We had an awesome and outstanding time at New York Prime, our server Lonny was the best I have had! We enjoyed the Carpaccio and Shrimp cocktail, then we had steak with creamy spinach, fettuccine Alfredo and a Caesar salad. At the end we were brought a Lemon Butter cake with ice cream on top and it was OUT OF THIS WOLRD! I really recommend this place! It awesome!
I spent my 30th birthday here with my fiancé.
Evan and Mina were our service team. It was Mina’s first day and we could not tell as her attention to detail was amazing and so were her suggestions when we were unsure about what to order. We honestly thought we had two ppl servicing us as she complimented her shadow, Evan well! Evan had many jokes to share and had us laughing all night. They checked on us to make sure we were satisfied.
We ordered oysters, bacon, and steak. Evan and Mina helped us choose our drinks. They made it hard for us to leave. I want to say thank you for a memorable experience. I am moving back to New York & I will be bragging about this location forever. I would highly recommend to anyone in Georgia and to my friends that want to visit!
Everything was delicious. We were celebrating my daughter's birthday. I had the crab cakes and broccolini. My daughter had salmon and sauteed spinach. Our server was Nina, and she was outstanding. I definitely will be back to try their ribeye.
Caleb our attendant was awesome. He really made our 25th anniversary special. The food was amazing. I recommend the Oysters Rockefeller and of course any steak. The surprise was the fettuccine alfredo that was made tableside. An amazing experience.
Great choice. Celebrated my daughter's birthday. If you're looking for a great steak and exceptional service than this is the place to go. A lot of folks advertise Baltimore style crab cakes!! If you're looking for great crab cakes then you must try theirs. Nice bar too and the drinks aren't watered down. Plenty of parking. Very interesting to get to. There's a street or ramp in the middle that will take you to the top. I recommend this place based on food and service.
I had a great time ! The waiter was really nice and his name was Jp and The food was amazing and jp’s service was amazing. Make sure to try the butter cake when you come in.
Our first time dining here, awesome. Our server Colton was top notch. Excellent service and the delicious food was first rate. I see why this restaurant has such great reviews. I highly recommend New York Prime. The tomahawk steak and the 3lb stuffed lobster is a must dining experience. Great drinks, very good and close by parking. My wife and I will return. I had a beautiful birthday there and again, highly recommended.
An AMAZING experience start to finish. Our server Ethan was incredible, attentive and engaging.
The food was delicious! The steak melted like butter. Everything we tasted was flavorful. We will definitely be back.
Used Valet to park. Arrived Just before close and was seated promptly with a smile. Waitress was very friendly and helpful with the menu.
I orders the Crab Cake, Cesar Salad, 8oz Ribeye, with a French Martini. The crab cake was So tender and flavorful. The salad was a classic Cesar, no complaints. The baked potato was hearty and baked well. The steak was done perfectly, no steak sauce needed. The martini was blended well and tasty.
The staff was delighted and courteous.
Went to dinner with my son, and it enjoyed it. Jable was a fantastic server and was the best part of the experience. The oysters Rockefeller was great, wedge was tasty, the carpaccio was like "meat butter" (as described by our server & amazing),tomahawk was good, the lobster table side was a nice touch, and the butter cake was top notch.
Amazing food!! Great and entertaining waiter. Definitely a place to visit for a special occasion.
Jesus-Daniel Gutierrez (JD)
+4
Excellent service and good attention. Every employee showed good hospitality skills. The bar has excellent atmosphere, ideal for a quick drink, socialize or have a nice meal. The dining room is large with well distributed spaces all along. The good maintenance is notable from afar. The food selection is almost as it was curated with delicacy and excellent taste. My steak was close to being perfectly cooked, probably some of the best I’ve had in many years. Their service had a couple of minor hiccups but mostly due to some miss communication. It was promptly addressed by our most attentive serverJeff. Lastly, their drinks and wine selection was as splendid as the quality of the food. They have complimentary valet but they also validate parking at the nearby lot. $$$$$
Some of the best steak you can find in the Atlanta area! The atmosphere is very ambient, the service is very professional, and let’s not forget the steak. Nothing beats a good dry-aged steak in my opinion, but the “Pittsburg” char, as they call it, on my bone-in New York Strip was phenomenal! I couldn’t finish the whole thing myself, but that leaves more room for tomorrows lunch 😏
When it comes to special occasions, or if I just want a really nice meal for once, this place is up there at the top of my list.
Our waiter set the bar very high saying NYP was just like our favorite steakhouse. Cool, let's see (but now we're a little jaded). Complimentary bubbles from Geno, table breads, Old Fashioned for the table, Stone Crab and Baked Shrimp appetizers, Pittsburgh-style New York Strip & Bone-in Ribeye (perfectly cooked), Southwest Creamed Corn, and Charred Brussel Sprouts were all impressive in their own way... but not the same as our favorite. Lawrence's service, attention, and patience were a hit! Verdict: We'll go back... one day.
Me and my hubby decided to try a new steakhouse for our 10 yr anniversary! Food was superb. Bone in rib-eye and the crab cakes were mind blowing good. But honestly the best part of this evening was the hospitality. Our server, sarab was phenomenal and the manager Megan was super sweet and made sure our experience was perfect. Thank u New York prime!!! We will be back
I normally don’t do a 5 star rating but last night was on point I took my Fiancé to celebrate her bday and I must say we wasn’t disappointed. The The appetizers was on point the drinks was on point and the entrée was superb she had the Seabass that she had never had before and she loved it I have the bone in ribeye 22 ounce steak well done and it was right on the money Our waiter Jeff was wonderful str8 detail on the menu I definitely will come back again!! Here’s My Pictures
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes