Best Shepherd's pie in Brooklyn

3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Wicked Monk
The Wicked Monk
84/100 (1414 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Irish
American
Bar
Pub
American
Bar
Irish
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Dublin Crab Cakes
Bloody Mary
Sliders
Shrimp Dumplings
Fish & Chips
Chicken Wings
Salad
Steak Sandwich
Salmon
Chicken and Waffles
Fish & Chips
Potato Leek Soup
Buffalo Mac and Cheese
Shepherd's pie
Honey Sriracha Wings
Beer
Fried Calamari and Shrimp
irish breakfast
Gaelic Steak
Burger
Mini Shapherd's Pie
Pan Seared Maple Glazed Salmon
Fish & chips
Wicked Monk Hamburger Platter
Chocolate Lava Cake Made
Sit down
American
Irish
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Reservations
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"It’s a lovely gem with a blurred segregation between restaurant and bar. Choose your own adventure. The medieval church aesthetic adds a unique..."
Sandy Dex
"I came here on a Sunday afternoon with my family the food was good but it wasn’t great it was missing some seasoning but overall good. The..."
Gabriella
"Fives all around. Stepped into a unique and amazing atmosphere. Dark wood and stained glass, huge open space but separate bar and dining area. The..."
Doc
"This is one of the best bar/restaurants in the neighborhood. Friendly staff, a generous beer selection, and a surprisingly good kitchen make for a..."
Tim-Ryan O'Kane
"Great spot for an Amstel and a cup of potato leek soup. Best meal I’ve had in a long time! Plenty of televisions too if you like..."
Sarah Slattery
"I always passed wicked monk and wanted to stop in and finally did with my wife and friend last Saturday. I love there decor and the feel of old..."
Krammer Avillan
"This is one of my favorite pubs in the area because they have an awesome selection of craft beers. The staff isn’t super knowledgeable on the..."
Megan Siegle
"I would recommend a reservation. The tables filled up quickly. Service was very fast and a team effort. Multiple attentive people made sure our table..."
Marc Maynard
"Had a good time, atmosphere was relaxed and friendly, sports on the TV's, food was great, really enjoyed the Philly Mac and cheese, chicken pot pie..."
Kenny “kenichiwa” Wong
"Moved to the neighborhood this past year always pass by here & been wanting to come in. Stopped by yesterday for some take out. Ordered a 3 cheese..."
bronte toledo
Buckley's Bar & Restaurant
Buckley's Bar & Restaurant
77/100 (1100 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
American
Pub
American
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Lobster
French Onion Soup
Chicken Francaise
Pie a La Mode
Prime Ribs of Beef
Shepherd's pie
Broiled Atlantic Salmon
Beer
Broiled Half Chicken
corona
Having a Pint Before the Quarantine
Scallop
Omelette of the Day Pepps Onions Bacon and Cheddar
Fried calamari
Pumpkin Pie with Whipped Cream
Martini
Burger
Roast Loin of Pork
Shrimp Appetizer
Filet Mignon
Fish
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Television
Reservations
Seating
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"First timer; celebrated my birthday. The atmosphere was terrific. The staff was attentive and friendly. The food was phenomenal. I definitely..."
Mitchell Philip Karp
"I was skeptical of this place after reading the mixed reviews. I attended a wedding yesterday and I must say my experience was GREAT. The food,..."
Scottie Scott Rorie
"Never went to a party there before. Staff members were young yet so professional and polite. Food was good too especially the cocktail hour. Room..."
Susan Miller Rosenblum
"Been here many times and have not been disappointed. Last night I had a chicken dish at a 70 birthday party. It was awesome. They are very..."
Marion Fusco
"Have been going here for years and had my wedding there two years ago. Jimmy and his staff are great! Always a great meal and good..."
Liz Meyer Mattina
"I'm at my dear friend's grandson's first birthday party. Great place. Lovely staff. Kathy Scott you are so welcoming!!! And the best omelette I ever..."
Marla Libowitz Nissinboim
"Great venue, great food, and an exceptional staff as a whole and individually attentive to every need and request. What a wonderful time they gave..."
Joe Naughton
"Midwood High School Football team had their banquet on March 27th, the service was wonderful. The food was delicious. The staff was attentive and..."
Yolanda Price
"It's my favorite place the service and the attention that they give is impeccable I love Kathy and Jennifer and everybody there I won't have a party..."
Karen Botti
"Had my daughters shower there last night and I can't even begin to say how great it was. Cathy and Jennifer were amazing. Made everything seamless...."
Jackie Goodwin- Pandolfo
"Great place great food good for all types of..."
Martin Papo Swing Arroyo
"Considerate, good service and extraordinary food. Great place to hold an event..."
Kathryn M Keane Ea
"This is a great restaurant. The place is big and homey. The bar area feels like home. The party rooms are big and fit a lot of people. The servers..."
Aksinya Kostyrkina
"The salted Carmel martini...what? Amazing. The cocktails all had an interested twist on the classics. The bar food was stellar and the entrees were..."
Robert Martin
"The servers and management are very attentive. All the meats overall are good. The temperature of one was a bit over. The person didn’t want to..."
Andrew Moy
"Went for a lovely dinner with friends last night. Had the fresh tuna salad. It was amazing. They even had live music that was..."
Susan Ayers
"One of my favorite local spots. Food is reliably delicious and well priced. They were closed during the day for a while, but since lunch came back,..."
Daniel Eckman
"Nice local Pub and restaurant. Food was good and service was very nice. Has been around for awhile and probably will last even..."
Ed Pessutti
"Very shocking to never have know such a restaurant existed in my area. You would normally find these places in Manhattan. But as always: decided to..."
Brian Edwards
"I got the prime rib...it was amazing. Even the appetizers here are great, and the wine was pretty good. I recommend making reservations if you are..."
Cavalo760
"The food is so good and there is a good place to celebrate. Can have a party here. We enjoy in the..."
JJ Cui
"Everything's perfect here. Good food and good music on..."
Fabio Campos
Mcmahon's Public House
Mcmahon's Public House
77/100 (1334 ratings)
Restaurants
Bars & Pubs
Irish
Bar
Pub
Dinner
Lunch
Fish & Chips
Shepherd's pie
Cannoli
Beer
Buffalo Wings
Guinness
Bangers and Mash
Cider
Triple Decker Club
Irish Nachos
Balvenie
Irish Breakfast Plate
Manhattan Bourbon
Shot Hennessy VSOP
Old Fashioned Knob Creek Rye
Seltzer w Orange Bitters
Grilled Chicken Wrap and Fresh Cut Fries
McMahon's Burger with Fries
Dry Martini
Beef Sandwich
Sit down
Irish
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"First time here to experience "authentic" Fish and Chips that was yummy. Wings and fresh cut fries were great. My McMahon Burger needed a lil..."
Vicki Mitchell
"Great place to grab a drink before a game at Barclay's Center. We didn't eat so I can't leave a review on the food, but from what I heard, it is..."
Brandon Brewis
"For some reason, I've never had a bad experience at Irish Pubs. The food is generally what you would expect. This place was busy, and the staff was..."
Ms. Dee
"Went there to watch the Jets & Giants game yesterday with a few friends. Great atmosphere, plenty of screens, and the wings were tasty. Very good,..."
Not J B
"Great place to stop in. Guinness was poured well, fish and chips were yummy and they had some decent gluten free options. There was live music for a..."
Maria O’C
"Came here before a nets game at Barclays. Super full even on a Monday & it was fun! Cocktails are priced right, tons of seating, and quick..."
Avani Tandon
"One of the best Irish bars in Brooklyn. Great food and beer selection, with brilliant live music. Definitely worth a..."
Aidan Q
"Absolutely Beautiful place inside, with awesome staff and great food! Big selection of beer on tap. I didn't go upstairs which I will checkout out..."
Laurie Quinn
"Even though it was packed, the owner McMahon sat us quickly and was so welcoming. Our food and drinks were great. Will go..."
Jen Zelinger
"Great place to go before concerts in the Barclay. Great service and they set the mood with the..."
Monica Brandes
"This is an outstanding pub in Brooklyn, quick and efficient service, the food is always delicious, and very easy to get to. Located less than a block..."
Julian Zuniga
"Great sports bar, they show the Premier League soccer games even morning ones. Drinks and coffee are good. The breakfast food not so..."
Roxana Guerra
"very solid service, both bartender & waiter were attentive. being a group of 5, we had a table in the back. food and drinks were also quite solid and..."
Gil W
"Love the staff! We had a private party and it turned out to be a really awesome time. The staff was great!! The food was delish. I donwish we would..."
DIAMOND GIRL
"Down to earth Irish pub with a big menu. The burgers are good and I also liked the fish and..."
Peter Stolarski
"Phenomenal pub food, like the real kind. The burger I had was juicy, flavorful, and made me want to try every dish on the menu! Highly..."
Nichole W.
"Great customer service. Food and the drinks were great. 2 levels to..."
Helena Crump