"V good pizza, took 20 minutes to get a 18inch classic cheese but there were plenty of places to window shop at while we..."
Gabrielle
"Very good Pizza, Even with it being a Friday night around 6pm, ordered and was served my Pizza within 15 mins. Crust was very good, and pepperoni was..."
Diane Ski
"Bay Village Pizza is a local treasure! Their pizzas are a slice of perfection, with a thin crust that's perfectly crispy. The sauce is flavorful, and..."
Poughkeepsie 360
"First time going to to Bay Village Pizza after usually eating at panzones. Living full time in North Jersey where pizza is an art, I can tell you ..."
William L
"No frills, walk-up pizza joint. Quite popular so it gets pretty busy. Expect to wait even if the line is not that long. Seems to be located smack..."
D. Ramirez
"the fresh cut fries never disappoint and pizza is good sometimes.. fries take a little while but pizza is almost immediate but they do tell you that..."
hi hi
"Quick!
Clean!
Good food!
Be patient as this is a hot spot to grab a quick bite in the hot town !
But food is very good! Been coming here for 15..."
C C (Honest Reviewer)
"Pizza was fantastic! My favorite on the island! Line was long, so definitely recommend calling ahead. They had a pick up window so was easy to..."
Jason Schorr
"An average pizza joint but with HUGE slices of pizza and great fries which I recommend getting which cheese. Great place to have a quick meal..."
Brendan
"Pizza was pretty good, and the slices were nice and big, but toppings were barely..."
Sean Aldrich
"Best pizza on LBI. Pies and slices are HUGE and fries are cooked perfectly every..."
Christopher
"Great pizza to go with the brewery right around the corner. The slices hit the..."
M Rogers
"Damn it's expensive and you'll wait a while, but it is totally worth it. I've been getting pizza here since the 90s and it is just as good now as it..."
Joe Susco
"Great pizza, great food, a little pricey but worth..."
ShoginFlick
"Can only comment on the fries - they are delicious and worth the..."
Sara Parente
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes