This is the pizza of my childhood and it always hits. I love sitting at those old school tables with a slice and fountain soda. I was so happy that it matched my memories. A solid choice in Bay Ridge.
Confessions of a Food Freak
+5
No frills just good pizza. A staple in bay ridge that’s been around since I was a child. Same place same pizza that is consistently good.
I noticed the shop showed up in a "best of" list - they deserve it. Excellent Sicilian slice at a simple old school slice shop. You don't have to go to a brick oven joint (they certainly can be great) to get good pizza. I guess there's a reason why they've been around since 1979.
So basically you buy 3 pounds of ground beef mixed with vegetables from Balady Super market in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn then you take it to Elegante Pizzeria and ask him for large pie. Don't forget to hand him 20 bucks. The result is that massive Hawawshi. Enjoy it.
This place offers a decently delicious pizza pie! There's something subtle about the sauce that distinguishes it from others. The crust is surprisingly crunchy in all the right spots & each bite just gets better.
Best slices in Brooklyn! Perfect if you’re looking for no frills, quick stop, truly authentic New York pizza! Very reasonably priced too!
Certain things in life should never change and Elegante Pizza is one of them!!
The last 2 pies I bought made it all the way to Syracuse, as a surprise for our daughter and her family.
We voted them as the BEST Sicilian Pizza ever !!!!
Finest Brooklyn Sicilian squares. Been coming here since I was a kid.
Best pizza in the neighborhood. Nice guys, quick delivery.
Love these guys probably the best pizza in town
I tell you I am so impressed by this place! The taste the texture the cheesiness the sauce it’s 100% best pizza I’ve had in NY ! I’ve had all types of pizza lived in Nj most of my life and live in Ny now !! Growing up I’ve always had great pizza and memories at a pizza shop and as soon as I ate here I had the good vibe and fresh great tasting pizza ! I would absolutely recommend!
The great old-school pizza spot, with the best-tasting pizza slice in Bayridge :) Really it is! The staff is super nice too!
Best fresh square pies in all my years, living all over Brooklyn. I find any and every excuse to dine here when in the neighborhood. If you don't get them fresh then the slices will be 80% as good, but still the best.
Really Great Pizza, anytime my out of town family visits the first place they want to go to is Elegante Pizza. The laminate on the tables are starting to peel. If you order a pie with extra cheese to be delivered, ask them to have the pie sit for awhile, otherwise you'll have all the cheese on one side of the pie
Great selection and consistently delicious food
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes