Stopped by with my daughter today. I dropped my gelato cup and she asked for a cup after having trouble handling the cone outside and they were so helpful & accommodating. Oh and did I mention our strawberry & Nutella gelato was so delicious?? I absolutely recommend Coneys and we will definitely be back.
I come to this cute little ice cream shop every so often during the summer months. Don't be discouraged if you see long lines as the staff moves really quickly. They have a pretty good selection of flavors and everything is reasonably priced. I recently got the mango/raspberry combo and it was so delicious and refreshing. I definitely recommend anyone visiting Coney Island to check this place out!
Loved the pistachio and coconut one i ordered! Creamy and not too sweet, full of flavor and smooth to the palate. Recommended? A big yes!
This is a really good gelato place. I try different places, but I keep coming back to this one. The only thing that could have done this spot even better - bigger tastes selection. But the ones they have are always spot on! Gelato is creamy & smooth heaven, portions are generous, staff is helpful. They always offer you to try it first if you're hesitant. Coney Island custard is a must!
Pretty impressed with the flavors here. Everything was creamy and perfect, not overly sweet, and priced very reasonably.
Service was great, very fast and efficient.
I'd definitely stop in again! Would be perfect on a beach day!
Nice gelato! If in Coney Island a great spot for gelatos with a great view!
The soft gelato has excellent structure and is scooped and packed to best advantage with a flat, wide spade. Among flavors, the Coney Island Custard is not to be missed, ever, even if the Nutella Crunch exceeds expectations. The scoops are very large.
Their ice cream is SOOOOO CREAMY AND WELL BALANCED! I'm in love with it! I ordered their cookie monster and strawberry shortcake and it was AMAZING! Also, I'm mildly lactose intolerant and this ice cream was just perfect and didn't cause any discomfort. 😉
Delicious Ice Cream!
Favorite Flavor : Cookie Monster
Yummy!!!!!! I got chocolate and mint chocolate chip. Fast moving line and quick service. Delicious and would recommend!
They make delicious gelato and sorbet here. My favorite flavor so far is the Cookie Monster.
The ice cream was very tasty and the ball was also big, so you got something for the price.
Coney Island fun place to be,train or bus will get you here ,amusement park Beach â›±candy shops ,food arcades rides have fun while you can,we did
Samantha Purcell-Musgrave
+5
Absolutely delicious! We got the Coney Island Custard and Pumpkin Spice. The large was definitely enough for two people. Would recommend!
The best ice cream on the boardwalk.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes