Tried this place for the first time with my girlfriend and it was absolutely amazing. Our server was great, extremely attentive and friendly. We will 100% be back and can’t wait to try something else on the menu. I should add we drive 35+ minutes just to try this spot. Highly recommended!
I have never been disappointed with anything on the menu. The burritos are my favorite on the island, the margaritas are delicious!! I recommend the BBQ Chicken salad and the portobello quesadilla!
Creative menu, great staff. You should try Pico. The owners are great, friendly people. Oh & if you like tequila this is the place to go.
This was my first tex-mex restaurant experience, and I loved it! Due to their great staff, the atmosphere was very warm and welcoming. Their delicious food was the cherry on top of my amazing experience with my friends. Drinks were awesome too! I would absolutely recommend coming here for a dinner outing.
Good food reasonably priced. Great happy hour. Friendly bartender. Makes a great Margarita.
Hermoso ambiente, la comida excelente, me encanto los tacos de pescado muy deliciosos , las bebidas exquisitas especialmente las margaritas 👍
Fresh ingredients, fun menu, great tap beer and margarita's. I really like the vibe at Pico. Pico's fills a void in the Bay Shore restaurant scene. Going back to back nights!!!!
Great place for a drink or quick eats. Service is friendly. And the burrito bowl is awesome. Cat where have yoy been?
Great cozy space. We were looking for a few apps and drinks. Luckily, happy hour is until closing on Saturday nights. $2 tacos and $1 off tap beer plus $5 well drinks which was pretty small needless to say. But all in all, we were pleasantly surprised. I had tried to get in here before a Boulton show, but there was a 30 minute wait, Now I know why! I cant want to get back to Pico!
The staff is genuinely friendly. The guacamole and the buffalo chicken burrito were awesome.
Went here for taco Tuesday deal and the tacos were legit crazy good. Might make it a tradition to just go there Tuesdays when I'm hungry with the boys. Place has a nice selection of beer as well and the flavor profiles were crazy nice. Outside scene was very nice and the inside was cozy. Very enjoyable experience that's well suited for parties of about 5 or less.
Spring rolls in and all of a sudden the urge to go out and take a walk in Bay Shore is so appealing...especially when on the way to lunch! I recommend you stop by Pico’s...friendly and prompt service, fresh and delicious food, and, a cold beer to round the meal out! So, take a break from your chores and enjoy the beans, burritos, enchiladas, or whatever!
Pork steak fish and southern chicken tacos, didn't care for the pork steak was burnt but the fish and chicken tacos were really good. So not bad. On the other tables the salads/bowls and nachos were huge I think that's what I will have next time.
Real good place, happy hour specials we're a good deal..tacos we're tasty.. wife liked the drinks.. we had the pork nachos and they were excellent.. 4 of us ate and drank for 54 dollars.. will be visiting this place again
Tacos ala cart. I ordered 4 only made it through 3. Tuna, bang bang shrimp, and pork were all excellent. I took a bite from the ground beef to taste but just to full to judge it. Not sure why they only offer soft flour and not a choice of corn.
The pico burrito and the bang bang tacos do not disappoint. I’ve come here several times and I always get the same ones because they’re just so good that I can not pass up. Staff is also very friendly
Services was very good. I enjoyed the food as well tasty.
My first time there and I will be back. Staff is so friendly. Food was great and drinks too.
Everything was great! Fried ice cream is a must.
So many gluten free options, friendly staff, and very delicious food make this a new favorite spot for the husband and I. Check out how they plated those nachos!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes