As a Detroiter, I belive we have the best pizza in town, but forget about it, these guys got us beat! They have a great selection of deep dish and thin crust pizzas. I recommend trying them all!
Service is awesome, quick, efficient, food us so delicious!!
We stopped here for a quick slice of regular and I took home a big slice of Caesar salad chicken for later- all delicious! One of the tastiest regular slices I’ve had in a while actually. Our fountain drinks were bubbly and and cold too. They also have honey mustard chicken slices without lettuce, which I’m going to try next time. The staff was also very friendly and helpful. I’ll definitely be back soon!
This was My first time here eating here, All the employees were fantastic such nice guys the place was clean and the food was spectacular!! The white slice I had was probably the best tasting white slice I ate in my whole life!! I would highly recommend Stella Pizza to anybody, the name Stella is an understatement compared to the service and the quality of the food I received !!!
Pretty good pizza. I really like their grandma's pie. Also very nice dining area!
Food was excellent, as was the service. Portions were very generous. Waiter was very pleasant.
Had our daughter Maggie's baby christening here and I truly have to say it was handled wonderfully by the staff at Stella's. Can't say enough on the theme and decorations designed and set up by my daughter Kelly.
If your doing any type of party or fundraising event I would recommend Kelly for planning purposes hands down
Joe helped my family providing a room, menu and most delicious buffet in a matter of 2 days for my mothers funeral luncheon. During a very stressful time, Joe with a smile calmly said don't worry-I'll work with you. It couldn't have been more perfect..Thank you. Joanne berman
We typically order take out and occasionally eat in the restaurant. Yesterday, we had our fourth event (over the past 8 years) in the back room of Stella's restaurant. The room is bright, airy and has nice decor.
The food is delicious with plentiful portion sizes.
We find the owners to friendly and accommodating.
It's a small but very decent place very close to Wantagh Park
The food is delicious and service outstanding.
I recommend this please to everybody
Their specialty slices are AMAZING. They seem to be made perfectly everytime. Stacked with ingredients and evenly distributed, cooked perfectly crispy but not burnt.
I can't stress how well they make their specialty pies. They are deep dish, so you get a lot of bang for your buck. The thickness allows them to pile on so much good stuff (Like the ton of bacon and chicken I had on my Chicken Bacon Ranch slice)!
We called early in the afternoon for delivery of 5 pies not only were they on time but pizza was fantastic. For a brick oven pizza La Strada of Merrick is by far the best... For a regular pie this place is awesome. Grandma slice top notch, the sauce the cheese wow. Chx bruschetta was perfect and garlic knots deliciously soaked... the only problem is I waited 10 years to try it. I will absolutely be back... Thank You...
Ate here 5 times during Hurricane Sandy. I was a Fema Disaster Relief Inspector. I did hundreds and hundreds of inspections. I asked the locals what was the best pizza in Long Island. Stella's came up over 45 times. I had most all singles slices so I could try many. I loved the rice balls. Never had them. I am from Virginia. We don’have pizza and deli’s & butchers like in Long Island. I highly recommend. Great service. They took care of me. 👍
Stella's makes the best pizza on Long Island. The garlic knots. Those spinach pin wheel things. Meatball Parm, Chicken Parm. Fettuccine Alfredo all great. Eat in, take out and delivery I've done it all and was always well satisfied.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes