Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Barnegat
8 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"A great new spot with delicious, fresh food that feels like home cooking. The staff is friendly and always smiling, and the owner is always ready..."
Michael F
"The food is fantastic, and a staff & environment to match! Loved their pizza, pasta, and literally the best rice ball I’ve ever eaten.
Be sure to..."
Francesca Brugnolotti
"A wonderful place to bring your family out to eat. Gemelli has a welcoming atmosphere and polite staff that make dining there an absolute delight. I..."
Shari Javines
"First time ordering from here tonight we got delivery. EXCELLENT! Loved the eggplant vegetable rollantini and sautéed spinach. Sometimes when you..."
Lauren Accaria
"Friendly staff and consistent service. Good good. Flounder Français was fresh and we'll prepared. The paella was fresh with a slight kick off..."
Martin Meltzer
"2nd Review* The food We ordered tonight came quick hot and correct!!!! So very happy. Everything was delicious. We ordered chicken marsala , chicken..."
carol healy
"Had an amazing brunch today at Gemelli's and all the food was fresh and tasty: the made-to-order omlettes, the mini-waffles, and all the items on the..."
Tom Ball
"Goes above and beyond the standard pizzeria. Flatbread pizza was good, but I was more impressed with the cauliflower bite starter. The pieces were..."
Christopher Frey
"New restaurant opened in Barnegat. Gemelli's. Excellent. BYOB. My meal 🥘 Chicken Scarpiello pizza 🍕 Delicious. Patsy had Short Ribs...."
Kathy Mellito
"Wonderful pizza. Mussels great. Very friendly staff
Will accommodate any menu choice! Area is small, so get there..."
Pat Marselle
"Friendly staff. Great service. The food is fantastic. Had a yummy rice ball and their eggplant prosciutto sandwich- so..."
Debra Scavuzzo
"Crisp tastey cheese steak pizza, we requested provolone cheese. , excellent. Owner Matt great, all servers attentative, will be returning for..."
Joan Deckman
"Enjoyed my Mother's Day Brunch, especially the Western Omelet, Chicken Franchaise, and the Italian pastries. The price was very..."
Lori Lee
"Great Experience with friendly and courteous staff. The food was fresh, delicious, and excellent. Definitely will go..."
Sharon Charlebois
"Food was excellent. Service was good. Prices were fair in relation to portion size. Will return for..."
"(Translated by Google) Even as a non-regular ordering customer, I can only report good things for several years (5 years). No matter what you order,..."
Andreas Weise
"(Translated by Google) Dear Ladies and Gentlemen,
From a negative order something positive was described - a short phone call problem = solved! For..."
Jimmys Transporte
"(Translated by Google) Super friendly staff, delicious pizza, clean shop. Always my pleasure!
(Original)
Superfreundliche Mitarbeiter, leckere..."
"I've been coming to Naples since it opened. I've never found a better pizza anywhere in the USA that I have traveled or lived. By far the best, its..."
Eric Curtis Cummings
"I know it's a izza place all the pizza is amazing but they by far have the best cheesesteak In..."
Paul Tiller
"Always excellent! By far the best mussels marinara around! We visit often and have never been disappointed! The staff is..."
Denise Murphy
"My family has been dining here for the last 10 years. It's still our favorite in town! From the food to the entire staff it, deserves the best..."
Denyse Szukalski
"Some of the best pizza in Jersey. The Balsamic vinaigrette chicken pizza is my absolute..."
Howie Bothers
"I had what I think was the very best lasagna ever last night ! Don't know if I will ever have anything else . Although the Chicken Parm was difficult..."
Ginger Lenart Oliszewski
"Best server, Tyler Ciaccio, hands down accommodated on every level. 10 stars, 5 for food and 5 for pristine customer..."
Kelly H. Mullarkey Stormer
"Best Pizzia since the 80s when they opened The Pizzia subs and food r always the..."
Craig Steven
"Love this place. Food is always so good never had a bad..."
Lauren Accaria
"Great food and great service. Finally some food that reminds me of..."
Pete Hutto
"Love this place the food is so good excellent..."
Vicky Schimmenti
"Words can't describe how amazing this place is! Naples Special is one of my favorites. Not all pizza places can conquer the crust...Naples does! All..."
Zena Kira
"Best pizza ever!! We are from Georgia and every time we are up visiting our family we must have..."
Wyndie Haldenwang
"I wasn't a fan of thin crust or gormet pizzas. A friend talked me into trying this place today and I was floored. The gormet pizzas are original and..."
James Edward Derrick
"Andre and his crew are the best!!! Best pizza and wings in..."
George Kitzler Jr.
"Pizza was delicious! We dined in and ordered a white and regular cheese pizza and all in our group loved it from ages 8-75! My kids and myself love..."
Jared Fudurich
"My mom an I figured we would give this place a try. Glad we did. It was delicious. Both had the dinners. Highly recommend
We have been back for take..."
Wendy Grim
"Good heavens this pizza was incredible. I had the margarita and it was perfect. The sauce is homemade from fresh tomatoes so it has a lovely tart..."
SamSamButDifferent
"Naples Pizza & Restaurant:
Naples is a great spot for delicious eats. From their pizza to their dinners to their sandwiches, all are well executed..."
R A
"By far the best pizza in town , and great people . Always a pleasure to support them , especially when they go out of their way to make sure..."
Tyler Aviles
"Naples has done a bit of decorating in their dining room since our last visit, nice atmosphere! The food is always consistently delicious. Prices..."
Joe Guastella
"Great food. We love the Italian chicken wings. Our seafood pasta was..."
Chin Li
"Naples doesn't deliver because they don't have to - they have plenty of regular customers. Order online and you can really customize! These..."
Diana Deckman
"Sometimes you want to go where the eggplant Parm is perfection and they know my name. I've been going to this place since I'm a child and it's always..."
Denise Zelman T.
"Finally made it back to Naples pizzeria in Barnegat, after so much medical stuff. It was good to see Andrea and his team. I purchase a large..."
Denise Ryan
"Happy to have found my new favorite pizza place!..."
Maria Eager
"Great Italian dishes and pizza. Very friendly staff and warm..."
David Burley
"We love their pizza. We've been getting our pizza here for about 21 years now. Pay attention to check out. I called in my order for pick up, and I..."
Maddie R
"First time ordering takeout as I am new to the neighborhood. Pie was well done as I had specified and mussels in hot sauce was delicious. Highly..."
Vinny Fish
"I dined in, as I believe pizza eaten fresh baked is the way to judge. The pizza was delicious, folded with no flop and tasty! The Italian Wings were..."
Frank Burkhard
"Foods always fresh and excellent 👍
Great owner..treats everybody like..."
Joseph Landi
"This is easily one of the best pizza restaurants in NJ. The counter people are courteous and fast. Love their vodka sauce and alfredo !!I have never..."
Raymond Regan
"Someone recommended this place to us a few years ago and were we ever glad they did
This has been our go to place for excellent pizza and..."
"We had a family event catered by Vinnie's. The staff were extremely helpful and patient when we ordered the food. The delivery was on time and the..."
Sally DiPaola
"An excellent place to call a neighborhood staple. I was welcomed the moment I walked in by the friendly staff. I ordered two common slices and a..."
Peter Rosado
"FIVE STARS all around. Vinnie's recently catered our twin girls first birthday party. From the beginning to end, Vinnie's staff knocked it out of the..."
Przemek Ryba
"Just. Wow. After working in the area for a bit, it’s only customary to have to find your favorite pizza spot in a new town. After trying the..."
Kashaun Covin
"I can't say enough nice things about Vinnie's, especially the new ownership! The Manager Greg is great as well as their entire team! The food is..."
cynabunzzzy S
"Food was amazing and the owner was nice and attentive when we sat down to eat! I live in northern NJ and always stop at Vinnie’s when I’m in..."
Rachel Canaie
"Don't let this restaurants underwhelming exterior scare you away. This is one of the best Italian restaurants I've been to. You come in hungry for..."
Nick R (redBadger)
"Food and staff awesome. Just a quick stop off exit 67 barnegat nj for a food refuel and a whizzz . It will be worth your time to experience quality..."
Edward Fraser
"Small spot, but their specialty pizzas are my fav, and the employees are the best. It's my favorite fast filling lunch..."
Amber torres-salazar
"This is our weekly pizza place and let me tell you the penne vodka pizza is to die for!!! The entire staff is always so personable and helpful and..."
Julia Harris
"This pizza joint is AMAZING. Great grandma pie- crispy crust, great sauce and ingredients all..."
Kevin
"I used to get from a place in Manahawkin but now I get from vinnies hands down best pizza in town now prices are great..."
Rich Weir
"We stopped in for dinner last month. My husband had chicken franchese and I had linguine with oil and garlic. OMG!! I don’t know whose meal was..."
Ginamarie Phillips
"Delicious and exceptional service. We ordered delivery this evening. The young lady that took my order was a pleasure, the delivery young man..."
"Made a reservation for 10 but had last minute cancellation of 4 people... CALLED TO LET THEM KNOW, little courtesy goes a long way. Found the SPECIAL..."
vincent barletto
"Service could be improved. It was a busy night and there was a wedding party, my friend wanted cheese and it took several follow ups and we still..."
Mian Sta Cruz
"We always enjoy our meal here. We were seated up on entering with a reservation. We opted for the 2/39.99 dinner deal. Choose 1 app, 2 meals and a..."
Vikster
"I was visiting from out of town and was very impressed. The food was great, the entertainment was wonderful and the service was impeccable. Special..."
Jim C
"Cute, comfortable outdoor dining to follow Covid 19 regulations.
They offer specials that change every week, however I had to go with the Penne..."
m
"First time here with the family. Really nice and clean place and we all enjoyed our meals. The bread to start was delicious. Eggplant parmigiana..."
Sue D
"Dining at East Bay is always a pleasant experience The food is well prepared and plentiful. The only thing that I found a disappointment was the..."
Jack D Benisi
"We are a party of 3, including one kid. The gnocchi dish had amazing flavors. The chicken francaise was delicious. The sauce was perfect, not to..."
Theresa Vedutis
"Excellent staff food was 4 out of 5. Mashed potatoes were very dry. Other then that the sangria was fantastic and the pork was..."
kathleen barton
"Great casual place. Most of the food is top-notch. The grandma's pizza is amazing. The pasta with Bolognese sauce is too sweet for my..."
Ron Esposito
"We love the food. Our waitress was terrible. Had to ask for utensils after our pizza was delivered. Had to ask for condiments and getting our change ..."
Madalyn Fantry
"Great food. Great place. I enjoyed Nonna’s Sunday Sauce First time here but won’t be the..."
Lavinia Schiavone
"BEST MEATBALLS EVER!!
Calamari is the best I've ever had in my life ❤
So tender, crispy 😋 with tentacles and sauce 😋 ask for 2 sauces,..."
Lynne Geneva
"Very Good place to eat I enjoy it..yummy food great..."
jamie caiola
"I’ve eaten here a few times and it’s always been wonderful. Today we had a shower for my sister and I can’t say enough positive things. Our..."
"This place has been great on multiple levels. My wife and I just moved to town and was hoping we could find a good Italian place and then we heard..."
Frank Jones
"Consistently good food, very clean, friendly atmosphere. Delivery is just as good as it never looks just thrown in a box and it always arrives in a..."
Deb Bower
"Great food and customer service, it’s our go to..."
Randy Hagen
"Great food the best pizza in town by far service is fast and friendly. ..love that I can order it online it's a piece of cake keep up the great..."
Marisa Jorge Pires
"Love their food ☺️ grandmas pizza is the..."
Michele Weisneck
"Staff is friendly, restaurant is clean, bathrooms are spotless, food is outrageous , owners are caring and commuted to the community . Exceptional..."
Mona L Schindler Nugent
"Ordered delivery last night, the meatball parm sub was delicious! Meatballs tasted homemade, not processed or salty and the roll was very fresh! Also..."
Emily Johansen
"Grab pizza several times a week, sometimes twice in a day. Staff is always personable and efficient. Zero complaints, other than how addicted to..."
Rich Frommann
"Just had another perfect lunch. These guys really make good food. No short..."
Jason Greenblatt
"I don't eat there often, But when I do the food is great. Thank you Jay and Danielle and staff for making such delicious meals. Hint try the chicken..."
Bobby Rufalo
"The food and atmosphere is always great and when you don't feel like going out, their delivery is just as..."
Ami Iannantuano Lombardo
"It is my favorite, besides their great..."
Cynthia Walsh
"Buffalo Chicken pizza is the best I've ever..."
John Cardini Jr.
"I used to work for Jay way back (don't remind me how many years it's been, haha) when it transitioned from Joey's Pizza. Jay is a great guy with a..."
Jamie Leigh
"The food is always DELICIOUS, and the owners are such wonderful, community minded people....a real asset to Barnegat! Thanks for all you do Jay and..."
Grace Keough Buck
"Good neighborhood pizza. I got a plain cheese pizza to go. Great crust, nice sauce and not too much cheese, perfect ratio. With so many places to..."
Don Massa
"Stopped in for some Italian food which we were in the mood for and settled on the chicken parmegiana dinner from their extensive menu. We were not..."
Enrique Cafaro
"Pricier but for a reason. (You get what you pay for) as someone of Sicilian descent who only really knows how to make Italian cuisine, I will truly..."
Sara Rachelle
"Best grandma pie in Ocean County, if not NJ, if not the planet. I haven't had any other food from here besides the grandma pie. Highly..."
Davey Loot
"Treated very well. Staff and management are so kind . Wall of fame awesome. Congratulations to my little brother Tony chini for making it. Looking..."
Sean Martin
"Great food, great service,reasonable price. Owner and his wife are very warm and..."
Glenn Lurie
"Best chicken parmigiana I had in a long time. Bread was fresh and service was..."
Jason
"Excellent food and service, pasta, so delicious, pizza very good, great..."
Wendy and Kay Kay’s Channel
"Hey, forget about it! If you wanna taste a pizza slice that's straight outta Jersey, you gotta try this joint. This slice is the real deal, like..."
R G
"The Spinach Salad is so delicious! Marchioni's is my go to for the best salads in town. Never disappointed. The delivery drivers are wonderful,..."
Carolyne Morris
"We absolutely love Marchioni's and order from there two to three times a week! Highly recommend! Dining in is wonderful as..."
Nick Brown
"Best crust in town! The white pizza here is so deeee-licious.
I also recommend the mussels..."
Michelle P
"Delicious pizza! My family moved to the area and as soon as I tried their grandma pizza I was hooked. Large flavorful chunks of plum tomato sauce and..."
Cassandra Lajeskie
"They make the most delicious pizza in the area! They have hands down the best chicken bacon ranch I have ever tried. We always go here and the staff..."
Alayna Petreski
"Wow 🤩 wings are huge with chunks of blue cheese in the dip. Always my go to place for Italian subs. Very good subs way better then any place I had..."
Cheese Sauce Extra Cheese Mushrooms and Fried Onions
Pasta
Pesto
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Flatbread
Pizza
Italian
BYOB
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Delicious dinner!! The veal chop Parmesan was fantastic!!! The restaurant was a bit chilly with the AC, but my own fault for not bringing a sweater. ..."
Linda McCulla Tonnesen
"Our favorite place for lunch! Food is always fresh, hot and tasty. Pizza, appetizers, hot and cold sandwiches and entrees. Eat in the pizzeria area..."
Marilyn Dori
"Best pizza around here! From North of here and I'll tell you everywhere else in barnegat sucks except LUIGiS!!! Best pizza and meat garlic knots r to..."
Lauren Ashley
"I love Luigi's!! Sal is the best. Vanessa is the greatest waitress. Never had a bad..."
Diane Russo
"We had our daughter’s party here and it was great! Service and food were wonderful. Vanessa went over and beyond to make sure that everything went..."
Jill Patterson Guidice
"The spaghetti at this place is amazing! The service was great. Definitely switching where I get..."
Anthony Pien
"I moved to Louisiana 13 years ago I miss Jersey pizza, I was here in July went to Luigi's 3 times, went back yesterday what does that tell..."
Jean Catlow Arnold
"Enjoyed a very good meal plenty of food service was good and the 2 for 29.95 is a very good value wait time was bearable would go back for..."
Pat Mancine
"Best Grandma pizza I've ever had. Absolutely..."
Marian Laird Repice
"Celebrated Christmas Eve with family and friends. Treated with love and respect...service wonderful...food delish...made our holiday a lovely..."
Carla Trovato Busardo
"Amazing food and amazing people. Had my going away party they're. Everything was perfect . Thank..."
Vincenzo Mattei
"Great Food! Great Service! Awesome staff and owner! Thanks..."
Devin O'Rourke
"Wife loved the food!!!! She said her dish was delicious!! I had the burger and fries. The burger was ok and the fries were good. The fries portion..."
Dwayne Johnson
"Was very busy but as usual but the know what there doing food was ready when I got there and delicious as..."
Anthony Carfagno
"This place is incredible! Their sandwiches and wraps are made incredibly well and are packaged neatly in high quality materials. It is clear that..."
Steven Frato
"Hasn’t changed in 45 yrs but when it’s good why change it?!
Great pizza, not sure if the name has changed over the years but I went back after 45..."
Donna Pascual
"Good food and a friendly staff. The garlic knots, especially the specialty ones, are soooooo good. The pizza isn't bad and the sandwiches are great...."
Bruce Johnson
"I just wanted to hop on here and leave a review! We ordered from here tonight. It was late when we placed an order. We ordered 6 entrees late too..."
Mikia Yager
"Nice people, great service, decent pizza. There's a place right next to it in the next plaza that's miles better..."
Jason Bean
"Our go-to pizza place! The ingredients always taste fresh, service is always on point and the owner truly cares about his customers. Delivery is..."
Kelsey
"Had a Pizza today by Luigi In Barnaget. Pasquale made me a medium pizza with Broccoli, garlic, and fresh sliced 🍅 .. no sauce. Have to say the..."
GIACOMO Lo Voi
"We love their antipasta and their pizza. We love that they will drive to Forked River to bring us said food. We always give their drivers a $10.00..."
Christopher Abrams
"First time but not the last time. It was a very busy Monday night. Had to wait a little but it was worth the wait. ..."
Lavinia Schiavone
"We live in Stafford so didn’t know this place existed until we got the flyer and immediately noticed the Brooklyn Grandmas pie and had to try it. ..."
Zach Zohan
"I had last minute company with one day’s notice. Pasquale and the Luigi team came through with a catered dinner that was amazing! Thank you for..."
Debra B
"Fried pickles & zucchini sticks are amazing. The sauce alone is to die for.. so good. Always super friendly & fast. Mine & my daughters new fav..."
Kaylarose Myles
"Absolutely Amazing mozzarella n carroza like off the hook Staten Island food! Made with fresh roasted tomatoes and capers!! Never had anything so..."
"I use to work there part time for over a year in a half. I lost my full time job back in October and Carmine (owner) did what every he could do to..."
Gerry Cooney
"I grew up in North Jersey and this is the best pizza I've had since moving here.
You are always greeted with a hello and a smile and the pizza is..."
Michael Howell
"Great food at a great price ,they treat you like family the minute you walk in the..."
michael colandrea
"Best pizza in Barnegat. They treat you like..."
Karen Cilantro
"Best pizza in town. Great taste and..."
Mike Declan
"best pizza in town. always the..."
Cono Cirone
"Best pizza..."
Damon
"Good..."
CORNPOP
"Good ..."
Ruth Buchanan
""
John lampert
""
Jenna B
""
Patrick B
""
Peter S
""
Bob Bell
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes