Reviews Peter's New York Pizzeria

5
christine fehr
+5
My business taste tested their pizzas. We took some and cook them over an open flame and they were beyond fantastic! We are excited to be doing business with them with our upcoming customers!
5
William McDermott
+5
All I asked for was a garlic half baked with mozzarella and that’s exactly what I got. It was perfect. I topped it and finished it at home. They pulled the pie exactly when it was ready to travel. They were busy, happy, organized and helpful. The pizza was inexpensive and delicious! We’re going back again tonight for another!
5
Andrew Gehrig
+5
Great pizza! Friendly Service. Well taken care of location, clean and fresh atmosphere Recommend their chicken wing & pepperoni pizza
5
Alex Thurston
+5
One of my favorite places to get lunch. Big selection, pizza is always on point. Always friendly people working there. Plus some of my favorite wings in town.
5
John
+5
The best pizza around hands down. Always have great food every time I go.
5
Chris Carter
+5
Owner is pizza king , dough is great plenty of toppings, the boys of Owasco marina thank you great job.
5
Laurie Walter
+5
We like their food a lot. We've always had good service. It's not really a place I would go for atmosphere. We really just go in and leave.
5
Beth
+5
Such good new york style pizza. The staff is super friendly, they are quick too no matter how busy it is there's usually only a short wait time to be helped. The food is delicious and they have a pretty good selection of not only pizza and topping but also other things like breads, calzones, salads, sandwiches etc. And it's affordable! I highly recommend them
4
Holly Mosher
+4
Always hunting for authentic New York style pizza, this place had alot of recommendations when I asked my fb community. It was good, but the crust was tough, and the toppings a bit sparse and not evenly distributed. On to the next pizzeria.
5
Monica Wilson
+5
Everything and I mean everything about this place is AMAZING!! Never a disappointment. Very friendly and fast service. Always polite and attentive.
5
Chris myself
+5
Every time I go there I buy every Pepperoni pinwheel/flower they have lol. Pizza is delicious and staff is friendly. Highly recommended
5
Melissa Marie
+5
Great food. Friendly people. Good value.
4
Lon Large
+4
I must admit that I love the Pizza and garlic Knotts. I would like a little more attention to the environment it really is not up to speed for cleanliness the floor is never really clean. The tables always need attention, pizza boxes and cardboard cover at least half of the indoor seating area. I know it's a successful business and it's very busy but take on one person who only does cleaning, tables, floors, walls, trash, stocking. Maybe inventory but not food service. Again I do love your product.
5
Matthew Johnson
+5
Fresh, fresh dough. Tastes as fresh as when I make it dough myself, but better. Friendly service. Tasty pizza and sandwiches. They have a big staff and give quick service. Clean, wonderful atmosphere. The way they employee so many local young people and decorate the area outside their storefront with flowers is admirable and community-oriented. My wife and I love eating here.
5
Albert Blakeman
+5
All the place is just great food is wonderful. Pizza is always delicious I love their Italian sandwich always on point never been disappointed
5
Sylvia Lennox
+5
Excellent fresh pizza great selection including different veggie ones, great fast service. Crust is crispy & light & slices are generously large. Absolutely recommend 👍
Clicca per espandere