Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Beach Haven

6 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Carols Organic Eatery
Carols Organic Eatery
96/100 (132 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Healthy
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
"This little eatery is Absolutely Phenomenal!!!! I am not even sure how to begin to review this wonderfully amazing place. I am a full-fledged vegan..."
Elissa Herbert
"I heard some great things about this place from friends, so thought I’d make a detour from my London to New York holiday to check it out. Believe..."
Will Chan
"I'm so impressed by this place. It's an unpretentious family restauran on LBI where I've had some of my favourite vegan food. The owners are very..."
Javier Camino
"Great food. Food is made fresh to order Everytime. Rolling deserts which is great for anyone who's eats vegan. Vegan cheese cake that is amazing...."
Elliott Pew
"The food at carols is beyond amazing! I got a pizza with vegan cheese and a vegan cheese cake. The cheese cake was one of the best desserts I’ve..."
Laura Bemis
"The best food on the island, hands down. The pizza is incredible. My girlfriend had the veggie burger, fantastic! The food is organic; the small..."
Anthony Massa
"Food is really good. Everything I've tried has been really yummy. The pizza is my favorite! Great sauce and thin crust. The decor is a little..."
Caroline Marcucci
"From one Newark Italian to another, this place is amazing...the bread, sauce and the atmosphere is top notch. The food is outstanding and the people..."
Dino D.
"Wonderful food made by a friendly wife and husband. Everything is vegan except the mozzarella cheese which is vegetarian. We had a delicious beyond..."
Sean Legg
"Great food. Always something different on the menu, even coming back to back days Carol and her husband changed things up, and every dish has been..."
Brian McCrystal
California Grill & Pizza
California Grill & Pizza
84/100 (612 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Soups
American
Vegan Options
Soups
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Beef Tacos
Cheesesteak
Burger
Tuna Salad
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Fries with Cheese
Grill Burger
Salad
Clam Chowder
Calamari
Cheesesteak
Calamares
Bread Bowl
Chowder
Tapas
Tacos
Sit down
Pizza
American
Soups
BYOB
Seating
Table Service
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Excellent food. The wraps were great and they had gluten free wraps available which we loved. Great side salad (as an alternative to fries) as..."
Brendan Hennessy
"Love this place. We always eat here when st lbi. We love their chowder (we get it mixed) with a slice of pizza. Their Cajun fries are delicious along..."
Rob Novack
"Had a great dinner at California grill! Got the burger and grilled chicken sandwich, both were great! But the real winner was the server, who I think..."
Sam Avila
"Their wings are so freaking good Nice and crispy very well done I would like to come again to this place and I recommend to my family and..."
Felix Luis De Jesus
"Great place for a meal. Our family has been going there for years. Great service and selection. This past week, I had a cheesesteak that was..."
George D
"Been coming here for years, chowder is great and most of the food is good. The mozzarella sticks have recently been changed, and in my opinion have..."
Tango Mango
"Great service. Quick and easy. The clam chowders are awesome. Grilled Tuna sandwich simple,clean and delicious. My comfort food favorite is the..."
Joseph Lavelli
"This place is awesome. The food is always great and the staff is always..."
Nicholas Mazzarella
"Went to California grill on a Friday night, went back the next night because we enjoyed the food so..."
Steve Popik
"The best clam chowder(NE and..."
Kristine Lima
"Easy place to go to for a casual meal. Never to wait to be seated, never empty either, good food, fantastic..."
Danilo Carbone
"It was the best crab cake I have ever had! Loaded with chunks of crab, perfectly seasoned, perfectly cooked while magically being held together with..."
Janine P
"Its a little Burger/Pizza joint that serves a good Bacon Cheese burger. We didn’t have Pizza but we did have their Fried Calamari which i thought..."
Plansito Diaz
"Very nice friendly place to be.. everything was delicious. Probably the best chicken burrito I've had in a long time "wish I would have got one to..."
Billy Finch
Bay Village Pizza
Bay Village Pizza
82/100 (382 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Pepperoni
Sampler Platter
Large Cheese Pizza
Seasoned Fries
Tomato Pie
Fresh Cut Fries
Whole Pie Peppers and Onions
Sit down
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"V good pizza, took 20 minutes to get a 18inch classic cheese but there were plenty of places to window shop at while we..."
Gabrielle
"Very good Pizza, Even with it being a Friday night around 6pm, ordered and was served my Pizza within 15 mins. Crust was very good, and pepperoni was..."
Diane Ski
"Bay Village Pizza is a local treasure! Their pizzas are a slice of perfection, with a thin crust that's perfectly crispy. The sauce is flavorful, and..."
Poughkeepsie 360
"First time going to to Bay Village Pizza after usually eating at panzones. Living full time in North Jersey where pizza is an art, I can tell you ..."
William L
"No frills, walk-up pizza joint. Quite popular so it gets pretty busy. Expect to wait even if the line is not that long. Seems to be located smack..."
D. Ramirez
"the fresh cut fries never disappoint and pizza is good sometimes.. fries take a little while but pizza is almost immediate but they do tell you that..."
hi hi
"Quick! Clean! Good food! Be patient as this is a hot spot to grab a quick bite in the hot town ! But food is very good! Been coming here for 15..."
C C (Honest Reviewer)
"Pizza was fantastic! My favorite on the island! Line was long, so definitely recommend calling ahead. They had a pick up window so was easy to..."
Jason Schorr
"An average pizza joint but with HUGE slices of pizza and great fries which I recommend getting which cheese. Great place to have a quick meal..."
Brendan
"Pizza was pretty good, and the slices were nice and big, but toppings were barely..."
Sean Aldrich
"Best pizza on LBI. Pies and slices are HUGE and fries are cooked perfectly every..."
Christopher
"Great pizza to go with the brewery right around the corner. The slices hit the..."
M Rogers
"Damn it's expensive and you'll wait a while, but it is totally worth it. I've been getting pizza here since the 90s and it is just as good now as it..."
Joe Susco
"Great pizza, great food, a little pricey but worth..."
ShoginFlick
"Can only comment on the fries - they are delicious and worth the..."
Sara Parente
Calabria Ristorante
Calabria Ristorante
76/100 (320 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Seafood
Seafood
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Meatballs
Shrimp
Pesto
Fish
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Clams
Calamari
Mussels
Sit down
Italian
Seafood
Pizza
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
BYOB
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"Calabria has the best pizza on the island. We like our pies well done and Calabria delivers with delicious, crunchy pizza. Calabria also has a very..."
Jake Comito
"First time and was pleasantly surprised. Everything was very good. Also I was glad they were open on a weekday night after season. Not many places..."
Megan Pritchard
"Really nice pizza! A must try is they white cream Pizza! It's an artisan kitchen which is worth trying if you are in the area. Good for take aways..."
Diwakar Prasad
"Came here for the first time and definitely not the last time. Food was delicious and very generous portions. My husband had the shrimp parm and I..."
E S
"My family and I went there. They give you plenty of food for each dinner. The food was good. I only noticed that that Resturant charges you 3.99%..."
JOHN COYLE HERE
"Crab filled Ravioli with crabmeat vodka sauce —sooo delicious! Pure filling of crabmeat and the generous amount of crab vodka sauce is buttery..."
Diane Reiley
"Terrific Italian restaurant just blocks from the beach. Delicious pizzas and wonderfully fresh seafood dishes - the mussels are the best I've ever..."
Michael Sheehan
"Good food! My fiancee had a flounder francais that was excellent and my clams casino was wonderful! My best friend had the veal marsala with calamari..."
Andy Ramirez
"The food is delicious with generous portions and reasonable prices. The Mgmt and staff are very accomodating and SO friendly. They have a large..."
Joann Traub
"We were looking for an old school NY neighborhood type place so we made reservations for six and gave it a try. We weren't disappointed. Appetizers..."
Nick Pinto
"Pizza, Pasta, Steaks, Seafood, Salads, Desserts!!!! So many great dishes it is hard to try a new thing since the last time you went you LOVED the..."
Mary Ann Gutchigian
"Our favorite restaurant in LBI, we dine here every time we visit the island. Food is always delicious l and the service/owners are friendly and..."
Joseph Templin
"We've been coming back every year for the last 15 years we've been visiting the island. Food is consistent. Food is delicious. The owners remember us..."
Jennifer Chapkovich
"Excellent Italian menu and the most generous portions that I can remember. A very friendly and casual place. Now on my list of..."
Neal Toglia
Panzone's Pizza & Pasta
Panzone's Pizza & Pasta
76/100 (651 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Dinner
Focaccia
Pizza Margarita
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Blackened Mahi Mahi
Meatballs & Ricotta
Anniversary Pizza
Pasta
Italian Lobster Roll
Salad
Manhattan Chowder
Caprese Sandwich with Side Salad
Pesto
Crock of French Onion Soup
Charcuterie
GF Cheese Pizza
Smörgåsbord
caesar salad
Panzoni
Shrimp Scampi
Chicken Francese
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
BYOB
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I had the Caprese sandwich. What made it great was that they toasted the French roll first! Awesome..."
Fran Olivieri
"It seems we may have missed the dinner rush because as we were leaving business was starting to pick up. We had an order of wings, Penne Vodka with..."
D. Ramirez
"Visited here for the first time in LBI, been down here 12 years and never tried this place. Location is off main drag in Beach Haven near Bay Village..."
Matthew Liptak
"This spot is an absolute hidden gem on the LBI strip. It almost seemed too good to be true. It is sometimes difficult finding good food down there,..."
Amanda G
"Lobster roll is obscenely huge and filled with large chunks of lobster. Totally worth the price! I also ordered a meatball sub and that was great..."
Hector Caceres
"We used Panzone's Catering service for a luncheon for approximately 60 people. The food got many compliments and it was a pleasure working with the..."
Mariann Fuca
"The pepperoni and meatball pizza was amazing, while the service staff was very friendly and nice. The only negative I can mention is I wish Panzone's..."
Arthur Davis
"Best plain pizza we’ve ever had. Our 2 year old would only eat Panzones pizza for our entire vacation. Came home and ordered a local pizza and it..."
Monica T
"Super good pizza and the service was super fast! We got a small pie to split between two people after a Long Beach day and it hit the spot..."
Han
"Take out orders always ready. Cheese steaks ate the best. Unfortunately Beach Haven location is closed for the season but Surf City is open..."
Pat Perrine
"Liked it so much I bought a t-shirt, so did my daughter for herself and her boyfriend! Great memories here over the years. Went in at an off time..."
Cathy Falt
"Our server Gabi was terrific.. very attentive and food came promptly. She made good recommendations.. the Caeser salad was..."
Barbara Vant
"Panzones is the place to order delicious food for a big group. They have trays of food that are crowd pleasers - salads, pastas, mains, etc. We..."
Sally Poblete
"Stopped here for lunch with family. We had the meatballs with ricotta and real good Brussel sprouts for appetizers. I had their anniversary pizza..."
Scott Rocush
"My best friend from LBI since I've known since Kindergarten, and I initiated Panzone's at its inception in 1980 when its Beach Haven location was..."
Sage Easterwood
"The food is very good. There is a website to order through rather than telephone. Went in person to order, which was easier. Ample..."
Chris Gregory
"Excellent food. Very friendly staff. Decent prices. Loved the building. It was cool looking. It's was nice and cool and dry and I had a fun time..."
Ryan Volk
Slice Of Heaven
Slice Of Heaven
70/100 (461 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Dinner
Sandwiches
Cheesesteak
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"my family and i have been coming to LBI since around 2015! i have so many memories of coming here , and the food quality never decreases. it has an..."
meow meooow
"This pizza was awesome and it was cooked perfectly!! Crust was so crispy! Staff was very friendly and..."
Ann Marie Kelly
"Everytime we visit lbi we havee to get a pie or 2. The best tasting pizza weve ever had. Will be coming down in a week and will definitely be..."
kimberly luzier
"My family and I have been coming here for years. Today we were in and had the same great pizza we have always had. The staff is, as always, very..."
Daniel Troiani
"Stopped in on a Sunday night for a couple of mushroom slices. Nice guys, good slices, hit the..."
Mike Emmet
"I ordered subs (hoagies) for my family because someone I know has ordered from there and the food always looked amazing and it actually is! I would..."
Deborah Corliss
"The pizza was great!!!! The wings not so much. I think they just make pizza great, but not anything that isn’t pizza. The wings were bland and..."
Michael Garity
"Nice family owned business with exceptional food. The pizza nice its not the best place but it's okay. I would recommend this place for a party from..."
Mark Harman
"Great place, and I'll tell you why. My girlfriend and I were staying here a few days, and were out and wanted a pizza. We chose here, ordered, and..."
Esseff Dub
"Great for a quick bite, ziti pizza is a must! Be patient with the staff if they are busy. I’ve never had a problem. But this place is hot and..."
C C (Honest Reviewer)
"I've had many slices here, but most recently a entire pie in late October. Was so good my friends and I went two days in a..."
Kevin Kelly
"Stopped here for a quick slice of plain pizza. Some of the best pizza I have ever eaten and I regard myself as a pizza connoisseur. Kind of sorry I..."
Jennifer Castner
"I've been going since I was a child, now 33 and still love it! Standard pizza spot but slices are large and tasty. It to me is a must when visiting..."
Danny P