Best Bagels in Beach Haven

7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Bagel Shack
The Bagel Shack
89/100 (380 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
American
American
Breakfast
Lunch
Toasts
Breakfast Sandwich
Bagels
Pork Roll
Sit down
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I visited The Bagel Shack for the first time this week and the food was amazing. Probably the best bagels I have ever had. No kidding. They are..."
David Baesler
"The best beagles in the world. They will soon open a new place in Surf City..."
Monica Ordonez
"Clearly the best bagel joint on LBI. Certainly one of the few that are actually baking bagels. A softer more chewy bagel and always fresh. They make..."
Paul Guba
"Delicious Breakfast!! Staff is always so nice and patient. I wish pricing wouldn’t be as much for a bacon egg and cheese. 8$ is kinda too much....."
Daniella Cañas
"Best bagels I ever had. We were down in LBI for a weekend and went here both Saturday and Sunday mornings. It was that good we had to go back. Fresh..."
Andrew P
"Amazing breakfast sandwiches! Super small space though, so probably assign 1 person to take everyone's..."
Sara Parente
"Great service. Very good bagels. Even better Mexican food. A definite hidden..."
Gandalf The White
"The best bagels in LBI. The sandwiches, bagels are great and NY style. Service is quick and friendly as..."
Dan Miranda
"Great bagels. I got the everything bagel with avocado and it came with tomato and onion, yum. I'd definitely come back for more bagels, but I hope..."
Thomas Borawski
"Always go here while in LBI no matter where I am on the island. Great shop, great coffee and great bagels and sandwiches. Highly recommend trying it..."
Todd P
"Great bagels, good variety, tuna salad was very good. Cream cheese and lox was great. Good..."
barry dounn
"As someone who lives by NYC I was very happy to find bagels at my favorite vacation spot, LBI, that are similar. Delicious bagels and great egg..."
Rob Novack
"I come from Central NJ where we have amazing bagels. Since moving to LBI I thought that amazing bagels were a thing of the past. I was wrong. These..."
Jeffery Schaefer
"Excellent home made bagels!!! Amazing..."
Sandra Yaros
"Definitely a local favorite! Don't be discouraged by the line out the door....it goes pretty quick and is worth waiting..."
#SmartHomeSecurityNY
"AMAZING bagels. Chewy but not too doughy, nice crisp when toasted. Line moves very fast and the workers are all..."
Natalie Mercaldo
"3rd year in a row coming to LBI and bagel shack never disappoints. The French toast bagel is to die..."
John Conglose
"Perfect bagels! Just the right amount of chew. They have great homemade cream cheeses too, we loved the vegetable one. Always fresh. Great..."
Tara McGovern
"Delicious bagels! Friendly staff! Must..."
Susan Popik
Subs Up Deli
Subs Up Deli
88/100 (136 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Fast food
Fast Food
Breakfast
Lunch
Bagels
Fast food
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I've been coming here since I was a kid on beach vacations at LBI tastes just as delicious as I remember. Hope this little gem of a spot is always..."
Jason Schorr
"Great bagels all the time when down at the Shore. Lot's of variety and the sandwiches are..."
Stevie K
"Great variety of bagels 🥯 and spreads! The jalapeno spread is..."
Taylor Rafter
"What I miss about moving to the Midwest is shops like this. The people, the products, just perfect. Good bagels and options for sandwiches. Friendly..."
Brian Traficante
"Quick amazing service for morning grub when you really need to eat and don’t want to wait on the abusive line at a ridiculously unorganized place..."
Michael Napolitano
"I miss the pork roll egg cheese ketchup salt pepper on a everything..."
Wanna bee (Cumg3tm3 / wan2bm3)
"My wife gets her favorite iced coffee from here, the bagel selection is huge and exciting especially if you haven't had many different bagels in your..."
Forrest Steele
"My go to spot every-time I am on the island. Lots of competition but the consistency and quality never disappoints. During the busiest times the food..."
Kevin K
"Great bagels, fast and..."
Rich B
"This is a 1 minute walk when staying at the Sea Horse Motel. Great staff, good bagels and they actually restock the creamers..."
S Friedmann
"Bagels and Beyond has a nice assortment of unique bagels. Two examples I can think of... jalapeno cheddar and multigrain everything. We picked up..."
susan dare
"Awesome breakfast sandwich and..."
Caroline Zimmer
"Great bagels and..."
Nick Rutter
"The only thing keeping me from rating it 5 stars would be the chubby, older woman who watches the cash register like a hawk. To the point where it..."
Dave Drzewiecki
"The huge subs are great for lunch on the beach. Not the cheapest spot but worth it. Can get crowded but lots of staff to keep it moving. Many..."
Michael O'Gara
Pearl Street Market
Pearl Street Market
86/100 (867 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
American
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast Sandwich
Shrimp
Bagels
Cakes
Fish
Lobster
Paninis
Salad
Crab
Salmon
Lobster Roll
Fast food
American
Deli
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
BYOB
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Street Parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Accepts Discover
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"My family and I have been visiting Pearl Street Market in Beach Haven, NJ, each year for our annual summer vacation, and it's safe to say this..."
Chris Arndt
"All the food here is delicious! My family’s favorite is the sunrise wrap and we love getting their sandwich cookies. The staff are very kind and..."
Adam Maltese
"Good breakfast spot! The inside gets packed very quickly so make sure to get there early. Good coffee options as well as fresh fruit and sandwiches...."
Erica Harriell
"This place is a 10. We ordered lobster bake for 8 and some apps. The food was incredibly fresh, traveled well and was prepared to make eating lobster..."
Carly Pisarri
"Not only great fresh food, but an exquisite delivery bus service ! I would recommend this to anyone, anyone who wants bánginshalaka..."
Deęz
"Pearl Street is a favorite when we are on the island. It’s a quick walk from the house and they make great food. The breakfast sandwiches are top..."
David Pikulin
"This place. I’ve been going here for every morning for past 15 summers and it only gets better 💪💪. I would give it 6 stars if I could...."
Mackenzie Motroni
"Pearl was a fantastic experience. This market is staffed with very ample young, respectful and very customer centric individuals. We had breakfast..."
Jim Knott
"We ordered the lobster bake for 6 for my wife’s birthday and the folks at Pearl Street knocked it out of the park!! Everything was delicious!!! ..."
Brent Harlow
"Absolutely delicious! I got a gluten free Fairview wrap and it was phenomenal. Staff took extra care to work in the gluten free space in the kitchen..."
Nicole Aguiar
"A little pricy, but a good spot for morning coffee, bagels and breakfast sandwiches, as well as milk, juices and other odds and..."
Matthew Curley
"Turkey wrap was fantastic. Chicken was a bit dry but other than that we loved this market. Not quite peak season yet so no crowd was a..."
Tim Pici
"There are little to no vegetarian (let alone vegan) food options but what they do have is very good! Desserts and other kitchen staples are sold..."
K C
"Whether it’s coffee and a breakfast sandwich or a wrap and lunch before the beach this place doesn't miss! Can’t come to lbi and not come here...."
Art
"My favorite spot for breakfast and lunch when working the south end of the island. The food is over the top. Staff is the best so are the owners...."
John Humphries
"Stopped in on my work trip to get breakfast. I ordered the Veggie Burrito and Sanpellgrino Blood Orange. I absolutely loved the burrito: cheesy,..."
Damian VanHart
"Sea Food is fresh 👌👌 a little pricey but LBI is an island so 🤷 def will be back next time for the..."
I. Graciano
"Fascinating combo deli, seafood market, coffee shop, and grocery store. I highly recommend the Grilled Salmon..."
David Pickens
Crust & Crumb Bakery
Crust & Crumb Bakery
83/100 (452 ratings)
Bakeries
Dessert
Breakfast
Cupcakes
Cakes
Bagels
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Breakfast
Mid-range
"Tbh… mid cinnamon roll… not squishy or glutenesque enough Very cute custom Patrick fondant sculpture though ! Worth every penny of $17..."
Deęz
"The elephant ears are delicious and you can see them being made if you go to the back of the bakery. The doughnuts and crumb cake are also a..."
Stephanie Lucas
"Fantastic bakery in Beach Haven. Elephant ears are huge and delicious. Jelly donuts have a ton of really good jelly. Boston cream are my favorite...."
S Fournell
"Great donuts huge elephant ears. Couldn’t get..."
Rachel L
"I haven't been to Crust & Crumb in many years due to location but I NEVER forgot how perfect their jelly donuts were. I was visiting a friend this..."
Bridgit Carroll
"Amazing and delicious baked goods. The donuts and pastries look and taste delicious. They are known for the elephant ears which you must..."
Josh R
"I went to the Crust and Crumb bakery this morning for breakfast for the first time and let me say… I was amazed!! The sandwiches were delicious and..."
Lynn Lawlor
"There is another bakery on LBI that has a well known sign claiming they have the best jelly doughnut on LBI. No offense to that bakery, but Crust and..."
Steve Kastenbaum
"Love the elephant ears. So tasty and one of a kind. It's a cute small little shop. I recommend for the smells and awesome..."
Corey Woo
"This is a DAILY must stop when we’re on the island. So many good things to experience. 65 years of family recipes and they are still knocking it..."
Mark Fiedler
"Love Crust & Crumb wife needs to have an elephant ear every beach trip, and I love their mini key lime..."
Braucht Hershberger
"Breakfast sandwich is just as good as Bagel Shack and $4 better in price. Paired with Cool Beans it is a great..."
Will Glass
"I work in Bay Village and come to the bakery every once in while. The people are great and so has been everything I’ve ever purchased. Today I went..."
Kayla Barker
"This is a fantastic bakery with European quality stuff. The elephant ears are amazing, the donuts are extremely fluffy , everything tastes..."
Charles Frederick
"Awesome bakery. Tons of options and highly recommend an elephant..."
Rob Novack
"This bakery is one of the best bakeries I've ever been in, anywhere. We always make sure to make it a part of our LBI trips. We haven't found..."
Russell M
"I came here and ordered the sausage egg and cheese on a croissant and a bagel with cream cheese for breakfast and they were so good! Went back for..."
Caitlin Dubin
"I love "The Crumb." Best donut on LBI in my opinion. Place usually has a decent crowd, so be prepared to wait in line. Employees keep it moving,..."
Larry Whitney
Spray Beach Bagel & Deli Shop
Spray Beach Bagel & Deli Shop
81/100 (224 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Cafe
American
American
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Pork Roll Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Chocolate Chip Bagel & Iced Coffee
Bagels
Cheese Lettuce
Café
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"OMG!! This Pork Roll Egg and Cheese on a plain bagel just ooooozed of tasty goodness. Stopped in this bagel shop while visiting LBI and the owner..."
Harry Davis
"What a cute place! My chocolate chip bagel and iced coffee tasted even better sitting outside in their yard. I felt welcomed from the moment I..."
Jennifer B
"This is our Go to breakfast and/or Lunch spot - PJ and his team are the best!! Highly recommend the italian sub or a pork roll (Taylor ham) hangover..."
Sam Katz
"Some of the Jersey Shores best bagels and tasty breakfast sandwiches made to order. Nice assortment of T-shirt's and beachwear as..."
Gregory Meyer
"They legit have the best iced coffee. I stop in just for the coffee..."
Phil DiAntonio
"Decent place but VERY busy. I understand LBI is normally not as busy in the fall and they got slammed when we were there. But the staff did a great..."
Michael Altmann
"Very good bagels, nothing more to say there. The staff is super friendly, just couldn't be nicer. Decent coffee. My kids love the muffins. Definitely..."
Joe Susco
"First time customer. The entire staff was very friendly and the owner could not have been nicer. Bagels were fresh and tasty. I’m not a coffee..."
Anthony C
"Delicious NY-style bagels and deli (grabbed some cheese for sandwiches while we were there). Lots of beverage choices, but try to get there a little..."
Dominic Russo
"Family owned and operated. Great Service. They hire in young kids, most this being their first job, so awesome. Get in early for Bagels since they..."
Kayle Bowker-Jenkins
"Customer service is excellent and bagels are..."
Jeanne Bermudez
"Quirky and fun. Good variety and close to the beach. Kinda expensive at $10 for the turkey BLT on toast especially since they forgot the turkey and..."
Sean K
"My name is Diane. I live in Upstate NY. I was at this bagel place this morning called BAGELS AND BEYOND in Long Beach NJ..... I left my wallet. I..."
tim liszewski
Jersey Girl Grill
Jersey Girl Grill
76/100 (441 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
American
Cafe
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Bagels
Sandwiches
Café
American
Café
Gift Cards Available
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"Very friendly staff. Food was delicious. The smash burger and grilled fish tacos are incredible. First time visiting this restaurant and will..."
Crystal Smith
"Food was good with a nice selection, staff was very pleasant. Nice little spot for breakfast or..."
Joseph Gagliardo
"Nice little local spot for breakfast and lunch. Indoor and outdoor seating in a shore care environment. Food is nice. Nice little menu with plenty if..."
Victor Coppola
"Solid breakfast spot. Chicken cheesesteak was very..."
Rachel L
"Love this place, every year I go. Very creative dishes, very, very delicious. I had the pesto chicken salad with cashews this time for lunch, holy..."
Lou O'Caiside
"I loved it here! A great location and a cute place to eat. The food we received was delicious....they make their own fries fresh!!!! It can get busy..."
Jackie Steinbronn
"Just went for morning coffee run with wifey and it was fast and good. Plenty of outdoor seating. 7/28/23 - went her for breakfast and thought it..."
Dana Rubin
"Stopped by half hour before closing on a Sunday to grab a wrap. Friendly service, but unfortunately it wasn't what the description of a California..."
D DG
"Convenient and servers are very pleasant. A variety of breakfast choices & bagels. This was breakfast Sunday &..."
Solitaire F
"The vibes here were amazing!! Riley was an amazing and made our experience even better! The breakfast burrito was perfect and they accommodated for..."
Brian Raudenbush
"Very good food! I love the mango chicken salad that’s my go to! They also have great lattes and breakfast food! Staff is super..."
April Pellegrino
"Long line, but a cool spot. Pretty good breakfast sandwich and coffee. Plenty of outdoor..."
Caroline Zimmer
"Great food. Quick service. Nice outdoor seating with umbrellas. Perfect for breakfast and iced coffee after a walk or..."
Richard Holowczak
"Great place to grab breakfast sandwiches or lunch on LBI! The breakfast sandwiches, wraps, and iced coffee are all really great. They have gluten..."
Hannah Feldman
"Great food, packed even on a weekday so expect long lines but totally worth..."
Michael Maldari
"Very good food and friendly service. Prices very reasonable for..."
Vladimir Vascisin
"Amazing food and excellent service. We will be back for..."
John Martin