Food is quite good, the chipotle steak is incredible. We started with the tomato pie which if you love cheese or pizza will be a must try. We were able to try the peach cheesecake, the key lime pie, and the banana cream pie; each of these desserts are amazing and I would consider them as must-haves if you still have room for them.
The staff is warm, inviting, and attentive. The restaurant is clean and well maintained, and is decorated appropriately and helps create an ambience and vibe that is The American. I would recommend this to anyone in the North Florida/South Georgia area looking for a great culinary experience.
AMAZING experience!! From the moment we walked in the door we were treated SO kindly. Servers were amazing. Food was five stars from appetizer to dessert, atmosphere was just WONDERFUL! We had never been to downtown Bainbridge before, but now we know! Menu was just out of this world, presentation was spot-on. One of THE BEST restaurants I have ever visited in my 45 years of life! My only disappointment is not knowing about it before now!!! Thanks so much for such a wonderful experience! Can’t wait to go back!!
We decided to have my son’s & daughter in law's rehearsal dinner at The American. It was the best decision. We had a private room at their sister location. The service was excellent and the menu was decided ahead of time. I highly recommend any wedding party choosing this restaurant. Everyone loved the food and the cornbread was a hit.
Food and ambiance was great I had the Chipotle Ribeye with Truffle fries and Mac and Cheese. I even tried The Spearmint Sweet Tea. Definitely recommend this restaurant.
Beautiful historic building, only ordered dessert but the menu looked great! Now…the desserts WOW the had Banana Cream pie, Strawberry Cheesecake and Key Lime Pie. The banana cream pie was absolutely the best I’ve ever had (besides my mama’s) service was great and the hospitality was amazing! Hidden gem in Bainbridge,GA! We’ll be back!
This place is awesome. The service, the vibe, the food…all incredible. Seems like a great family doing an awesome thing on the square! If you are in the area, I suggest eating here. Specifically the Gouda grits and pork chop. Thanks Tyler for the great experience and even better conversation.
One awesome burger... a perfect mix of brisket and short ribs topped with cheddar. Delicious!!! Love the American theme in the restaurant and the cute little seating areas. Everything was neat and clean to include the bathrooms. Service was excellent keep up the good work and we will see you again soon.
The very best restaurant in Bainbridge and all around our area. This is food like I have never tasted in my life. Chef Tyler really could be compared favorably to any of the top chefs I have seen on Food Network.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes