3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Cycled 45 miles from Long Island and couldn’t find a bakery nearby. Saw the $15.95 advertised poster outside and got drawn in.
Was looking for a..."
Frugal Cyclist
"First time at Sammy’s and am pretty pleased. The hostess was very nice and caring, she asked if we had any birthdays in our party of 17. The..."
Patrizia
"Food was amazing, atmosphere was amazing, everything was great. Was visiting from Texas and had the best time with my loved ones from NJ, already..."
Shay Yates
"My father and I had just got done boating into the city and had docked on City Island earlier in the day. A quick Google search found this place,..."
Arthur Goudey
"The place is nice and spacious. The service was slow but our waiter was super nice. My friends loved the food, I found it a little bit too salty and..."
gigi jaime
"Fresh bread and cornbread good to start the meal with. Ordered the seafood chiller, from raw to cooked very fresh. Here’s for the 5lbs lobster..."
KAI YAN Lo
"I just want to say the king crab and anow crab combo is the best. One of the best seafood restaurants in the city. Come hungry. Cornbread is where..."
marina dee
"The food was great. The staff checked in often and was very accommodating. Even the music threw me back to a time when listening was easy and it made..."
Paul
"The staff is really what has me coming back to this location few time, and has a great set of people, they are wonderful and so sweet and always..."
Jishan Chowdhury
"So I went to city Island for the first time after living in NYC for 10+ yrs which is very sad because it’s an absolute must visit for any NYC..."
Rakesh
"The service was very good here. The food was also good, very good portions and everything came out hot! I recommend the New England Clam Chowder if..."
D BG
"I've been coming to this restaurant for years because I love City Island. I gave them a 4 because they need to update their menu. Yhey doubled their..."
WaterIsLife EssenceOfOils
"The food taste amazing, the atmosphere is perfect and the service is great! This entire meal cost $27.99 plus tax. Who could ask for anything more..."
Diana Washington
"Went there for a double birthday celebration. It wasn't too crowded. Was outside at first but the bees buzzing around was a little too much. We were..."
allyoop Dan
"Simply the best seafood restaurant I have gone to in a long time. We had a 7pm reservation, and it was on right on time. The service was excellent...."
"Had the petite filet mignon, cooked okay, maybe a little overdone to my liking, but still good. Regular French fries are also good, and there are..."
Edwin Martinez
"Had the dry aged strip steak. Cooked perfectly(although med rare might be slightly more well cooked than most like). Food arrived quickly. The..."
Al Olivero
"If you are a Yankee fan and like a good steakhouse, then this place is for you. Remember, it's a steakhouse so you really can worry about the cost of..."
Jeremy Langer
"Amazing stand alone steakhouse. Competitive prices. Excellent food. The stadium itself is..."
Roger Eldridge
"Booked for my husband's birthday..staff so friendly and the food is amazing and definitely have the Cherry Pie red..."
Jacquimc McQueen
"A legitimate high end steak house inside of Yankee Stadium. In NYC you can do better food wise but to be able to have a meal at this caliber..."
Gregory Lamparello
"Easy to get to right inside yankee stadium, sat at the bar, atmosphere was nice, bartender pleasant and knowledgeable. Cocktails were well made, apps..."
Tessa Marino
"The food was great especially the steak🥩. NYY Steak was better than what I thought. They have a good staff that's friendly, helpful & on point...."
BAMM BAMM
"If you want to feel like a million dollar VIP make sure you eat dinner here. The food OMG unbelievable & 2nd to none. Everything from the taste to..."
Brian Marciniak
"The entire experience was tremendous! Loved the atmosphere, the service and especially the..."
The NVP Show
"Was a little unsure about going after all they do have a security check with metal detectors before you could go in but as I walk in those my whole..."
Sicario Music
"Had a great waiter, chris, he was very attentive ,we were a party of 4. We had great steaks and lobster tails....excellent food.....
On 11am..."
Michele Paxson
"Fabulous food, friendly staff, and you’re at Yankees Stadium!!! You gotta love it!!! The Steakhouse is our go to place to eat at the Stadium. My..."
Joann Kusk
"Everything was 5 star. Hot hand towels to wipe your hand before eating. My caesar salad was to die for. I ordered the filet mignon, the waitress..."
Robert Dutton
"The service and the food was terrific!!! Great place to go before or after the..."
James Menite
"The Steak and Drinks at New York Yankee Steak are worth it. It was great to experience the game from a different area of the ballpark. No reservation..."
Scrooge LaBucks
"Straight up steak house!
Ceasar salad, clams casino, shrimp cocktail very good.
Ny stripe, filet migion and lobster tail cooked perfect.
All the..."
David Hurtado
"It’s just so cool to eat in a steak house in Yankee Stadium. The food was pretty solid and the cocktails were well made. I’ll be..."
Patrick L
"Awesome night at the Yankees. This is a great bar to arrive early. $15 cocktails, great calamari, salad. Get here by 5, sit at the bar. Special..."
"I had a great lunch with my mom who was up from Florida and wanted a nice meal with a view. The view was great from the outdoor deck, as was the food..."
John Killen
"Having private graduation party. Price was great , food awesome & service impeccable. They moved us from the inside to deck after it was all set up..."
John M. Bedosky
"Went there for a business lunch yesterday.
Service was excellent, food was amazing and the view was beautiful.
Great deck outdoors and beautifully..."
M'liss Newfoundland
"Celebrated my birthday with my family. We ordered the Surf & Turf. Steak was juicy, and crispy on the edges, just how we like it! The potatoes and..."
Lourdes Melendez-Gamez
"I ordered Skirt steak medium well was cooked perfect to my taste and my husband ordered the Linguini lobster with clams and mussels was so good too. ..."
Maria Fuentes Mendoza
"I was shocked that we were just about the only diners. It was a Monday though. Awesome food in a charming environment. Prices are reasonable. The..."
Michael Hatfield
"It was my moms first time out to city island in a long time. And it was Mother's Day. She's 84 now, and she had the time of her life. Everyone was..."
Jimmy Changa
"Great service and excellent food - we had a Groupon for 2 and it included appetizer, meal and..."
Tricia Pentheros
"Great food Great service Great time and I'm hard to..."
Cory
"Great food, great atmosphere, love this place!!! BEST FOOD IN CITY..."
DARKNIGHT007
"The best PLACE eVer. THE FOOD WAS FIVE STAR !!!!!!!!!! Must try the veal with crab meat!!!!! Service was first..."
Anel
"Best restaurant. I love this place we go there all the time. the best food and service love the outdoors..."
Mirsad Rugova
"My recent visit to this restaurant was just as delightful as the previous one, and I can't help but be amazed. The staff remained exceptionally..."
G
"Amazing view of the water. Drinks - white sangria - was a little watered down. Appetizers- fried calamari- a little dry and not too much flavor...."
D H (Dee)
"I was on a date night with my fiancé. Food and service were phenomenal. Lobster was tender, well seasoned and very delicious. It was so appetizing I..."
Ms. Perez
"I celebrated 🍾 my 53rd Birthday here with my Babes ❤️. I had an Amazing evening in your Beautiful romantic establishment. The food was..."
Wathena Barker
"Went there for my anniversary and was very happy with the food and service as well as a great view. I initially was not happy with my entree, but my..."
Cindy Valentine
"My family and I visited. Actually our second time. The staff was great and the food came out at a timely manner. The outdoor is beautiful and my 9..."
Sandra Katehis
"Quick stop for the bday. Excellent view of NYC skyline. We were the only ones outside. Only complaint was low tide with the smell of the floor. I..."
Brien Ling
"We had about 14 people in our group and the service was on point! The food was great they even made a dish not on the menu! Everyone who worked there..."
Jonquel NYC
"Run by a family who is passionate about good Italian food and giving out the best service. Love the outdoor seating and the ambiance. Food is always..."
Aideen
"Amazing food and service ! Cappuccino was delicious too, and so was the wine. They also have live music after 11pm, and a lovely deck seating area..."
Sparky Ny
"We just had my Fathers 90th birthday there this weekend, Mario was very nice and professional, when we sat down to go over the details he was very..."
Ken Forsberg
"The food was delicious! Incredible view from the outdoor covered patio on the water! Family owned restaurant that makes you feel like you're part..."
Rosemarie Salvo
"Great dining experience, our waiter Benny made sure we were all well taken care for while we dined. The food was tasty we had the hot antipasto..."
Carmen Jimenez
"The staff here is really great, very very family oriented and welcoming. It's hard to find good service now and they really do an excellent job..."
Steve Vanderheof
"I liked it! Spacious, the food was good. The service was good. It looks like a good family restaurant. I would definitely go back again. There is a..."
Peter Papagiannakis
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes