Love the Penny! Delicious food, great tunes & an awesome bunch of regulars. Always made a point to go whenever Mike or Jill were working. They’re seriously the best - top notch bartenders! �
Can't say enough about Mike and the rest of staff at The Penny Pub! The people, the food and the service are impeccable!! Everyone is friendly and it's a joy to hang and have a drink, eat some delicious food and listen to live music! Always a good time at The Penny!!
Need a late night snack and drink?! The penny pub is a the place to go! Always open late with a fully stocked bar and kitchen!! The bartenders are always friendly and cracking jokes with the customers. The food never disappoins and neither does the drinks!
I absolutely love the new summer cocktail menu especially the cucumber mojito! The staff is very friendly and super accommodating. Mike made my last experience a memorable one. I will definitely be back!
Great staff, great drinks and (oh by the way) great food! Just had an awesome skirt steak sandwich. Delicious!
Great place. Food is delicious, great friendly staff. Darts, warm atmosphere and great location. Highly recommended. Jillian is the BEST BARTENDER!!
Great service from friendly bar staff, great music playing, all round amazing atmosphere. Would happily trade the 2 pubs in my village for this one.
Always a great time!!! Good food too. Bartenders are the best!
Love that the place is open until 4 every night. Bartender John is excellent!
Just had lunch and Katie was a wonderful host, really friendly and just an all out nice lady! The food was fantastic and overall the pub is a friendly place! Will definitely come back next time I am stateside.
Good food, good music (Julia Lambert), great bartenders.
Excellent service mike and jen were amazing ! Excellent customer service!
That Banana/Peanut Butter/Jameson coffee was incredible!
Justine and Adrian made the night a blast!! Love them both!
The Penny Pub is our most favorite bar in town! Awesome food & well made drinks. Great manager & staff! Such a very hard working group & it can be very crazy & packed pub at times but the staff always handles it amazingly well! When we go there we look forward to seeing them all! They like my family when I go there. Last night when we went to the pub we didn’t see one of our favorite bartender Jake . I asked where is Jake tonight & was told he was let go because he can’t work at different bars in the same town! What? Who makes these rules up? It’s hard to get really good, friendly hard working employees these days. Please reconsider & bring Jake back at the Penny!
This bar was a blast to visit we rolled in from Philadelphia with 12 guys after a local event we came up for ended.. bartenders and locals were friendly. We had great service and mixed drink were well made. Beer's were ice cold and poured the way they should be.. they have a section in the back of the bar were we played pool, darts, huge jinga listened to great music.. We highly recommend this pub. This pub was clean with no sticky floors... A++
The penny pub is a great bar for any occasion and a great local experience! Their attentive staff and persistent customer service will draw me back in time and time again. Mike the bartender and George the bar back have made my experience wonderful! I look forward to my next visit at the penny pub
I was just visting NY and it was my first time at this place. I LOVED it! The pumpkin pie martini was amazing as was the food. Seems like anything on the menu is excellent. Bartender was all smiles and great service!
First time ordering, great food. Order delivery off their website - cheaper than third party delivery services. One con? Smaller than I expected portions of the fried Mac & boneless wings.
Hosted a birthday celebration at Penny’s and it was perfect! Food was great, the drinks were perfect and the service was exceptional!! 10/10 !!!
The Dublin dip is one of the best steak sandwiches I've ever had in my life. Cool interior. Nice place for casual eating.
Old school bar, pub food all good. Great drinks, specials and service.
Yummy food! Open late, and great service.
Good drinks, yummy food, & great bartenders! My partner & I have been here a bunch of times. We are never disappointed. We’ve brought friends & everyone loves it. Would definitely recommend!
Definitely recommend especially if Ashley is working. She such a sweet heart and cater to everyone. One of the nicest bartender I ever met. She awesome!!!
Great Pub atmosphere, staff are friendly and pretty fast when place is busy.
They are worth a great tip.
Pool table in back for some fun the foods not bad either. Very chill and fun place to go.
Cute place the rum punch was delicious. But the pièce de résistance last night for me was the Karaoke with Alex, which happens every Wednesday night. We the most fun that could be had on a random Wednesday night. Alex his team were cool hip friendly and welcoming. The karaoke is free, so why not grab a friend head to the penny pub buy a drink or two a few hrs of pure unfiltered fun? See you guys again next Wednesday 🎤🎵🎶🥁🎹🎸
This is my go-to spot in Bay Shore! The food is absolutely amazing ! They make all their sauces/dressings in house - the Guinness Gravy and Beer Cheese are beyond delicious! They have wings with a variety of options/spice levels/flavors - including Lemon Pepper, the typical Buffalo, Irish Whisky BBQ, Garlic & Herb, etc. Love them all - but my fav is the Lemon Pepper (even though I typically steer clear of anything with pepper as I hate spicy! it's not too peppery, thankfully! more of a dry prep as opposed to saucy like the buffalo. )
The atmosphere is also super relaxed - the bartenders & crowd are always friendly ! Love it here!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes