Best Pepperoni Pizza Slice in Brooklyn

5 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Best Pizza
Best Pizza
87/100 (3158 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Fast Food
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Veggie Pizza Slice
Zeppoles
Italian Combo
Romaine Salad
White Slice
Garlic Knots White Pizza Veggie Pizza
Salad
Seasonal Vegetable Grandma Slice
Pizza with Caramelized Onion and Mushroom
Meatballs
Pizza Slice of Pizza
Margarita pizza
Pepperoni Slice Beer
Sixpoint - Sweet Action
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Garlic bread
Meatball Side 5
Cheese Pizza Slice
Vegetable Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Sit down
Italian
Fast food
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"This is everything you want from a neighbourhood Pizza shop. They are welcoming, the place is warm and the food is great. Ordered the grandma slice..."
Cory Parsons
"I've been here a bunch of times whenever I'm in the city. It definitely lives up to its name! I haven't found any pizza that is as fresh and crisp as..."
Cameron Pratt
"One of best brooklyn pizza. Thin crust and crispy base. Slightly sweet sauce. They are always putting pizzas in the oven so your slice(s) will be..."
Wesley Chan
"One of the best pizzas that we tried on our pizza crawl in NY. Delicious and crispy crust, tasty sauce, and I loved the way the homemade mozzarella..."
Mujahid Sachoo
"Best pizza was pretty dang good! I really liked the grandma slice because of the saucy tomatoes. I thought my white slice was a little dry honestly..."
Bennett Smith
"Had this on my bucket list for a long time now and it exceeded my expectations. From the food, to the decor, and that 100 year old oven place was..."
Adam Arciola
"This place is dope! Pizza was nice and thin( if you like that sorta style) the sauce had a subtle sweetness to it and there was a lil basil leaf..."
Rozlin001
"As the name says, it really is the best pie around. Tastes like a classic new york slice, but elevated to the next level. Wishing them continued..."
Alex Aguirre
"The tiny shop was definitely a vibe with some outdoor seating as well. We got the white pizza and it had sesame seeds on the crust which was really..."
Susie Su
"Wow. They did not bluff when they said best pizza. Probably the best pizza I have had so far. The white pizza in particular is on another..."
Shant Rising
"The taste is very good. However it is not Brooklyn authentic pizza, and I know this by asking for a " plain " slice and they responded by saying "..."
Frank Vistocci
"I visited new York for a week and visited about 10 pizza places. I think I put Best Pizza second on my list behind Di Fara, slice was delicious. The..."
Centretard Tardcentre
"This was the third and the last stop of the day for my NYC pizza tour. Located in the pizza capital neighbourhood of Williamsburg, BK; would suggest..."
Sanchit Kamath
"Great pizzas with a nice and thin dough. I really liked the white slice. Pepperoni and grandma were decent as well. Finished 2 slices with ease..."
Aditya Gupta
"Been here a few times and always a consistent great slice of NY style pizza. Great choice if you are in..."
Brian Zientek
"I love this place and have been coming for over a decade. In addition to their tasty wood fired pizza, their secret delights are salads and side..."
Ari Taub
"I loved the Sicilian and Grandma Slice. So so good. Very high quality ingredients and the dough was super light, airy and crisp. The NY slice was..."
Sahil Singh
Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza
Il Porto Ristorante & Wood Fired Pizza
87/100 (5345 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Lunch
Dinner
Spaghetti Vongole
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Homemade Tiramisu
Garlic Knots
Gelato
Salad
Pesto
Grandma Pizza Slice
Rack of Lamb Special
Soup
Penne with Shrimp and Asparagus
Sangria
Bianca Pizza & IL Porto Pizza
Cozze In Umido
Beer
Crab Crouquettes
Bread
Chicken and Sausage Roll
Fried calamari
Italian Mule
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Amazing pizza! I got a slice of the grandma pizza and it changed how I view pizzas. It’s a new favorite for me. Crispy, yet chewy crust and a..."
Christopher Walker
"Great setting. Very lively atmosphere. Had a quick chicken and sausage pizza roll. It was prepared just right and filling.The feel of fresh crust is..."
Hemkalyan Pandit
"My personal experience is from my frequent visits to IL Porto in Brooklyn, NY, and the fact that I am one of the vocal entertainers there on most..."
PAT TANDY
"Love their pizza crust. Excellent marinara..."
rop vazquez
"This place has very distinctive "home-made" atmosphere and their food tastes as they chef is some old Italian grandmother. The portions are generous..."
Alex Serebrov
"I have been to many Italian restaurants all across the city. I put IL Porto in with the best of them. If you are looking for an Italian restaurant in..."
Michael Lanzi
"I dropped by to get a slice of pizza. I love their grandma’s pizza. It had the right balance soft dough with a crispy base. Eat it while it’s hot..."
Saveur Spot
"Absolutely beautiful restaurant. The service was impeccable, and the pizzas were so fresh and perfect. The owner came out and spoke with us for..."
Alex Moore
"All around A+. Food is made w quality, Service is very attentive. Live Jazz. Amazing cocktails and very cute atmosphere much try. Oh also get the..."
Legend
"Amazing Authentic Italian food nestled in Clinton Hill Brooklyn. Live jazz on Fridays and Saturdays from 7 to 10. Their menu offers fresh homemade..."
anthony david
"We came in to the pizzeria for a slice but ended up sitting in the restaurant for the live music instead. Our waitress Kelsey was super sweet and..."
hello joe
"Great place for a quick slice of Pizza or a nice dinner (2 sections of the restaurant). Great pizza. Pastas are good too. Spinach Salad is my..."
Kristian Gunn
"Great food, friendly service, and very clean establishment. Excellent wine and cocktails selection. My girlfriend loved the rack of lamb come with..."
Mostafa Mohamed
"The owner Vinny and son Sal make you feel like at home. Their food is excellent. Granma pizza out of this world. Will return again for..."
Carmelo Mazzaferro
"Very nice restaurant. Home made quality food. Much cheaper and better than engine oil and with cheese sold at liberty Pizza on myrtle ave just one..."
roman abramov
"I was here years ago, about 9 maybe 🤔 The pizza is or was absolutely delicious and if still run by the same owner he was extremely friendly! I was..."
Sheridan Friesen
"This is the spot for Brooklyn pizza pastas. Owners behind the counter/bar, lots of regulars, neighborhood staple, boxes stacked to the moon. Old..."
Howard Chang
"What amazing place. From the Wood fired Pizza to the specialty Italian dishes and down to the live jazz, this place Rocks! Their amazing cocktail..."
Vincent David
Grotta Azzurra Pizzeria
Grotta Azzurra Pizzeria
83/100 (532 ratings)
Restaurants
Lunch
Dinner
Neopolitan Round Cheese Pizza
Meatball Parmigiana Dinner
Calzone
Pizza by the Slice of Pepperoni
Scrambled eggs
Round Sfincione Sicilian Pizza
Mashroom Pizza by the Slice
Fresh Made Chicken Roll
Spaghetti with Garlic and Oil
Hawaiian Pizza
Vegetarian Pizza
White Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
Baked Ziti
Vodka Sauce Pizza
Andrea's Baby Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Smilling Pizza
Smilling Pizza
82/100 (314 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Brick-Oven Style Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Garlic Knots
Empanada
Chicken roll
Pizza Bianca
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Sicilian Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slices
White Slice
Round Cheese Pizza
American
Dinner
Lunch
"My wife and I were coming from the hospital and were very hungry after our ultrasound appointment, we saw the pizza ship and said why not pizza..."
Damian Padilla
"Great place We do order from this place for a long time now. I always went here while I was growing up with family and we continue to go/ order..."
Lisa Seiler
"So happy it's still here when so many places are gone! Pizza's still..."
Lori Maloney
"We did a Brooklyn Pizza taste test, and the concensus among our group gave Smiling Pizza a 9 out of 10. The Pizza was really good. We all enjoyed the..."
Lisa Neal
"Love their pizza! Excellent service. Everything is fresh. Has bathroom. Good..."
Gabrielle Sheridan
"We were walking out of Prospect Park. We saw the sign here, and we just went in. It was lucky. We ate a piece of pizza. The pizza dough was very..."
Heo Heo Heo
Sbarro
Sbarro
74/100 (1326 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Lunch
Dinner
NY Pepperoni Slice
Tomato Cucumber Salad
Baked Ziti with Meatballs
Cajun Tilapia Fish
Veggie Pizzaand Cheese Pizza
Baked Ziti Honey BBQ Wings Halal with Rice
Rotisserie Chicken
Flour a Bowl of Unattended Flour
Garlic bread
Baked Ziti Steamed Mixed Vegetables Con Chicken Marsala
pasta salad
Beef Meat Ball
Slice of Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Extra Cheese Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Baked Chicken
Roman Pizza
Not Just Pizzas Sbarro Offers Stuffed Strombolis Too
"When I went to Sbarro’s at Kings Plaza I didn’t expect to find the best pizza I’ve ever had. Finished my slice within minutes and had to come..."
Eweghana Forster
"omg this pizza was so crunchy and cheesy put if it was hotter it would have a nice cheese pull but i def..."
abby kay
"The pizza's taste was unlike any other that I usually eat in my home country but it was tasty. The surroundings were clean and I loved that there was..."
Kathy Ann Halls
"I had been going to Kings Plaza for years and had seen this restaurant since it is literally at the entrance of the mall but never given a chance to..."
Salman Iftikhar
"Tasty pizza but just..."
Matthew Walsh
"Alhamdulliah halal food in Brooklyn kings plaza. 2nd time come to here. Delicious..."
Tajul Islam
"This place been in KP for many years and the food is good and it's a quite bite or you can sit and chill for a..."
Msredbone
"Funny enough this location is the best sbarro I’ve tried by far. I’m never disappointed it consistently is better than you..."
James Kim
"Its been a long time since I had a slice. It was tasty I enjoyed it. For shopping mall food not bad. The service was pleasant. Only thing tour..."
Michele Hill
"I visit this place very often for my,bake ziti an Meatball , I love..."
Leonardo Grant