pizza we got tonight was so good! Serious compliments to tonight's chef. The white pizza was to die for. Reminded me of back home in NJ.
This is by far the best pizza around!!! Service is excellent as well!! We loved Jerry's in Longwood and we're so happy to have found the brother-in-law's place here in Altamonte Springs - corner of 434 and 436!!!! Going back again...again...again...again...
Good pizza! I come from the northeast, and it is hard to find a good slice in Florida. Happened to walk in when they had a big rush on slices and had run out. They were prepping a fresh one and asked what toppings I liked and they would make that for me! Super nice of them, but I ordered a small pie so that I didn’t mess up their flow. Reminds me of the old fashioned “House of Pizza,” restaurants back home. Good food, well priced, the staff seems to be family—and I love family run businesses. Will be back for sure.
Geat food, friendly and speedy service! First place in 5 states that was willing to add mustard to my stromboli. I can't wait to try other menu items.
We come all the way from Orlando to eat in Altamonte. Best pizza in fl... Coming from Massachusetts it hard to find a comparison... but we found it! �� #pizzaforlife
First time customer here! All I can say is I'm very impressed with this business. The food is great and the service is even better. It is family run and they're doing everything right to earn your business. I will be back!
Yummy yummy pizza wings nd all food great people great service 😎
Best Pizza in Orlando! If you want real NY pizza then this is the place to GO!
I love their New York style pizza. One of the best around.
Love this place!! It's the best pizza in central Florida. Staff is always nice and friendly and there specials are awesome
I've lived so close for so long and never visited until today. I will be a repeat visitor.
If you're looking NY pizza THIS is the place! I grew up in queens n this pizza is the closest to NY I can find near me 🍕😋
Best New York style pizza in town. I would eat at Jerry's Pizza And Subs every day if my budget and wife allowed for it. They will always be my go-to for pizza. Tony and Dawn are very friendly, provide excellent customer service, and are always happy to see my family and me. Great catering service, too.
Love home dressing salad. And the pastrami sandwich great!
I was referred here for their Meatball Subs. They opened about 5mins early. While waiting for my food, they already had 4 dine-in guests sit and another 5 or 6 take-out orders, just to show how popular the food must be. The lady up front was super welcoming and engaging during the wait. The music in there is decent, too. A few of the guests seemed to be regulars.
Met the owners at our neighborhood garage sale. They claimed their pizza was closer to NY style than most places around. Although we live in Apopka, we decided to give them a try, and they did not disappoint. The pizza was very good. Good flavor on both the sauce and the crust. Unlike those chain restaurants, they have a 20" pie. One was large enough to feed the 3 of us. We will definitely be having them again in the near future.
Have only tried the pizza and knots so far but have been happy every time. We love the standard cheese and get the white when we want variety. I would compare the crust to a Brooklyn style from Dominos, which is great since it's been impossible to find that from a local joint around here. We usually go around dinner time and have never had to wait forever after arriving at the estimated pick up window. Pic included is the 20 inch and it's just as good as the pic suggests!
Everything was great I love the pizza like this one. I will come back and I really recommend it. And great service. This is my first time I came to this location. Thank you the pizza was very delicious.
New York style pizza big slices sold by the slice, 2 slices and a drink is the special. Comes cheese I got pepperoni, ingredients tasted like high quality pizza cheese and topping it’s hard to fake those especially with me since it’s probably my favorite most eaten food over my lifetime. So definitely stop in if you like New York style and they have good subs with fresh boats head meat I had got some turkey sliced to feed my yorkie since she was riding with me and I tried it myself the meat was great also. Fresh food and nice owners which I met at the counter… ENJOY.👍🏼
I ordered a 16 inch pizza with mushrooms and pepperoni plus 10 buffalo wings.
First off this place has ACTUAL buffalo sauce not normal hot sauce pretending to be buffalo. The wings were cooked until crispy but still juicy inside The pizza was about an 8/10. I'd highly recommend the wings here.
Jerry’s has become our new favorite pizza shop. The BBQ pizza is the best we’ve ever had, the food is always fresh, and the service is always great. While this place looks unassuming, it is definitely the best in the area.
Have you moved from NY/NJ and HATE Florida pizza? Then you must come here. It will restore your faith in pizza for sure. I can't get over how REAL Jerry's slices are. If they can impress a Florida pizza snob like me then they're doing something VERY right. 10/10 will be coming again. And again.
I got a chef salad and an order of garlic knots and both were fantastic. The house creamy Italian was delish as well. Everyone in the bank was asking what I ordered as they smelled the garlic. I’ll be back for sure.
The staff is always friendly and the food is great. Definitely recommend the garlic knots as well.
Jerry's not only has amazing food, but the staff is so friendly, personable and on-point! Even during their busiest times, they make time to communicate with the customers and provide timely updates. Not to mention they are so down-to-earth! This family owned place is one of my go to places. I love it here! Five stars, highly recommend!
Jerrys is the best pizza in town. Their thin crust and amazing toppings are to die for. They also make an AMAZING chef salad.
Great pizza and very nice staff . The lady at the front was super sweet and asked me how I enjoyed my food I will definitely be back again .
Very good white pizza so good I ate most of it before taking a picture for review #cleanplateclub
I decided to try this place after seeing the really good reviews for the wings and pizza. I ordered a regular cheese pizza with wings and i thought the pizza was not bad but i prefer more marinara sauce on my pizza. As for the wings i had the garlic teriyaki and i thought the sauce was pretty good but I'm a sauce person so i couldve used a little more. But overall i thought the wings were pretty good as well but i wouldn't say i haven't had better. Service was good and the ladies that helped me were nice.
Walked in for lunch 2 weeks ago. I'm back again today, and the pizza is just as good, if not better than 2 weeks ago. The crew and owner are fabulous. The place is very clean. This is absolutely a great lunch stop
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes