This place is incredible. My girlfriend and I each got The Hamilton, which is turkey apple chipotle and some other things. It was one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had. The sandwich was HUGE (I was starving and completely full after half a sandwich) and delicious. Even the bread was great, the crust was flaky like a croissant. It took a long time for the food to come out, but the man working there (owner vibes) was very apologetic and gave us free water and a muffin (the blueberry muffin was amazing too!). Definitely worth making a trip for a sandwich here!
I cannot say enough about this place. I usually get one of the meat sandwiches and my sister who is a pescatarian usually gets the salmon sandwich. First of all let me just say, that everything I've had here is great, but that salmon sandwich touched my soul. It was absolutely delicious and the salmon was perfectly cooked. They vary the bread they serve it on but I think the Texas toast added something extra. I highly, HIGHLY recommend getting something from these guys.
P.S. I also love the names of their sandwiches. Nice way to pay homage to Brooklyn.
UPDATE: I had the buffalo shrimp mac & cheese yesterday. DE.LI.CIOUS!! But I also forgot to say their MUFFINS! If you haven't had one before you have to try it. Especially the blueberry.
I’ve had a lot of amazing sandwiches in my life eating in NYC, but this is probably the best sandwich I’ve ever had! The guys that own the place are friendly, welcoming, and make you feel at home. Old-school Brooklyn vibes that let you know you’re about to have an amazing sandwich. And the Flatbush Avenue definitely didn’t disappoint. The portion size is massive and is two meals worth of food. The size is evident by the fact that I was barely able to take a photo. And don’t let the portion size confuse you, the quality of this sandwich was exceptional. I will be back soon!
What a sweet place. Not only was my sandwich (The 5th Ave, a chicken cutlet vodka parm) incredibly delicious and so were the garlic pomodoro fries, but when a flash flood took out my half-sandwich, the owner gave me a new one for free. I tipped them well as is customary in such a situation, a real NY understanding. I’ll be coming back here for sure.
The Flatbush Avenue sandwich was awesome. Crunchy breading on the chicken cutlets really gave it a fun texture. The only improvement would be a little salt and an acidic ingredient like balsamic glaze.
Great sandwiches. Had corned beef on the brioche (called the 8th street) and loved it. Also had a great time talking to the guys working there as well. Highly recommended!
This is the best sandwich place in Brooklyn and the owner and staff are the best. Try out their salmon sandwich and shrimp sliders. And the muffins are to die for. This is Staceeeeey
Just came here today for the first time, and I know it will be my go-to lunch spot. This is perhaps my new favorite eatery in all of Brooklyn. They have a huge variety of sandwiches to choose from, and all seem amazing. Freshly baked banana Nutella muffins smelled absolutely divine. The service was fast and the sandwiches are enormous, and aren’t super expensive.
This is not just my Favorite "Sandwich Shop" .. it is my favorite place to eat..
The menu is filled with just magnificent eats! … then it gets better, The daily specials this Top Chef comes up with, Chicken cordon blue... roast pork with apples... and on Wednesdays the MOST Amazing Meatloaf ever !! I have it with pecorino fries. I look forward to Wednesday more that Fridays now :-).
Best Burgers, great Muffins. worth a trip from Anywhere !... wow I forgot to mention the roast beef Start with the # 1
Amazing quality sandwiches crafted with care. I’ve recently been ordering from this lovely little spot and the sandwiches are huge, really creative, and delicious. The staff is also friendly and it’s just a nice local spot. Highly recommend!
The best sandwich shop in New York city. The guys running the place are so cool and friendly. The sandwich is delicious. You can tell they use quality ingredients. Portions are huge! Highly recommend the Flatbush Avenue, and the meatball parm special when they have it
Been hearing how great this place was, but I was not expecting it to be this good. Stopped here with my dad; I had a burger, he had a roast beef sandwich with jus. Wow! If this place doesn't end up on a Food Network show, then something's wrong. The quality is super high, the sandwiches & burgers are huge & soo tasty. Add them to your Brooklyn "Must Go Here" list!
Very tasty sandwiches made from fresh and quality ingredients. They don’t skimp on the fillings! There is a great variety of selection on the menu all named after places in Brooklyn. Staff is also super friendly and helpful. Highly recommend for a quick but satisfying meal!
Love me a good sandwich spot. This place has the local-owned vibe and they’ll take care of you. The Moma of the place cans her own pickles (I believe bread and butter pickles) which is that hint of love that adds to a sandwich. You can also buy the pickles there. Sandwiches are good quality and you can order ahead and pick up no problem, very quick. They also have a 10 (?) stamp card.
The owner/workers are all so kind and friendly here! The sandwiches are incredible and baked goods are exceptional-- but the people who work there just really make my day with how considerate and pleasant they always are. Truly a gem in our neighborhood!
If you're looking for some bombing @ss sandwiches you gotta give this place a shot. Guaranteed you'll be coming back for all their sandwiches!! I've tried three of them and my favorite one is the Montgomery Place (chicken cutlet, NY State cheddar cheese, butter pickles, etc.) Give Mark a chat while you're there, he's super friendly and warm. This place is my favorite sandwich shop in the area and I look forward to going every time I'm in the neighborhood.
Great locally owned neighborhood sandwich shop with an extensive menu and super-friendly staff. The sandwiches marry traditional NYC deli with higher end culinary experimentation. Secretly a great place to grab coffee and a muffin on your way to the train, too.
I have had just about every sandwich they make here and they are all absolutely delicious. The muffins and breakfast sandwiches are amazing as well. The owners and staff are all awesome. I highly recommend this place for the food and the people making it.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes