Reviews Penny House Cafe

5
Sea Curves
+5
I ordered the grilled chicken supreme on an everything bagel. Super filling and hearty. The staff was so professional and nice! The pastries were so yummy and fresh. The price for everything I got was super affordable too! Wish I could go back here tmrw! My new favorite cafe in Brooklyn. Thank you for the best experience
5
Caitlin Gorss
+5
I absolutely loved it here the staff was so friendly and welcoming. They greeted us when we came in and explained the menu. The food was delicious, loved the homemade bagels, I got the bestseller and an iced vanilla latte both for a good price. Would eat here again.
5
Deja Bond
+5
Love the chicken supreme sandwich Was so good! The fried egg and sriracha mayo Is perf! I was nervous to try but definitely delicious
5
Orhun Unsal
+5
Awesome vibe, super friendly staff and the food was delicious. Enjoyed my latte and really enjoyed my Chicken and Hummus bagel sandwich. Great spot to enjoy a bite and do some people watching. Highly recommend!
5
Χαρα Οικονομιδου
+5
Do yourselves a favour and try it out! It’s one of the best places to eat and the people working there are great! It was so good I didn’t get a chance to take a picture
5
TIFF TIFF
+5
Went to the Brooklyn library to see the JayZ exhibit and googled nearby breakfast/brunch spots. Penny’s was at the top of the list. So we took a chance. DELICIOUS! I got a blt on bagel and my husband got a beef sausage, egg, & spicy cheddar on a roll. Everything was made fresh and piled on thick. Nothing skimpy about this place. It is well worth the visit and everyone there was friendly!
4
John Andrawous
+4
I visited NYC recently and stayed in Brooklyn. This place was nearby and I came for some breakfast. Very cool little place. Chilled-out vibe, and the gentleman that helped me was super friendly. The entire menu looked great, but I decided on the Ghost Pepper Beef Sausage breakfast bagel and an iced mocha. Very tasty breakfast, not too spicy. The iced mocha was a little too sweet for me, but still better iced coffee compared to a couple of other places nearby (i.e.: Grabstein's Bagels, Hungry Ghost)
4
Kerry-Ann Burnett-Astree
+4
The staff was super friendly and courteous. The establishment though small was very clean. Service was prompt and the food was great. The prices were more than reasonable. I had a 3 Cheese Omelet on a Cinnamon Raisin Bagel with a glass of Apple Juice and my daughter had a 3 Cheese Omelet on a Croissant with a Chai Tea Latte. We both enjoyed our breakfast.
5
Richard W
+5
Very friendly staff! Ask for the americano with coconut water. Really good combo with the can they have in stock.
5
Nicole Ansbacher
+5
My favorite neighborhood coffee and bagel. This was the first place I tried the morning I moved to town, desperate for a cup of coffee early in the morning, and I’ve been back frequently every since! The bagels are prepared just how I like them, and the coffee is always hot and delicious. And the best part yet is the friendly faces that go with it.
5
Irene CP
+5
Great sandwiches and friendly staff
4
Robert Cardoni
+4
Great bagels and coffee Have your order ready when approaching the counter! Efficiency is the key here :) Avoid fees...pay cash 💸 Everything bagel with veggie cream cheese is amazing.
5
Emma McWeeney
+5
Delicious coffee and incredible service!! My 2 year old was in a mood, and he made him is own tiny cup of chocolate milk. Made it possible for me to enjoy my yummy caramel latte :)
5
Karim Poonawala
+5
An extremely modest establishment. Yet the bagel sandwiches, and super friendly service compels me to give it 5 stars. We had an everything bagel with ghost pepper cheddar, beef sausage and eggs. My guest ordered a wheat everything bagel with Turkey bacon, sriracha aioli, smoked gouda and eggs sandwich. Both were super good. Coffee was exceptionally good. A super filling breakfast for under 10 dollars. Omar served us and was super friendly, getting us coffee refills. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
5
H L
+5
Cute little spot with a decent amount of seating for such a small place. Excellent assortment of drinks and friendly staff!
4
Phil Douglas
+4
This little cafe ticked a lot of my boxes. The guy who served us was obviously the owner and personally invested in making us feel welcome. The coffee was good and made to suit our taste and the cinnamon scroll was good. Drop in some time.
5
Lauren Crowe
+5
Muhammad is great and the entire staff gives off a great vibe. Both the coffee and the tea are great. I ate a chicken wrap at the staff’s recommendation, and it was delicious and filling. I went back multiple times during my trip to NYC.
5
Jerica B
+5
amazing coffee nice staff ❤️
4
Garima Gautam
+4
Started my day with this delicious multigrain bagel with scrambled eggs and pepper jack cheese 🤤.
Clicca per espandere