Best Ice Cream in Amherst

10 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Anderson's Frozen Custard
Anderson's Frozen Custard
92/100 (296 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Fast food
American
American
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Choco-Peanut Butter Passion
Roast Beef
Haddock Fish Fry Dinner
Ice Cream
Beef on Weck
Roast Beef on Kilmerwick Roll
Birthday cake
Onion rings
Mintzilla Sundae
Carl's Choice w Side of Au Just and Curly Fries
Ice Cream Sandwich
Banana split
Small Hot Fudge Sundae with a Small Drink
Ice Cream Cake
Original Roast Beef on Weck & Curly Fries
Beef Gravy
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Turkey Sandwich
Vanilla Frozen Custard
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Burger
Brownie Overboard
Beef
Hard IC Shake
Salad
Curly Que Fries
Fast food
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"The ice creams are ok. The bubble gum flavor had some gum pieces that are very hard to chew. The Oreo ice cream had tons of cookies which was nice,..."
Jen Groot
"The ice cream cake had a very different and eye catching design! It also tasted very good! My first time buying an ice cream cake from Anderson’s;..."
Joseph Hallata
"Always visit here. They have ice cream and food. Never tried the drive thru. Got a root beer milkshake, this was made with root beer syrup not from..."
Dee Dee
"Only had soft serve ice cream, so I can't comment on anything else. Small cone was on what I would have considered a baby cone, and quantity was..."
Brian Moeller
"Cant go wrong! I've been to this Anderson's and the one in Williamsville on Main St. Always delicious food and custard/ice cream with good service...."
Dan Thomas
"Clean, kid friendly. Make your own salad and vegan burger was delicious. Had the cookie dough ice cream pie... was hoping for a full crust, no cookie..."
Michelle Hageman
"We love Anderson's. I haven't been to one in years since I moved away. I was just shocked by how expensive it..."
Christina L
San Marco Ristorante
San Marco Ristorante
91/100 (492 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Risotto
Bass
Bolognese
Ice Cream
Gelato
Pesto
Wild boar
Shrimp
Lobster
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Private Dining
Street Parking
Reservations
Dinner
Fine Dining
"The food is excellent. The venison special was the best venison I have ever tasted. Veal saltimbocca was excellent. Not one bad thing to say about..."
road warrior
"We came to San Marco for a celebratory dinner. Everything from the wine, the appetizers, the main course, and the deserts were delicious. Service was..."
Sean Grohman
"The food is absolutely amazing! It has that nice classic atmosphere with it. I would return back..."
Nelson ns
"I spent a lot of time traveling all of Italy and America and many other countries. I eat Italian food everywhere I go. I can think of few restaurants..."
RAFFAELE GENNARO VILLELLA
"Doesn't look like much from the outside but the atmosphere when you walk in is very inviting and warm. The wait staff was very friendly and the food..."
Breanne Callahan
"Came for a family dinner for my mother-in-laws birthday. Staff was friendly and efficient. One of the only places I've been where the server poured..."
E Malinoro
"Great ambience! Love the family owned business! Great service and very friendly! Every room that I saw had only 4-5 tables so even when busy it..."
Erson “Dr. E” Religioso III
"agree -- with other reviews. excellent food all around. gnocchi appetizer is amazing, as was the venison special the other..."
Kevin Russell
Hastee Tastee
Hastee Tastee
89/100 (321 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Probably one of the best banana splits that I've ever had over 62 year's. And they still have outdoor seating...."
John Garcia
"This is... without a doubt... the best ice cream we have EVER had... they are not offering us free ice cream to say that... (we will accept any that..."
Paul Smith
"Best ice cream we have ever had!!! no joke!!! They have every kind of ice cream you can think of to accommodate everyone (gluten and dairy free) and..."
Melissa Wagner
"The number 1 Banana Split we have ever had in our life !!! When in the area again we will definitely..."
KC R
"I nice variety of choices and reasonable prices. They also have a large patio with quite a few..."
Dale Chan
"Good stuff and good icecream! Excellent spot in downtown amherst. I like getting little faces on my orange sherbet cone. Kids like it too. I've..."
Josh Cumberledge
Bart's
Bart's
85/100 (423 ratings)
Dessert
American
Soups
Cafe
Breakfast
Ice Cream
"Best Chinese food in Amherst downtown. The authentic Pork Shredded in Beijing Sauce are not found in any other Chinese restaurant! Mapo Tofu is..."
snowyCheckpoint
"Extremely large menu where items carry no description of what's contained. Delicious beverages and decent quick vegetarian tofu and vegetable meals...."
Rebecca Morgan
"Very good! Food came out as it was prepared! Enjoyed the Crab Rangoon and boneless..."
Elle deValois
"The food was GREAT. I’d rather they take credit cards and offer a meal instead of having to get rice separately from the entree, but the food was..."
Jeremiah Scanlon
"One of the best Chinese food in town. Especially the sour soup beef and spicy..."
Cony Ming-Shen Ho
"I don’t know why all these local guides are leaving bad reviews, but after the manager changed for Panda East, the service is now at a way higher..."
Ben Wu
"Is this place good? I ate here regularly in the late nineties; that fact that this place is still around must mean that it is as AWESOME as it was..."
Javier Colayco
"I've been going here for more than 30 years...."
RJ FRANKE
"I was brought out to lunch here several days ago with two good friends of mine around noon. A very nice and big spacious restaurant and honestly..."
Tyler John Almgren
"Great traditional menu. Ordered from lunch..."
Ci Besn
"Came in tonight with spouse and ordered the sweet potato cakes, twice cooked pork with leek, and an eggplant dish. They were out of eggplant but gave..."
Andrea Welsh
"Friendly staff and very authentic Sichuanese..."
Will Schwarzer
"Wanted to write a positive review cause they were absolutely slammed tonight (Christmas) and there was a mix-up with telephone numbers vs. online..."
Jack Cape
Kreig's Itz The Berries
Kreig's Itz The Berries
84/100 (555 ratings)
Restaurants
Healthy
Healthy
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Healthy
Lunch
Dinner
"The best icecream around, and great..."
Nathan Smith
"Delicious! They had our favorite flavor, Raspberry (we love the swirl). I love the fact they have a kiddie cone size. Great for kids and my..."
barb vancs
"Our favorite local ice cream stand! The pistachio custard is so good. Kids love the ice cream by the scoop! We go every year, all season..."
Stephanie Clawson
"Family oriented business! Always wonderful..."
Rick Adkins
"We always enjoy going here. The frozen custard is excellent and so far we’ve enjoyed everything we’ve tried on the food menu as well. The lines..."
Curtis Fox
"An excellent ice cream place, exceeding the expectations normally held for a roadside stand ice cream vendor. They make their own soft serve fruit..."
Uriah Jackson
"Stopped by after a long day of work for some surprisingly great ice cream and awesome service. Will certainly be back, for more ice cream and..."
Cam Neptune
"Very cute little ice cream shop with an expansive menu! I tried one of the sundaes, which was definitely big enough for two people to split and..."
Camille MK
Sal & Al's Diner  & Danny's Pizza
Sal & Al's Diner & Danny's Pizza
81/100 (833 ratings)
Restaurants
Diner
American
Diner
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Ice Cream
Perogies
Burger
Sit down
American
Diner
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great restaurant with specialty foods as well as everyday foods cooked to your liking.  Service is always great and it is always CLEAN!  Family..."
Judy Wargo
"My husband and I ate there last week for the first time.  The service was fantastic!!  I had ribs and they were delicious.  There was plenty of..."
Trish Morgan
"I use to visit this restaurant years ago and had not had the opportunity to revisit for quite some time because I was out of state, and I thought..."
Jane Taylor
Hot Dog Heaven
Hot Dog Heaven
81/100 (1403 ratings)
Quick Bites
Fast food
American
American
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Chili
Hot Dog
French Fries
Fast food
Fast food
American
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"It was great coming back to this place for the first time since its reopening. The food was good, the service was good. We did not wait very long...."
Adam klemens
"The Kielbasa dog and Beef chilli dog were great! The fries not so much. They may want to rethink those. Steak fries or crinkle might better. Overall..."
Michael Goodwin
"Enjoyed a chili dog, fries and strawberry shake... many great memories..."
Susan Zabrecky
"Went here for the first time in years. New building is nice and clean. Food and service were both great and even though it was busy, it did not take..."
Alex Washburn
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill
81/100 (1334 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Fast food
Fast Food
Dinner
Chicken Fingers
Hot Fudge Sundae
French Fries
Chicken Tender Sandwich
Double Cheese Burger Combo
Peanut Buster Parfait Made with Pecans not Peanuts
Large Cheese Curd
Ice Cream
1 3 lb Double with Cheese
Side of Cheese Curds
Slush
Moolatté
Sit down
Fast food
Wheelchair Accessible
Drive Thru
Cheap Eats
"Great place. I ordered a ice cream cake. It was decorated..."
Sherie Plaza
"They have really good things to choose..."
Crystal Rivera
"Very fast in the ordering lane, polite and friendly service at the window. Love us some..."
Darrell Martin
"Love the family who owns it, and they seem to hire all good people who will represent..."
WLH 4
"Great service! They're always very cautious with my daughter's food..."
Professor KimK
"Their ice cream is delicious. The staff works hard to serve the customer quickly and in a cheerful manner. Debbie..."
Debbie Gresh
Goberry
Goberry
79/100 (216 ratings)
Dessert
Fast Food
Ice Cream
Frozen Yogurt
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Cheap Eats
"Fresh, simple, refreshing. GoBerry reminded me to eat more frozen yogurt. I had the original with cherry and pretzel. The cherry was so good I should..."
Shannon Adams
"I had to try GoBerry N Cream. I saw the sign and I love supporting Fresh and local especially when it’s some FroYo. I really liked it here...."
Crystal Perry
"So happy there is still a place to buy froyo out there! The plain is my favorite, and it was so delicious and tart. The honey lavender was yummy too...."
Madison
"The staff was super sweet (pun intended), and the key lime was great with graham cracker crumbs and popping boba! I can't wait to come..."
Rebecca Marshall
"I wonder if this GoBerry is the same one as the Northampton’s. The frozen yogurt was pretty good but not as impressive as the Northampton’s..."
Josie Rossum
"Great local dairy frozen yogurt, rotating flavors. I find the flavors subtlety different but I really like it. Not too sweet, a bit tangy which is..."
Lyle Frenkel
"I LOVE this place!!! Their yogurt is amazing, and their toppings are always fresh and delicious! I always get the mango, raspberries and toasted..."
Cynthia Bush
"low sugar, just four choices of flavor. very simple very low-key. more than a dozen toppings. probably pretty healthy. local dairy. not a typical..."
Daniel Reis
"So fresh, the real deal. Nice to be able to get tart froyo but plenty of other indulgent flavors too. Tons of toppings, including fresh berries. Very..."
Dorit Radzin
"Specializes in local products in their frozen yogurts. This is not a self-serve place where you put the toppings on yourself. You tell the employee..."
Joe Hutson
"It tastes just like goberry so big fan of that!!! though I did not like how I think they were the owners, well i hope they were since they were..."
Jessica Martin
"This should be rated higher. Not even over priced and ive never had better quality froyo ever. All the 1 star reviews complaining about price are all..."
Dominic Sychtysz
"This place offers the best quality frozen yogurt you can ever find. Sadly It closes during this pandemic. I’ve checked online multiple times and..."
L D
"Super tasty local milk made frozen yogurt and alot of toppings. They have different flavours everyday. They have pints to bring home. There is a..."
Attie C
"Visited my daughter at college so she took me there for Fro-yo. Cute little shop and delicious Fro-yo. The taste was..."
Natasha Waldron