Best Sandwiches in Bay Shore

3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Ajs Grilled Cheese
Ajs Grilled Cheese
88/100 (2620 ratings)
Quick Bites
American
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Grilled cheese
"I love the Mac and Cheese grilled cheese. It was so good. Very cheesy the fries was good as well.... Crunchy and nice. The sauce was great too , I..."
Joanna Moran
"Ordered the grilled cheese with bacon and apple which was just what I expected/wanted. Tried my friends’ orders and they all tasted amazing and..."
Tony del Rio
"The food is as good as the service. Friendly blonde employee welcomed us and gave us a great run down of the menu. We took her suggestions and they..."
Johnny Malloy
"This place was really nice. We ordered a small mac and cheese with the crispy buffalo chicken, a large mac and cheese with the crispy buffalo chicken..."
Sara Lopez
"This place is great. Prices can get a little up there but I've posted picture of the small versus large Mac and cheese entrees. I got the large and..."
Luis Lopez
"Love love love it here. Food is great, workers are awesome. Thanks for making an awesome..."
Kenny Tax (Long Island Foodies)
"Ordered an apple bacon cheddar sandwich to go on my break. It was delicious and the house made chips were amazing! The price was great and the food..."
Melissa Kopacska
"Delicious grilled cheese sandwiches. Sweet potato tater tots are..."
Christine McGovern, LMT
"Picture doesn't even do it justice. This place always puts out great quality food. The staff is always friendly, and the enviornment is always clean..."
Casey
"Delicious. I had lobster seafood grilled cheese with tater tots, both were great. The potato chips were delicious and not greasy. The jalapeno..."
Marc H
"Cute, clean and yummy! They don't only do grilled cheese there are also salads and soups. I work with food safety so if a place isn't clean I walk..."
Lucy sanchez
"I love the sandwiches here. This place is new to my area so I got a pretty reasonable groupon for several discounted sandwiches. I loved the lobster..."
Latisha Murray
"Tater tots are a work of art. Good Sammie's. Chips are..."
Amy Nowacoski
"Absolutely delicious food. The sweet potatoes fries were amazing, and we accidentally got a few sweet potato tater tots which were on another level...."
Steve Esposito
"Good service, plentiful food. Good specials. When I paid my bill I told the owner my potato was cold and said not to worry, but he ran right into the..."
Ted Reich
Cyrus: Chai & Coffee Company
Cyrus: Chai & Coffee Company
86/100 (314 ratings)
Coffee & Tea
Coffee & Tea
Cafe
Cafe
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Café
Café
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
"Always a great place to relax with an unbelievable cup of coffee. The Zimbabwe is my personal favorite. The staff is what makes this place truly..."
Mark Mizrab
"This place is great! The staff is so friendly, and the coffee always always tastes amazing! I use to go to starbucks and would get disappointed over..."
Michelle Mendez
"Great place and even better coffee!!! The Hawaii is my favorite and the Brazil is a favorite of a lot of my..."
Mare Sherie
"This place is so awesome like there's no words to describe how awesome the place, atmosphere, people, coffee, tea, and food. Just everything about..."
Daniel Torres
"Intricate selection of coffee. Samples to smell were spot on with the flavor of the brew. Definitely will be back. More people should check this..."
Christian Alexander
"Dropped by today to give Cyrus a try. What a refreshing taste on a modern coffee house. Easily the best cup of coffee I have ever had. Highly..."
Michael Wick
"Very cozy amazing place! Delicious chai tea. The owner it's there and he's so good making the drinks! This cafe it's a must come back!..."
Rodrigo Cisi Rubio
"I love this place. The tea is super delicious and baristas are extremely friendly, kind and welcoming. Wouldn't go anywhere..."
MaryAnn McKay Giannettino
"I got a sneak preview tonight!! Thinking it was already open, I stopped by. Cyrus saw me at the door and let me in so I could see the wonderful place..."
Tom Capasso
"They are Absolutely Amazing. Great atmosphere. Great Staff. Great Coffee of Course. I Love this..."
Lisa Scott Spence
"The coffee is perfect and the staff is very..."
Christina Fatigati
"I've never had a chilled Japanese brew coffee... until today. And I had it at the train station. I'm speechless. That could be the best cup of..."
Ben Vaughn
"My fave spot! The ambiance, decor and awesome coffees makes it worthwhile to spend an afternoon..."
Cee C Elle
"I love it!! So peaceful and love the smell of the coffee😍The stuff are so wonderful and frendly..."
Damarys Sorto
"There are few people who have vision as this man does. The end result is bound to be an outstanding place. Simply..."
Tom Ciccarelli
Milk & Sugar Cafe
Milk & Sugar Cafe
74/100 (329 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Cafe
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Salad
Omelette
"Cozy Restaurant!. A different kind of restaurant, with couches and low tables as well as traditional seatings. like being in a comfortable living..."
Acava
"Mmmm. Cute place, good..."
ComeSailAway
"Great. Pricey but, great... downgraded the menu a bit since I was there last but overall a..."
Doug
"Good food, great atmosphere. While the food here is very good (though a little on the pricey side), the atmosphere is amazing. Where else can you sit..."
ClockworkSoul
"I love this place, but try to get a table on a Fri. or Sat. night. No reservations are taken and you can wait, sometimes out in the cold & rain for..."
Go Fish
"Milk and Sugar Café might sound like just a tea or coffee shop but don't let the name fool you like it fooled us. Initially we were just going to..."
Long Island Restaurant Review
"Me and my two friends went there for dessert. We were a little thrown off by couches and the lighting was unsettling, but I would definitely go back...."
Cansel Cebeci
"I just hosted my daughter's baby shower this weekend at Milk & Sugar's "Victorian Room." It was an amazing day for all, especially my daughter. With..."
Lou Schilling
"I love the burgers, buns and the cute little bottles of ketchup. I haven't dined in as yet. However, it would be very romantic and cozy to do so. I..."
Hassan M.
"I can not say enough amazing things about the Victorian room. The service, the staff, the food the setting ... all beyond my expectations. My..."
Edie Longo
"I had my daughters bridal shower in the Victorian room. The communication with the catering department wasn't up to par, but the service was top..."
janet dibartolo
"Saturday Lunch. Patrons 98% female. Artichoke Dip watered down. Had Filet Mignon/Asparagus/Gorgonzola Mashed Potatoes. Filet was perfect. ..."
Jeff Johnston
"Cute tea-themed spot with homey chairs and furniture. Came for brunch and had a really nice belgian waffle as well as a huge delicious omelette...."
Denise Dang
"Very nice Victorian furniture to sit on while you enjoy a sandwich, wrap, or burger. A little pricey, for example it's $5 for a cappuccino, but the..."
Luis Alicea
"Cozy and awesome place and the food and deserts are equally..."
Vaughn Hong Ping
"Well worth the time spent - delicious food. Enjoy This spot as the top brunch on Long..."
William Kucmierowski (Brimstone)
"Went there last night after a show and we all enjoyed the food and relaxing atmosphere. Will visit again when in the..."
Cathy Ginley