Reviews Sal's Pizzeria & Mama Maria's Restaurant

5
Matthew M
+5
I went there yesterday afternoon with my wife after we went to IKEA to get some furniture, obviously I wanted to try it since I saw the episode on YouTube. Everything about this neighborhood speaks family, cultural and home made. Sals pizzeria and mamma Maria’s restaurant make this neighborhood look amazing, now on to the food, while we didn’t stay for a huge dinner we grabbed a few slices and let me tell you, those slices are exactly how pizza is supposed to be made, traditional pizza done the absolute best way. I ordered a salad from the restaurant to try it, that was the best salad I’ve ever had, I don’t think I’ve ever had to say that because who thinks of a salad like that? But that salad was amazing, you can taste how fresh the ingredients were, and from dining at many other places that claim to have fresh ingredients they hold no water to sals and mamma Maria’s. The decor here is definitely warm and inviting, the outdoor dining experience was great and definitely welcoming. John’s hard work definitely shows in the food here I loved it. Will definitely visit again
5
Caroline Ireland
+5
I've never been to this restaurant. I'm from the UK. But I would love to come and visit you one day. Your menu looks amazing ❤️
5
Gael Castaneda
+5
Prepare to embark on a culinary journey that will transport you straight to the heart of Italy, as you step into the enchanting world of Mama Maria's. This restaurant is not merely a place to dine; it's an experience that captures the essence of Italian culture, hospitality, and, most importantly, the exquisite flavors that make Italian cuisine renowned worldwide. From the moment you step through the door, Mama Maria's wraps you in a warm embrace of aromas that can only be described as heavenly. The air is perfumed with the rich scents of fresh basil, sun-ripened tomatoes, and the unmistakable bouquet of simmering garlic and olive oil. It's as if you've stepped into a nonna's kitchen, where every dish is prepared with love and generations of culinary tradition. The ambiance at Mama Maria's is a perfect blend of rustic charm and modern elegance. The cozy, candlelit tables evoke a sense of intimacy, while the vibrant murals and decor pay homage to the beauty of Italy's countryside. Whether you're sharing a romantic evening, celebrating with friends, or savoring a solo meal, the restaurant's inviting atmosphere sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the food. Mama Maria's menu reads like a love letter to Italian gastronomy. Every dish is a masterpiece, carefully crafted to showcase the freshest, high-quality ingredients. Begin your journey with the burrata caprese, a delicate dance of creamy burrata cheese and juicy heirloom tomatoes, drizzled with aged balsamic. As you move on to the main course, the handmade pasta dishes are a revelation. The tagliatelle al tartufo will leave you speechless, each bite delivering an explosion of earthy truffle goodness. And let's not forget about the wine selection. Mama Maria's boasts an impressive array of Italian wines, curated to complement the flavors of each dish. The knowledgeable staff is always ready to help you find the perfect pairing, ensuring that every bite and sip harmonize in a symphony of taste. But the true magic of Mama Maria's lies in its people. The staff here doesn't just serve food; they share stories, traditions, and a genuine passion for their craft. Every interaction feels like catching up with an old friend – attentive, warm, and always ready to make your dining experience extraordinary. In a world where authenticity can be rare, Mama Maria's shines as a beacon of genuine Italian cuisine. Each visit is a celebration of la dolce vita, a reminder to slow down, savor the moment, and relish in the simple pleasures of exceptional food and company. So, whether you're a culinary connoisseur or simply in search of a delightful meal, Mama Maria's is more than a restaurant – it's a destination that will leave an indelible mark on your heart and palate.
5
Isabel Quek
+5
Fooder from singapore! May the owner and the family be bless , may everyone come here to try their food and be blessed too. Goodluck to john!
4
Robin van Wijngaarden
+4
$5 per topping on a small pizza seems a little crazy. Also their online menu says $3.50 for a glass of bad wine but it's $7 around dinner? Just say so. Very very tasty pizza. Got a fresh pie, not sure about by the slice.. really good stuff
5
Ethan Dobby
+5
Loved this place so much seriously i recommend to anyone and everyone and if your Italian you MUST come here
5
Adam Baker
+5
Just saw this on kitche nightmares , and I must say, WOW what a difference. It is excellent and the food was so delicious and luckily not mouldy!😂
5
Chysoul
+5
I’ve been to this amazing restaurant during my visit to NY it was the best experience ever everything was delicious and everyone there was kind. I’m actually shocked that this was one of the restaurants that Gordon has helped, because most of them just shut down after few months, but this one shows that they really did with Gordon’s advices. Keep up the good work, the delicious food and i wish you the best of luck 🥰
5
Bethany W
+5
Amazing! Loved the episode. John you seem like an amazing guy. Hope it’s all going well for you. Food looks amazing! I’d love to visit from England and hopefully will get too one day
5
Sebastian Matthews
+5
I would recommend this restaurant in a heartbeat. Great atmosphere and a fantastic staff. Oh, and the the food is delicious.
5
Sam Dane
+5
Food is absolutely amazing I would definitely recommend anyone I know and everyone I don't know to eat at Mama Maria's you won't regret it
5
Phyllis Rogers
+5
The food is amazing here and the service is one of a kind. I strongly recommend try them out when you in the area.
5
Mr Fruitgum
+5
John you are an amazing man, you have not only turned your restaurant around but your life as well.
5
Jason Sichi
+5
Let me start by saying that we had no idea that this place was on Kitchen Nightmares until after we ate there. I have to admit that it was absolutely amazing. From the wonderful service to the fantastic food. Our server was fantastic, the food was fantastic. All of our meals came out quick and fresh. I would highly recommend this place for great authentic Italian cooking in Brooklyn!
4
Amine
+4
great experience. amazing staff and delicious pizza. also not so far from home wich is even better. thank you
5
A. Alaz
+5
So far my favorite Gamberi e Vongole in Brooklyn, I love how cozy and authentic this place is. Everything we’ve ordered was amazing and delicious. The service is beyond great, We’ve also enjoyed the calamari fritti. I can’t stop talking about this place to friends and family, I’ll definitely return to this place.
5
Tamica Hutchinson
+5
I love this Gem! This restaurant and the owner has a special place in our families life. They have been with us since our 3rd date! We are now married almost 6yrs with a 3yr old! Best Italian food and even my Lo eats it! Go here, you won't be disappointed. Must try the Tiramisu, you won't be disappointed. It inspired me to learn how to make Tiramisu, since they were closed due to the pandemic. So happy they are open!
5
Stacey Huffaker
+5
Visited as an out of state tourist and was amazingly surprised at the food quality, portion size and service. I had seen this establishment featured on Kitchen Nightmares and my heart went out to the owner and his fearless and honest approach to keeping his parents legacy alive. I had to visit. All heartfelt feeling aside, I was pleased to see that this special owner embraced the gift of Chef Ramsey (whom I've had the pleasure of shadowing in previous endeavors) and the producers of Kitchen Nightmares. Sometimes God guides and the result is in gold when one follows. I believe that is the case with Mama Maria's. Try any pizza on the menu. I am sure you will be as pleased as I was. And they will special prepare any request.
Clicca per espandere