Came here because I wanted to try them to compare against other places in the area. They were pretty good. Right on the beltline so walkable to go to other shops and spots as well. Got the dairy-free vanilla ice cream, topped with bourbon spiced pecans. It was fantastic and it didn't have my stomach going crazy afterwards. Definitely could taste the difference in it being dairy free. Seemed creamier. I'd come back for more, because there are so many flavors.
I don’t know how anyone could rate this less than 5 stars. It’s seriously the best I’ve cream I’ve ever tasted! Soooo incredibly creamy and the flavors are exceptional! I’m already planning a trip back. The service was great and the store is comfortable and quaint. As a bonus, there are gluten-free options and dairy-free options! DELICIOUS!
Service was slow. No fault of the worker. Only one worker on a Friday night. Ice cream was delicious. Cookie Monster was amazing. Wish I could give 5 stars if they were fully staffed. Someone else did show up halfway through our wait so that helped.
Very well laid out. Ice cream was creamy and fresh. Many original and interesting combinations of flavors. Had the Honey Ricotta Pistachio and Maple. Wife had Butter Pecan, Vanilla. Both on GF sugar cone. Amazing!
Peach season in Georgia ended this week, and sadly I couldn’t make it to the final farmers markets to pick up my last ‘fix’. I was happy to be able to get from Butter and Cream, the decadent peaches and cream ice cream, made with Pearson Farms peaches - along with scoops of the creative flavors basil pine nut brittle, and blackberry ginger caramel. All three scoops were fantastic - love that Butter and Cream makes all their ice cream locally with real cream, small batch using fresh ingredients, you can taste the difference in texture, and I’m going to say it’s good (ok ‘better’) for me. Also, the Beltline location meant I could balance the indulgence with outdoor exercise (walking back to my car counts, right?) after.
Their dairy free chocolate is DECADENT!
The DF fruit flavors were highly flavorful, and tasted like pure fruit (not artificial).
I ended up getting a mixed pint of DF Chocolate + DF Strawberry. It was actually more satisfying than the dark chocolate-dipped strawberries I was craving yesterday. 😋
All of the people were over-the-top friendly. The employee was a gem, there were sweet customers in line and cheerful people outside. I'm guessing that this place must be a happiness vortex...
My only qualm is that the DF fruit flavors were icy, and not really smooth. While the taste was spot on, the texture of those flavors were reminiscent of Italian ice.
I can't speak on the dairy options. BUT they had 5 vegan options 🤩. My only wish is that they offered DF ice cream sandwiches in the cooler.
This ice cream was amazing! Staff was helpful in picking out flavors, and it was more delicious than I expected! The honey flavor was perfectly sweet, definitely recommend.
This location is clean, beautiful, and offers a great selection of choices. The five stars are also for Amir. He was super friendly, made great suggestions, and was great to work with. His energy was authentic, chill, and very appreciated.
Great ice creams just quite expensive we spent 20 dollars in ice cream for my girlfriend, a dog an I which is too much I think.. Otherwise it’s great the ice cream tastes really goo!
Parking might be a little hard to find for this place, but don't let that discourage you from going. You can always find parking on the side streets.
This is hands-down the best ice cream place in Atlanta and way better than Jeni's. They're just not famous enough yet. Their flavors are all hand crafted and they taste wonderful.
I have had their OJ goodness, dark chocolate Malbec, two of the coffee flavors, butterscotch brownie, and they were all phenomenal.
In the picture you see the bourbon chocolate and OG goodness.
Please don't waste your time and money going to Jeni's and start going here!
Really great quality ice cream. Super refreshing, loved the cookie monster flavor. Would go again!
I didn’t know a brown sugar cone could be this good. The staff is friendly and helpful, and when I asked them what “OG Goodness” is, they told me it is a brown sugar ice cream, and added that it is their most popular flavor. After enjoying it, I 100% understand.
This ice cream is thick, creamy, and delicious! I also love the quaintness of the shop and it's convenient location in the Krog Market area!
Just discovered this adorable gem 💎 of an ice cream shop. Customer service is excellent. The shop is nicely decorated. It reminded me of those little row shops in those quaint coastal towns. They make their own peanut butter cups! I enjoyed my wonderful ice cream 🍨 and will be returning very soon.
Hubby and I may have found our new favorite ice cream shop. We've visited twice so far. Personally I recommend the honey forest flavor but I don't think any flavor will disappoint
Hands down my favourite ice cream in Atlanta. I’m obsessed the midnight snacks flavour!
Simply delicious. Not overly sweet. You taste the intended flavor in its purity. My son couldn't get enough.
I personally like this one better than the one in Decatur. The employee was super friendly and the ice cream was fantastic. I especially like the OG.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes