The most friendly staff who never fail to make you feel welcome with a smile no matter how busy. The food is always spot on with no bad choices to be found and presented fast.
Great Staff, friendly casual atmosphere, great tasting food at great prices. Always worth it and im driving 2 hrs every time
Sal's pizza never lets you down! Great pizza, don't get me started on those awesome garlic knots! All around great food!
Great pizza at a reasonable price! The garlic rolls are a delicious bonus.
Awesome place! The best pizza west of the NY metro area. It reminds me of home. Also love that you can have it by the slice.
After being in Wisconsin for 2 years, I finally found good pizza. This is a genuine NY pizza joint.
Lisa Lindstrom Gotelaere
+5
Fantastic pizza! Great price and great staff. A must stop when in Appleton!
Great pizza slice, great price amazing garlic roll comes with it
I called in a pick up order. When i arrived, i was informed that their delivery driver accidentally took my pizza on a delivery. I was disappointed to have to wait another 15 minutes, however, the guy gave me a fresh pizza as well as the one that was accidentally taken by the driver. Great pizza, but the great service will keep me coming back.
Every time Im there it’s the best. Never had a bad slice
Wonderful! All their pizza and food is divine! Especially love the lasagna pizza.
Proppa!
Great pizza, great service!
A must visit!
The best Buffalo Chicken pizza! They are supper friendly even when you come in all fucked up after bar close
I tried out Sal's Pizza while visiting Appleton recently. They sell pizza by the slice, and had a variety of options to choose from. I was greeted upon entering the restaurant, and a few people were dining in. The guy behind the counter was friendly and talkative. The pizza comes with garlic knots on top, and both slices and rolls are placed in the oven to warm them up when you order. I found the pizza to be very tasty, with a crisp crust and flavorful toppings. All in all, an excellent experience and great food, will definitely keep Sal's on my list for future visits.
This pie is Legit! Great deal on the slices and bread roll. This is a for sure stop anytime I'm in Appleton! The sauce rocks...cheese is balanced and the dough! Get some!
Only real NY style pizza in the valley (that I know of). So for that alone this is good. Atmosphere is also great, a usually lots of people in the store and it’s nice. The table of condiments with Parmesan and whatnot is also awesome. Prices are really reasonable too. Parking is a little bit of a challenge if you’re coming here specifically though.
We never vist Appleton without stopping at Sal's for a slice! Generous slices of thin crust pizza. Great variety. Pizza is fantastic and the rolls are amazing. Service is always good. Dining room and restrooms are always clean. Outdoor seating area. Very highly recommend Sal's Pizza!
Best pizza around. We love the Barbecue chicken pizza. I order it every time I go there, which is often. Garlic rolls are to die for. I could eat those all day.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes