Seafood cuisine: the best places to taste it in Anna Maria Island
2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"The grouper I got was in all seriousness the BEST I have ever had. EVER. It was so good I went back the next night to get more. My daughter, who..."
Pam Gould
"Anna Maria is our second home. Every stay in AMI begins the same way with a stop at Capt Anthony's Seafood Market. Pick up incredibly fresh fish and..."
Kevin Mulshine
"Best and Freshest Fish and Stone Crabs on the Island.
Also, the Best Fish Dip to be..."
Jon Bonadeo
"Amazing! There is no better place to go for fresh seafood. Captain Anthony and wife Joann are true professional fisherman constantly offering an..."
Mark Melancon
"OMG! The best freshest stone crabs ever! We lived in South Florida for 15 years, when we moved to the Tampa Bay area we were afraid that it would be..."
Marianne Philippart
"Oh my! Did we have the freshest grouper filets that was caught today! Matt even gave us the trays to cook them in and the..."
Alexander Burkovsky
"The # 1 Place to get the Best and fresh..."
Francine Guy
"Love this place! Stop every time we leave the beach for seafood. Miss Joanne is the best. She takes her time and is so friendly. They have the best..."
"Lucked out and found a self seating table within minutes. our server Alex was laid back and knew what he was doin. had a trio of fish and a..."
Cody Baker
"Great Food and Friendly Service. We had wonderful meals here twice ,the restaurant itself is charming ,the staff greeted us with cheerfull smiles..."
Gourman
"Don't let the Shark fool ya!. By accident, I found this restaurant while searching for something to eat along the beach. If you're familiar with this..."
The Magical Pig
"Best seafood on the island/ good service and entertainment..."
Dt88
"Nice atmosphere and friendly staff. Food was great! The lobster linguinie was delicious and it was a very large portion. The prime rib was..."
Victoria
"Great Special. The night we went, 1 of the nightly specials was Cajun Prime Rib. My only issue with it was that it did not come in a 16oz portion. It..."
Thunder Dawg
"Fantastic food, very cool atmosphere, very friendly staff! Can't wait to go back!! Order the sea bass, scallops, or lobster spring rolls - can't go..."
Katie N
"This is the second year in a row we've come to Sharky's for my birthday. The shark bites are really good, as was the fish trio special. Large..."
Tristaan
"Sharky's Seagrill. Sharky redoo-we visited sharky's two years ago and it was good ..now is oooo... wownice change- new decor -new menu -new..."
Steven Gerard
"Ate there last night, very good food , old school restraunt. Kinda of pricey but the best tasting meal we have had on the island. If you don't older..."
Joe B
"Best Restaurant on the Island. Grate Food and a good value You get complete meal for the price no extra this and that last night was our anniversary..."
Martuzi56
"We just stopped in for an appetizer and drinks. We had the shark bites (mako) and they were very good. Also, Gina enjoyed her Key Largo..."
Tim Goyette
"I'm from Oklahoma visiting the island and was looking for a great seafood place. This one is within walking distance. Walked in and were greeted..."
Stephen Pales
"I’d have to say that my very first impression of this place was, omg what did I walk into.
There were only two servers and a bar tender, looked..."
JustMy Thoughts
"Excellent sea grill in the Anna Maria area.
Access is relatively easy and the area is great, it is located in front of the beach where the views of..."
Matias Baldi
"6 Stars. This place is wonderful in every way. Tom at the bar makes strong drinks and deserves large tips. The prime rib was perfect, suzy had..."
paul terhune
"Awesome place to get prime rib. And the mussels are always spot on. Service is great and the price is very reasonable for the..."
Steele Russell
"Awesone dinner & service too!! I had the Macadamia crusted Red Snapper & my significant other had the Onion Crusted Grouper. We will definitely be..."
Doreen Lab
"Is amazing restaurant, good food, good service, good price.Mrs Jean friendly and serve us too good. We will be back for ours next visit.highly..."
Amy Vo
"This place is amazing. Very nice place for dinner with the family and or a date night. Food is well worth the price! Highly recommend eating..."
Michelle Yarwood
"The service is excellent. Food delicious, and options for everyone. Full Bar with knowledgeable bartenders. Prime rib special $17.95 Sun-Thur..."
Rebecca Burden
"Small intimate place. Love the dark wood inside. Don't let the exterior fool you. Food was good. Added a star because they have Guinness on..."
Josh Riddle
"DO NOT let the neon sign and enormous shark deter you! This place is a winner! My fiance and I were staying across the street and had heard very good..."
Angela Beers
"Melt in your mouth filet mignon and prime rib specials, vegetables are delicious..."
Julie Bishop
"We came in Sunday night and ate at the bar, all had the Prime Rib, best meal on the island all week! We sat at the bar, our bartender Michelle (?)..."
David Harrison
"Lobster ravioli with beet cream sauce was amazing. I put this place on my list every time I travel down from..."
Edward Butler
"We arrived early (before our reservation time) and they were happy to seat us as they had a table available.
3 of our party of 4 had the red snapper..."
Julie Olson
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes