Best cheese pizza in Bay Shore

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Mustangs' -- Da Chicken Spot
Mustangs' -- Da Chicken Spot
89/100 (241 ratings)
Restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Fried chicken
cheese pizza
Gyro Sandwich
Hamburger
Chicken Wings
Half Beef Pepperoni Half Regular Pie
Beef Patty with Mozzarella Cheese
"I got my order fairly quick customer service (cashier) were extremely friendly and very easy to understand , food was an absolute 10/10 come here..."
Prism Act
"Bought a half pepperoni/half regular pie, lamb gyro, and 2 double cheeseburgers.... The owner was so scared when I showed up for some reason, I..."
Syed Atif Ali (Long Island Nomad)
"The chicken here is sooooo good!! For years I’ve been buying food here and its the same since day one!! Great food and the owner is so nice and..."
SMD D
"Great food, loved coming here for years. Same food same amazing taste. Amazing hot wings and gyro, many chicken specials to meet your..."
Amy Medina Flores
"Favorite fried chicken/comfort food place to go to on the ENTIRE island. Authentic quality, friendly staff and the owner MO is an amazing guy. You..."
Matt Cusack
"Amazing food, amazing food quality, very friendly staff, I’ve been coming here for years, always my go to..."
Ilmar Hernandez
"I’ve been coming here for 15 years and counting. From the food to the service of staff, all is amazing! I highly recommend..."
Sohrab Noori
"Absolutely best place that has the most crispy and flavorful chicken. I don’t go anywhere..."
Allie Hart
"the chicken was mad good and it smelled good i recommend the beef patty’s with mozzarella and pepperoni , the hamburger is also really..."
Ashleyy
"Great food. Great service. I love the variety of food. Love how they use healthy oil to fry the food as well. Have nothing but great things to..."
Victor Severino
"We just went yesterday and it was delicious we had the chicken breast sandwich, cheeseburger, and philly cheese stake. Highly recommend. The only..."
Sunny A
"Really Good Food. Good Crew with Excellent Customer Service. Should gave them six stars if there was a option. Highly..."
Mahfuz Shafi Choudhury
"Amazing pizza with great marinara sauce with delicious taste, great mozzarella sticks with..."
Amy Flores
Joe's Pasta & Pizza
Joe's Pasta & Pizza
84/100 (546 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Dinner
Lunch
Brooklyn Pie
Veal Saltimbocca Yummmnm
Angel Hair Pasta Parmesan with Shrimp
Carbonara Specialty Pasta
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Salmon Steak
Mussels Marinara
Cappuccino
Garlic bread
Tagliatelle
cheese pizza
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Chicken roll
Shrimp Parmigiana
Chicken parmigiana
Sicilian Pizza Slice
BBQ Chicken Pie
Shrimp Oreganata
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Its no longer called Joe's but the food was pretty good and the portion was pretty good for the..."
ozinmax
"Worth the ride from Ronkonkoma. Best pizza. Love the..."
Nadine Jacklyn
"Amazing! The food is great and the service..."
Gabriel
"Been getting pizza from here for as long as I can remember. The people running the restaurant are friendly and know how to have fun. Prices are good..."
Ahmed Mohammad
"Joe's Pasta & Pizza of Bay Shore (since 1973) is now Marcony's Pizza & Pasta Ristorante. (This name is on the menus and website; the outdoor signs..."
guy 8118
"First time my wife and I had dinner at this local, family friendly, restaurant. . Although we've had great take out pizza, before. We had a mixed..."
Bob Mantione (Schoolteacher Bob)
"Place is awesome. Since new ownership not only has the food gotten better but the service has significantly improved. Super nice waitress and the mew..."
matt bardoo
"This place is good... really good. I used to just come for the slices which were decent, mostly out of convenience but even those have gotten better..."
Robert Conforte
"This place never fails to deliver on good quality pizza. I've been coming here since I was 5 & now the pizza tastes better than ever. Try the Drunken..."
Naomi Macchia
"I love Sicilian accents all day. Same ole Joe's pizza. Doesn't seem like anything has changed. Same pasta night. Great sauce. Great chicken roll......"
Zachery Sevier
"I came in here for the first time in over a year and was super impressed with the renovations they have made. The dining room actually looks like..."
kristen santoloci
"This was the nicest restaurant experience I’ve ever had. The food was amazing and the owners were some of the kindest people I’ve ever met!..."
Jacob Lancaster
"I lived in NY years ago, i remember when this place had just 1 shop, and around 10 or so customers when me, mom, and dad walked in... in my opinion,..."
Raydiance Stenson
"Pizza is great and staff is even better. Went in here for the first time and the place was super clean and everyone was so friendly. I even shared..."
Alexis Waldron
"They make a sweet sauce pie definitely worth trying there sausage and peppers slice is better then most others there chicken parm pie is definitely..."
Marc Komornik
"Videos of clothes place so the convenience is normal and a great as well. Who there isn't that bad since like I only love my teeth pizza so it's..."
Lisbeth Ortega Sanchez