Best Crab cakes in Bay Shore

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Coastal Kitchen And Daiquiri Bar
Coastal Kitchen And Daiquiri Bar
86/100 (1248 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Seafood
Pub
Dinner
Lunch
Coastal IPA
The Lobster Roll
The Cubano Sandwich
cerveza
Guacamole
Piña colada
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Green salad
Rum Punch
Poke Bowl
Steamed Mussels
Mojitos
Fish Tacos
Juice
Surf and Turf Burger
Crab cakes
Classic Mussels
Lobster Quesadilla
Grilled Cheese & Fries
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"PSA: Get here immediately! Fabulous food, delicious drinks, and an amazing atmosphere. More casual than their sister restaurant Verde, but food and..."
Remy Torsiello
"Great spot! Drinks are on point and the atmosphere is awesome! They have pool, dart and other bar games towards the back of the bar. Great laid back..."
Robert Anthony
"The concept is to feel like you are hanging in a laid back spot along the coast. It totally works. Nice seafood menu options. Tropical inspired..."
Stacy L Niessing
"Great new place! Went with 6 couples and played shuffle board and pool. The food was great. The appetizer menu could be expanded because you want..."
Claudia Trinceri Kavitt
"This place is absolutely gorgeous and the food was so damn good !!! The coastal burger was probably the best burger I’ve had in a long time !!! And..."
Kimberly Palanisamy
"This place is phenomenal! Exactly what Bayshore needed. Exquisite food, outstanding atmosphere and superb bartenders! All with an island vibe...."
Jay FitzPatrick
"The cocktail list rocks!! Try the Oaxacan Zombie Swizzle - off the hook!! The food is so flavorful, a fav is the miso & black garlic..."
Tara Fedozzi
"The best cocktails in Long Island! Staff is superb! Super friendly and so accomodating! Overall a great atmosphere and great..."
Marissa Tartaglia
"Bayshore is lucky to have a gem like this! Just got back from one of my most favorite Beaches, St.Augustine in Florida and I swear I was back there..."
Chanda Misevis
"Great service. The decor is so cool. It is a must go to. Had the chicken jerky sandwich -..."
Marie Dlouhy Allmendinger
"Very cool place, need to try the rum punch they sneak up on..."
Brian Zweifler
"Best staff, best drinks! Excellent..."
Abby Marinescu
"Love this place! Great drinks, delicious food and awesome..."
Nancy Ann
"I would like to thank Joe for accommodating my Birthday party of 15 in such short notice. I was able to bring balloons and decor for the table..."
Tania Reyes
"There are 2 Coastal experiences. 1 is the inside dining where the music is loud and crowded and young people having fun. Then there's 2 where you..."
Executive Group Realty
"Daiquiri is my new favorite. I'm glad it was suggested by the waitress. One drink, and I felt the rum 😄. Also happy I chose fried for my chicken..."
Vashti Persad
"Jerk chicken bowl and lobster quesadillas (not pictured) were bangin. Frozen drinks were just OK, have had..."
Robert Torossian
"Have the Classic Marg and the Jerk chicken quesadilla with street corn. Chef's kiss. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent..."
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
"A wonderful use of space, bare walls and ceilings really opens the place up. Dart boards, a pool table and shuffleboard makes it a fun spot for a..."
kebby koppe
"Food was good. Service a little slow A little to loud for dinner.. Should keep music a little lower during dinner hours then blast it after 10:30 or..."
Chris Leon
"Bloody Mary’s with Tito’s tasted delicious. Plates are clean and food smells amazing! I definitely recommend this place! Waiters were all super..."
Antonio Clavijo
"First time here tonight and had a great time. Place is decorated well and the ambience is perfect for a weekend evening out with friends. There are..."
Lord Admiral Lee
"Hands down best service, drinks, and food. This place is absolutely phenomenal. The bar tender, Joe was fantastic, seriously one of the best..."
A A
"Bustling lively spot on MainSt with Thai infused cuisine at rusticly industrial spacious restaurant perfect for lunch, meeting up for drinks at the..."
Johan Chabrel
Nicky's On The Bay
Nicky's On The Bay
70/100 (2469 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Seafood
American
Bar
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Clam Chowder
Tacos
Linguine & White Clam Sauce Coming Soon
8 Ounces Burger and Fries
moscow mule
Steamers
Cakes
Crab
Shrimp Tacos
Fish
Clams
Pot Roast
Mojito
Oyster
Shrimp Scampi
caesar salad
Calamari
Fried Seafood
Burger
Crab cakes
Mussels
Fish & Chips
Hamburgers
Tuna
Buffalo Wings
Calamares
Fried Clams
Salmon
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
East Coast Oysters
Shrimp
Warm Lobster Roll
Crab Cake
Nicky's Fried Calamari
Lobster
Chowder
Mussel Pot Du Jour
Lobster Roll
Lobster Roll Sweet Potato Fries and Cole Slaw
Salad
Tapas
Free Range Chicken Paillard
Sit down
Bar
American
Seafood
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Reservations
Television
Live Music
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Had a great day here ! Southbound played here upstairs on the roof ! What a beautiful view ! The crowd there was awesome both line Dancers & people..."
Elizabeth Byrne
"Breathtaking view, great music and great food. Loved it and can't wait to go back. I wish there was a more extensive menu for rooftop..."
John Lennon
"If your going here for a gourmet meal, turn around, if your gonna bitch about the prices, stay home. This is where you go to enjoy the best thing..."
Charles D'Angelo
"First, the view and atmosphere are perfect. The server I had was excellent and the shrimp scampi was as good as I've ever had. I will definitely come..."
Mark Mariano
"Great place and the food was delicious! Our waiter was outstanding and so friendly! I believe his name wad CJ-sorry if I got the name wrong. We were..."
Rosemarie Mccarthy
"We love Nicky's on the Bay! Great atmosphere, good food and the owner Nicky always makes time to say hello & introduce himself to any new people we..."
Dana Persico
"Excellent food and view! Good variety on the menu. Friendly..."
Felicia Rybak Adorno
"This was my first time here and everything about this place was amazing! We sat outside and watched all the ferries go by while sipping a delicious..."
Michele Stokes
"The food is still amazing and spectacular service and a nice view of the ferries and boats! This time around I was able to have a perfect view of..."
Shenera Boodie
"omg !this is best seafood restaurant I ever been to!oyster is so fresh! Personally I hate oysters! But I had half dozen! That’s how fresh..."
wayne weng
"This new food they have is light years ahead of the old menu. We had the burger, lobster roll, chop chop salad, and salmon with a few apps. Thanks to..."
kenny powers
"Nice place on the water to watch the boats come and go. Baked clams and calamari were very good. I had fish and chips, which were good. My husband..."
Deborah Carleton-Tierney
"First I would like to give a shout out to Sherry our waitress for the outstanding service and the small talk we shared. Everything was beyond..."
Brett “El Guerrero” Harte
"Fantastic food. From the first to the last bite it was absolutely delicious. I had the special which was the salmon w summer pasta. I loved it. The..."
Jessica Seegolam
"We loved it. The fried clams are their specialty and the portion was huge. Great prices too. Everything was covid safe and the service was on point...."
Annie Pisapia
"Nestled beautifully along the water's edge, Nicky's On the Bay is a beacon for those seeking an exceptional dining experience combined with..."
Const Const
"Definitely coming back to Nicky's for Fried Calamari (tasted fresh and was crispy), Steamed Mussels (delicious!), and crab cakes! I ordered the..."
J K
"Very nice place next to the water.I had to wait a bit on the waiting list.But the wait was worth it.The food was very tasty.A bit pricey though.But..."
Tatiana Panova
"Very romantic, food was extremely fresh, homemade dipping sauces extremely fresh great quality, professional and persistent staff. Beautiful scenery,..."
Davina Wynn
"Great location on the water, food was delicious and service was very attentive. They had long island Vinyard wine, which was a nice surprise. Perfect..."
Matt Beriloff