This is the best pizza I have had in the area. The crust was crunchy the sauce was delicious. I just walked in off the street and was pleasantly surprised at how good the pizza was. The price was reasonable and the service was as if I was at home. Say hello to Carmen the pizza Queen when you were there.
I came in at around 7:45 one evening recently and they were closing at 8. I felt bad stopping in right before closing but they made me great tacos and a slice and even threw in another slice for free. Food was very good I will definitely be back. Workers were friendly and prices were good.
Really good food, nice service and the prices are amazing.
Food was fantastic! The prices are unbeatable! I was very impressed. The owners were kind and helpful and went out of their way to make my experience great. I highly recommend it.
I have worked in the area for almost 8 years. At least 5 different owner at the old Pizzelis over that time. New owners and new name. Finally some good pizza in the area. I've eaten here now almost once a week. Never disappointed.
First time with new owners and it’s a home run!
I ordered the vodka pizza and Ceasar salad, so good!
I picked up my order and noticed how clean the place is!
I’ll be back!
Food was excellent! Service was fabulous! The owners really go above and beyond for every customer that walks through the door. Great prices too. 10/10!
My family and I love this place. The staff is always friendly and the shop has a real comfortable "home", feel to it. You can tell the cooks put a lot of thought and love into what they do. Their sandwiches, calzones, rolls, and garlic knots are great. They also make really awesome specialty pizzas. However, hands down, they make the best regular cheese pizza that I have had anywhere on Long Island.
Got a few pies (Buffalo chicken, pepperoni and grandma) for kids and parents pre Halloween trick or treating meal and garlic knots… everything was delicious, price was reasonable and was delivered exact time I requested it. Thanks guys, we’ll be back.
It's under new management. I got the grilled chicken bruschetta and it's soooo good! The entree comes with side of pasta. I got penne in red sauce. My brother got a burrito (yes they have burritos now) and he loves it. My dad loves his meatball parm hero tooo. Don't sleep on this place!!!
I'm going to start off by saying I've moved in about three months ago and tried every pizzeria nearby. I also believe that this is the best pizzeria in the area, I used to work at one in NHP for years on end that was in the same ballpark as umbertos. Pizellis is an incredible new pizzeria in this town and its a hidden gem. The pies are unbelievably fresh and will never dissapoint. The slices are big and always topped appropriately. Additionally the kitchen food is another unbelievable part of this place. That chef can cook! I highly reccomend if you are looking for a place to get great italian food or just in the mood for some slices you check this place out you will not be dissapointed. The owners are great and always friendly which is another plus. I am so happy this will be our go to pizzeria.
I just moved into the area and after trying a few pizzerias, I finally found the one. The new owner is extremely friendly and the food is absolutely delicious. They are working on renovating and I can’t wait for the extra seating to sit down and eat here.
Under new ownership, best food, best price. Three entries for $29.99. The best professional cook. Pizza and garlic knots are so delicious!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes