Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Bay Shore
14 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"The slices are HUGE-true NY style. The spinach slice was the BEST I've ever had as well as the garlic knots...Mmm. I have to travel 10 miles for this..."
Donna Williams
"No longer Tina's Pizza. It's now La Casa a much better place and staff then before. Since it's become La Casa I feel there is a much friendlier..."
Vincent
"The food in this place is awesome. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The prices are very fair. I couldn't think of a bad thing to say about..."
richard logrippo
"Great pizza never had a problem everything is..."
"Absolutely outstanding pizza! delicious.. This place is absolutely a gem and the best new addition to the Bayshore community. All the food is..."
Erin Daly-Spano
"We enjoyed our lunch. The food was delectable, fresh, and expertly prepared. We have never tasted better eggplant. The salads complemented the..."
Kathleen Kriehn
"The Slice of Bay Shore has absolutely delicious food!! It has such a welcoming atmosphere. We had the Shrimp Oregenato and Chicken Marsala. Both..."
Shannon Flynn
"My son and I tried this place last night. We had a great experience and this will be our new go to pizza shop. The pizza is great, atmosphere is cute..."
Lauren Elizabeth Albanese
"So far everything I’ve tasted is amazing. Shout out to the best chef, Mike!! Highly recommend the chicken Marsala, vodka slice, and minestrone..."
Morgan Linds
"The new restaurant looks beautiful. I can't believe this was a Friendly's restaurant once. We were a party of 8. We arrived nice and early so it..."
Gary Nasta
"Great food, great wine and great staff! Couldn’t decide amongst the delicious options so we went family style... all was so good... some of my..."
Joanne Russell Hitchcock
"Wife and I went tonight with the family. We shared a pie and my wife got the penne alla vodka. The pasta was delicious and we loved the amazing pie...."
Brian Giglio
"Love it! Excellent food and service! Will definitely be back and recommend it to..."
Barbara Screeney
"Food was delicious. Waitress was very attentive. Would recommend & definitely going..."
Kristie Junior
"My girl and I went for the 1st time last night we went around closing time we ordered 2 slices to go and the guy threw in 2 extra slices for free we..."
Miguel Estrella
"We found our new spot, thank you so much for opening!!!!
Absolutely..."
"Great food. We got baked ziti, and the pasta combo. Mozzarella sticks too. The bread with the oil and tiny pizza strips are a great start that..."
Tommy Christianson
"Place can easily seat parties of 4 or less. The pizza here is sublime. The flavor for the pizza is unmatched and their other dishes are superb as..."
WKUK B
"Nice and local is the only way these days, love to support the small guy! This place is one of the few places that still serves a meal at a great..."
David S
"The best pizza, garlic knots and chicken rolls. Their salads are also fantastic and they don't skimp on the toppings. The staff is very helpful..."
Megan Gardner
"MULBERRY STREET has the best pizza and Italian food in town, and I am not exaggerating, I kid you not. I believe it is in the sauce. But that's me. I..."
Jayne Marrs
"Stopped in for dinner and had a nice meal. I had lasagna with some red wine. Great combo and both tasted excellent. The staff were very friendly..."
Art “A2Jr” Angst
"Some of the best pizza in town! The staff is as friendly as the owner Mike! It is always an enjoyable experience wether I dine in or..."
john ceramello
"I work with an individual with Autism and we come here for take out once a week. The staff is incredibly patient, friendly, and kind to us. Their..."
Dylan Owens
"Ever craving good pizza? This is the place to come. Also, awesome dining room with a great menu of lots..."
Jonathan Friely
"The food was great and the service was excellent. Nice place to eat..."
Bruce Fogel
"I attended a baby shower here. The food and service was very..."
Karen Silvestri (Inspired By God's Beauty)
"I’m here on vacation, a young lady named Angela She was super nice & very beautiful also VERY polite. Gave us our pizza and salads an asked us if..."
Samantha Tedesco
"This place has some of the best food on Long Island. The portions are huge and worth every penny. My favorite is the grilled chicken with spinach..."
Avanti Fugetaboutit Montana
"I am a very particular person when it comes to pizza and this pizza was amazing. From the crust to the cheese to the sauce it was so full of flavor...."
Grilled Shrimp Salad with Our Home Made Salad Dressing
Mushrooms Broccoli and Cherry Tomatoes Pizza
Baked Cavatelli
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Sausage Peppers and Onions Pizza
Grilled Vegetables
Chicken Francese over Spaghetti
Sausage and Peppers
Chicken Marsala
Seafood salad
Shrimp Scampi
Homemade Bread
Sausage Parmigiana
Lobsters
Riceballs
Chicken Piccata
Baked Clams
Pepperoni Broccoli and Spinach Pinwheels
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"This is the best pizzeria. Their food is excellent I especially love their white pizza If you haven’t tried thier food and pizza it’s a must...."
Emily Trotta Florenzo
"Best pizza in town! It's our local stop for a slice, but also a great little dine in. Delicious dinner and wine. Surprisingly good wine actually and..."
Erica Soto
"Delicious pizza and meals like my mom and grandmother would make! Everything great....soups, salads, pastas, chicken, ALL..."
Robert Flannigan
"Consistently great food and very accommodating. A pleasure to work with when trying to coordinate for larger groups! Thank..."
Dori Moore
"Fratelli's pizzeria is the best kept secret on Long Island. John, Vinny and Frank run a friendly family restaurant. Anyone interested in finding..."
John Pontacolone
"Been going there for over a decade, always a quality..."
Dan Seyler
"Sono bravissimi io ho mangiato da loro tutto buonissimo � ci tornetei sempre dai Fratelli pizzeria..."
Consiglia D'alba
"Been eating here for 6 years, great food & service...."
Mike Ferrari
"#1 pizza place on the planet! The service that these gentlemen provide is outstanding and unmatched by anyone else. Always can guarantee..."
Stephen Westby
"Very BEST pizza!! And awesome people, they treat you like family every..."
Kendra Anne Lombardi
"Perfect N.Y. pizza, this is what every one wants and transplanted New Yorker's dream..."
A V Haight Markham
"Best food I have ever eaten and the owner John Desiderio is a great guy and really knows how to treat his..."
Ryasn Pe
"Pizza and more pizza. Best in Long Island. Friendly staff and owners. Miss it..."
Art Basy
"First time here and wow it was good pizza! John the owner so friendly and welcoming. Definitely will be back to try his..."
Jim Casey
"Looks like your everyday pizza place but when you step inside you will see families sharing laughs while eating authentic dishes. The best homemade..."
Solow Sports
"Fratelli's Pizza is one of the best on Long Island in my opinion. The only bad thing is the service lacks courtesy a bit. Been going there for almost..."
Skyblazer
"I was recommended this place and it didn’t disappoint. Came with 3 of my friends and we loved it. Food was great and so was the hospitality. John..."
Ariel Kombor
"First time eating food from this establishment and I ordered through Uber Eats. I was a little hesitant because of my last two experiences ordering..."
Sharon Hendricks
"My son chose Fratelli's as the next restaurant on our pizza adventures. Great pizza, knots & service. We will definitely be..."
Vashti Persad
"Great spot for near NYC Pizza on Long Pennsinsula. Great selection of pizza and other staple Italian dishes and service that's top notch. Highly..."
Rich Haste
"Best shrimp parm I have ever had. This place is incredible. Everything is fresh and staff is so..."
Leandra Mueller
"Great family owned restaurant. Service and food was perfect. Baked clams were more clams oreganata, but were so good....I haf the monto carlo..."
desiree jackson
"Great food and service. They make you feel like family here. Will definitely..."
"This is real Italian food �, very good , people is very nice , they take good care of you , I recommend this place so bad . You has to come to..."
Joel Romero
"This is a great family restaurant, we love the food, specially the chicken Francese, is my..."
Sandra Colonna Van Dyck
"This place has the most amazing pizza
Come check it..."
Lorraine Ellis
"Been going here for over a decade and still by far the best and closest to NY pizza. All time favorite dish is the pene with vodka sauce and breaded..."
Kay Cee
"I got the chicken marsala pizza. They were extremely busy but still managed to get everyone served quickly. What a great place. Top quality food..."
Marc Cummings
"I don’t know what was in my pizza but this was the best Chicken bacon ranch slice I ever..."
Willian Curran
"Food is always good, favorite local spot for..."
Manolo ,
"Their dough is so delicious. The crust is not too thin or thick. They have a good variety of pizzas. Small for eating in. Reasonably priced and good..."
Jenny Ramirez
"Had 2 slices of barbecue pizza today and they were delicious. The flavor, crust, etc were all good to great. The place looked pleasant and family..."
Chery Kivens
"I’ve been coming here since I was 9, I’m almost 30. This is the best tasting pizzeria in Suffolk. It taste best when dining in because it’s..."
Glenn Terry
"Pizza was good. Service was good. Kid friendly..."
Tyrus Curtis
"My daughter's favorite pizza, it's just great food good service..."
Jonathan Gomez
"They're doing a great job not letting down Mamma Santina customers. Now that's a pretty tall order!
Cheese slice / Brooklyn slices are delicious..."
Nikhil Kini
"BEST EVER GREAT AND FRIENDLY SERVICE ALWAYS AND YUMMY DELISHHH BUON..."
Ricardo Melendez
"My first NY slice.. I swallowed down the wrong pipe right as I attempted to order. I sounded stupid and hoarse.. nonetheless even though I chose the..."
Darryl Wilson Jr
"First visit..Delicious, fresh gooey cheesy pizza, even at closing time!!! Crisp, tasty fresh. Old school pizza taste..clean restaurant [ kitchen and..."
"Its no longer called Joe's but the food was pretty good and the portion was pretty good for the..."
ozinmax
"Worth the ride from Ronkonkoma. Best pizza. Love the..."
Nadine Jacklyn
"Amazing! The food is great and the service..."
Gabriel
"Been getting pizza from here for as long as I can remember. The people running the restaurant are friendly and know how to have fun. Prices are good..."
Ahmed Mohammad
"Joe's Pasta & Pizza of Bay Shore (since 1973) is now
Marcony's Pizza & Pasta Ristorante. (This name is on the menus and website; the outdoor signs..."
guy 8118
"First time my wife and I had dinner at this local, family friendly, restaurant. . Although we've had great take out pizza, before. We had a mixed..."
Bob Mantione (Schoolteacher Bob)
"Place is awesome. Since new ownership not only has the food gotten better but the service has significantly improved. Super nice waitress and the mew..."
matt bardoo
"This place is good... really good. I used to just come for the slices which were decent, mostly out of convenience but even those have gotten better..."
Robert Conforte
"This place never fails to deliver on good quality pizza. I've been coming here since I was 5 & now the pizza tastes better than ever. Try the Drunken..."
Naomi Macchia
"I love Sicilian accents all day. Same ole Joe's pizza. Doesn't seem like anything has changed. Same pasta night. Great sauce. Great chicken roll......"
Zachery Sevier
"I came in here for the first time in over a year and was super impressed with the renovations they have made. The dining room actually looks like..."
kristen santoloci
"This was the nicest restaurant experience I’ve ever had. The food was amazing and the owners were some of the kindest people I’ve ever met!..."
Jacob Lancaster
"I lived in NY years ago, i remember when this place had just 1 shop, and around 10 or so customers when me, mom, and dad walked in... in my opinion,..."
Raydiance Stenson
"Pizza is great and staff is even better. Went in here for the first time and the place was super clean and everyone was so friendly. I even shared..."
Alexis Waldron
"They make a sweet sauce pie definitely worth trying there sausage and peppers slice is better then most others there chicken parm pie is definitely..."
Marc Komornik
"Videos of clothes place so the convenience is normal and a great as well. Who there isn't that bad since like I only love my teeth pizza so it's..."
"It was my husband and I first time there and we absolutely loved the Supreme pie we ordered. We will definitely be regulars at Salvatore's. Can't..."
Lori Martin
"Atmosphere was very nice and cozy. The service was excellent. The food was delicious and the staff was very friendly. Excellent place to bring family..."
Leresa Pearson
"Napoleon. I mean it was good yes, but did they take one piece of basil and tear it up? I was expecting a little more from such a nice place. I'll..."
Alexea Rivera
"Worst pizza I have had. What happened ?This was my go to place when I wanted a brick oven pizza. Extremely soggy and thin pizza. Barely any basil..."
Maria Velez
"I stopped in for lunch and had the Baked Ziti Salvatore. It was a bit soupy for my taste and the tiny bits of sausage were kind of a disappointment...."
J F
"We got the neopalitin and loved it! They serve it so hot that you need to let it rest for about five or 10 minutes. The garlic bread was awesome!..."
Nick Bierman
"Omg the best pizza ever!!! I did half white/half Napolian and the greek salad with the tastiest olives- to. die. for!!! My bf raved about the baked..."
Kary D
"Our recent dining experience at The Pie at Salvatore's in Bay Shore was a culinary marvel. From the moment we entered, the tantalizing aroma of..."
James Wood
"A long time spot of ours for over 8 years.... Great for family & friends to enjoy nice meal comfortable & nice restaurant, and a great Pie. As well..."
Joy Be
"Consistently the BEST pie and food around.. They use Real mozzarella which is so good! Calzones the size of the box
If you’re not happy with..."
"i order from here every wednesday and they never miss. it's one of the best tasting pizza i've ever tried 10/10 totally..."
Carterisbad
"Owners/staff are friendly and courteous, their food is delicious, they serve the community well..."
Karen Small
"I have been coming here for the past 30 years .Everything in here is good .It is the same owners all those years .Very nice people..."
Thomas Macdowall
"Victorios one, on 27. Absolutely the best Pizza anywhere I have ever been and you always get friendly service.
8/5/22 Ordered a chicken Alfredo, ..."
Harry D
"Always nice, great food. Go at least once a..."
matt honings
"Great food and service. The bad reviews are all written by..."
Michael
"I have ordered from this place numerous times and it’s always great!! Thank you for the great pizza and the sense of community you get every time u..."
Ashlee Burke
"They cheap on the marina for garlic knots BUT this hands down the best regular slice pizza around. Ain’t no Thiccccc sauce, but a nice thin squirt..."
Destiny Sulima
"Argentina pizza was excellent. Made me feel like I was in Buenos..."
Steven Crawford
"The pizza here is the best we have ever had. 1/2 Sausage round pie. If you like sausage you will be very happy. Believe me. My wife just said WOW..."
David Wilt
"Surprised the pizza was as good as it was one of the best slices I’ve had will come..."
XavierAlien
"I've been going to this restaurant since I was in junior high school and the pizza still taste the same😍😍😍😍😍👌. I love the pizza and..."
Tiana
"Always enjoy there pizza. Always come..."
diane parker
"My absolute favorite pizza place, I was born and raised right behind that shopping center. They have the best pizza I have ever had. They have..."
James Capodiferro
"Really good food at a decent price ! The linguine and mushroom sauce is a must-try ! So next time you're in the mood for pizza you should stop by ,..."
Amazing Mussels with Roasted Peppers Red Onion Garlic & Butter
Pasta
Pesto
Pizza
caesar salad
Eggplant Parmigiana
Garlic bread
Veal Marsala
Minestrone soup
Garlic Knots
Chicken special
Paella
Pasta
Baked Manicotti
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Great food. We got baked ziti, and the pasta combo. Mozzarella sticks too. The bread with the oil and tiny pizza strips are a great start that..."
Tommy Christianson
"Place can easily seat parties of 4 or less. The pizza here is sublime. The flavor for the pizza is unmatched and their other dishes are superb as..."
WKUK B
"Nice and local is the only way these days, love to support the small guy! This place is one of the few places that still serves a meal at a great..."
David S
"The best pizza, garlic knots and chicken rolls. Their salads are also fantastic and they don't skimp on the toppings. The staff is very helpful..."
Megan Gardner
"MULBERRY STREET has the best pizza and Italian food in town, and I am not exaggerating, I kid you not. I believe it is in the sauce. But that's me. I..."
Jayne Marrs
"Stopped in for dinner and had a nice meal. I had lasagna with some red wine. Great combo and both tasted excellent. The staff were very friendly..."
Art “A2Jr” Angst
"Some of the best pizza in town! The staff is as friendly as the owner Mike! It is always an enjoyable experience wether I dine in or..."
john ceramello
"I work with an individual with Autism and we come here for take out once a week. The staff is incredibly patient, friendly, and kind to us. Their..."
Dylan Owens
"Ever craving good pizza? This is the place to come. Also, awesome dining room with a great menu of lots..."
Jonathan Friely
"The food was great and the service was excellent. Nice place to eat..."
Bruce Fogel
"I attended a baby shower here. The food and service was very..."
Karen Silvestri (Inspired By God's Beauty)
"I’m here on vacation, a young lady named Angela She was super nice & very beautiful also VERY polite. Gave us our pizza and salads an asked us if..."
Samantha Tedesco
"This place has some of the best food on Long Island. The portions are huge and worth every penny. My favorite is the grilled chicken with spinach..."
Avanti Fugetaboutit Montana
"I am a very particular person when it comes to pizza and this pizza was amazing. From the crust to the cheese to the sauce it was so full of flavor...."
"Great service, good people ,and great pizza shop. I will return to amore..."
Eric Schwarz
"Always great food and great service from a place that also supports the community. Thank..."
Bill Rb
"Best pizza around says my son who’s tried pizza..."
Christa Riccaldo Ramos
"Amore took care of our cub scouts tonight. The boys made their own pizzas and had a great time. What a great restaurant to have in our..."
Kim Morrison-Gannon
"Love Amore Pizzeria!!! They catered a couple of parties for me!!! Food was delicious and my family raved about it!! We especially love their..."
Jamie Carlino
"Food is amazing!! Great atmosphere and service is..."
Jeff Cohen
"Best pizza we've ever had! My son made me drive from North Babylon so he can come back and enjoy another..."
Shannon Ticas
"Definitely gives you the old-school pizzeria feel. The locals are there and are super nice. You have the young kids working behind the counter who..."
Angelina D
"The Best Most Delicious Philly Cheesesteak Pizza & The Best Zeppole !! Very Friendly Like it Says ..Amore & Mangia..."
Dawn Howard
"Best pizza on Long Island hands down the staff is amazing, hand made pizza pop slices in house by the old man! Is a must try! and your treated like..."
Brian Layne
"Great food, we catered my sons graduation party very happy rodrigo delivered the food an was a great help thank..."
w kearney
"Great service, great guys! Had a ziti slice with three garlic knots and two pepperoni bites. Thank..."
Rob Sep
"Best pizzza in town! I’ve never been disappointed in the slightest. And the staff are some of the nicest..."
mckayla mowbray
"Got catering for an event. Guests complimented the delicious food. Service was great (and you can order the catering online through Slice). Would,..."
Jonathan Russell
"This is by far the best pizza place on long Island. We are treated like family when we come here and the entire staff is absolutely amazing. ..."
Jessica Redding
"I ordered trays of chicken piccata, rigatoni alavodka and wings!!!! So so good!!! I love amore! They never..."
Dawn
"My husband stops in once every other month.
To get my to go order... in Florida. They make the best food. Nothing comes close down here..
They made..."
Jennifer ODonovan
"Traditional Pizza place. Love there Philly cheese steak pie...."
Frank Howard
"Wow..finally an Excellent Pizzeria ..
"Amore"
I've lived all over LI,,this is the best pizza on LI!?
I live in Sayville and drive to Bay Shore when..."
SAM
"First of all. The name of this restaurant is perfect. The employees did their jobs very well and gave me a strong impression of family, hard work and..."
Robert Rosado
"There are times in life when we all change the way we eat something. Are you the kind of person who first eats the marshmallows out of Lucky Charms?..."
J F
"My husband catered the food for my birthday celebration on 10/22 in Lindenhurst and it was delicious. We want to thank Rich for being honest with us..."
Specialty Pizza with Olives Mushrooms Possibly Yellow Peppers
Pepperoni Bacon Cheese Jalapeños Garlic Sauce
Cauliflower Crust Pizza Vegetarian
Pizza Spot
Orange Soft Drink
Meat Lovers Pizza
Hot Pot
Brisket
Blood Orange Lemonade
caesar salad
Red Vine Pizza
Blaze Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza with Pepperoni and Bacon
Juice
BBQ Sauce Chicken and Peppers
BBQ Chicken
Double Cheese and Double Pepperoni
Fast food
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Google couldn’t wait for me to review. Sent me request by the time I got home. I’ve been here once before after it first opened. Sorry it took me..."
Joe Vigna
"Excellent little pizza shop. The shop offers a multitude of selection in terms of what kind of pizza you want. They have several different cheeses,..."
Christian Acevedo
"I brought my girls because of a school fundraiser. They didn't disappoint. Even though they were swamped with both in-person and online orders, the..."
Kate Kearney
"Chipotle of pizza basically, build your own and they cook it on the spot. Pizza wasn't the highest quality but it was pretty cheap and they have a..."
Tom Dascole
"Hands down, this place has the BEST pizza! I love it when I'm able to customize my own pizza and this place has everything you can think of. The..."
Dawn Williams
"Busy location... So upset they closed the 1 in west Babylon!!! Please open it back up!!! Amazing..."
Michael greco
"It's exactly what you expect. Tons of toppings, a thin crispy crust and fast pizza. Got zero complaints. No surprises and the pizza is good just get..."
WKUK B
"Just ate a whole pie to myself because I Dared to Be Daring. It was BBQ chicken pepperoni, onions and banana peppers. Love the char to the crust just..."
FREDDYG_NY
"I visited this place yesterday and its great I love pizza 🍕 and they are really friendly.
Yummy..."
Axel Xavier
"Wait was long but was worth the wait will just go not at dinner..."
Debra Domino
"Great service pizza was good love you can put whatever you want on the pizza and ingredients were of good..."
Joseph Lanzarotta
"First time and won't be my last. I'm very very picky about pizza since going to Vegas years ago and having pizza at 800 degrees (no longer at the sls..."
Shenae Campbell
"This place is amazing. Everything is fresh, the service was great and the price is..."
annette del monte
"Very good pizza. I thing I could eat this every day. The build your own is a great value. You can
Put as much as you want on of any topping.
There..."
"Food is always made to perfection. So many options I mostly loved there hot wings. Great people great..."
tesjr1
"The pizza lunch special is $5.99 until 3pm for two plain slices and a fountain soda. I grabbed two specials for myself and a friend. We definitely..."
T. Doug.
"Quick in and out. Reasonable prices clean and adequate..."
Lewis Henninger
"The pizza was delicious and the counter person was very..."
Antoinette VanSchaick
"Good pizza and still affordable!
Wednesday special
$14.99 large pie, garlic knots and zepolies!
Highly..."
Kristal Biscardi
"Very very very good chicken rolls!!! One of the best I've had.
Delicious pizza 🍕. You can get with a "garlic knot" crust that's amazing.
Variety..."
Shannon Aurigema
"This pizza place has been around for years and hands down the BEST pizza on the island. The owner is so sweet nice and funny and a down to earth good..."
Tracy Wood
"Love the white slice from this place! (All of the food is amazing..."
Danny Garcia
"Very friendly pretty clean place good service I've bin buying pizza here before it was victorios and the pizza and hero's ices all..."
Marc Komornik
"Excellent pizza!!
Ordered a Wednesday night special for the first time and pizza was delicious . There was a slight issue with delivery but the made..."
Joseph Pupino
"My sister introduced me to Victorio II Pizzeria on 11/18.
Magnifico and DELICIOSO!!!
So glad she did because their food is the epitome of fresh. And..."
Melissa Bostick
"Garlic knot pie is a must try when you go
Here. Great staff very friendly always happy to
Order from..."
joe Dabs
"The pizza was delicious but the dark haired woman behind the counter last Tuesday was rude, dismissive when I thanked her. She definitely did not..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes