Best Garlic Bagel with Cream Cheese in Brooklyn

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Montague Street Bagels
Montague Street Bagels
80/100 (2645 ratings)
Quick Bites
Bakeries
American
Fast Food
Fast food
American
Breakfast
Lunch
Pumpernickel Bagel
Garlic Bagel with Cream Cheese
Sausage Egg and Cheese on Everything Bagel
Bagels
Bagel Lox Cream Cheese Tomatoes Onions
Nasty Bagel
Onion Bagel with Bacon Cheddar
Bagel with Meat and Cheese
Salmon Bagel
Sit down
Fast food
American
Reservations
Delivery
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Nothing fancy. Little underground shop with fresh bagels starting at $1.75 as of writing. Egg and cheese was good but nothing..."
Gabe Shakour
"Real simple place! Order your bagel and get going. Generous in their cream cheese! Got a plain toasted bagel with vegetable cream cheese, super soft..."
sarah gafur
"Bagels are generally really great. Sometimes the line is super long and it can take a little while to get your order, but the wait has never felt..."
Casey ROSS
"The sausage egg and cheese on an everything bagel was awesome. The everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese also. And loaded with cream cheese..."
Raddigan Bros Noise Experience
"Just ate there for the first time. Very delicious. They have so many different cheeses. The pumpkin, veggie cream, and jalapeño were all so..."
emily marshall
"Great bagels, great prices and they really put good amount of filling. Definitely will come when..."
Elena Terlyga
"This place is not fast, but damn is it worth it. If you're in a hurry and you see even 1 other person waiting skip it though (lol for real). But if..."
Laura Wright
"Have come here a bunch of times, got the pumpernickel bagel with sundried tomato and veggie cream cheese once. It tasted nice as..."
Bhakti Dalvi
"got a whole wheat bagel with egg/cheese/tomato for $4.50. bagel was huge, chewy, with a great exterior. super friendly people. no service fee if you..."
victoria tan
"Best New York bagels. When you enter, at the back, you can the bagels on the making. Worth the weekend..."
Majo Salgado
"This place was great! Not only were the bagels delicious, but the bagel breakfast sandwiches were absolutely amazing. The egg was high quality and..."
Brittany Harvey
"First bagel place I’ve been to in NYC and it’s so good I’m not sure I want to try anywhere else or just keep getting bagels from..."
Kaju
"Surprisingly good bagels Took smoked salmon and it was delicious Great location very close to Brooklyn bridge..."
איתמר נחליאל
"5/5 Quality of Food 4/5 Quantity of Food 5/5 Service 5/5 Value (Price to Food + Service) Good bagel, tasted fresh but just a tad bit pricey for me...."
Jason Kwan
"Drove an hour when in the NY area to get a bagel from here, fresh, filled with flavor and delicious aroma, a 20yr wait in between stops, worth the..."
Brett Golden
"Low key neighborhood gem. Expect loaded bagels and no frills..."
Asriel Low