Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Buckeye Lake

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Pizza Cottage
Pizza Cottage
92/100 (3064 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Salad
BLT
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Wow, great food. The waitresses are the hardest working I’ve ever seen. Food comes fast and they have the best price for Draft I’ve ever..."
Steven Wells
"Ordered tonight and we got a BLT pizza instead of our Pepperoni pizza. They called us and immediately wanted to make the situation right, not only..."
Catey Walker-Hoisington
"Live music with great food and cold beer on the patio is always a great evening. The staff is..."
Tauni Graham
"My wife and I went there last night and had a great meal of pizza and wings. Our server was very attentive and helpful and we were very pleased with..."
Tony Schmalstig
"Thank girls who waited on the baseball team and their family were excellent. The pizza was fast and hot. Great..."
Theresa Miller
"Had a great personal pizza. Just the right size. I usually have wings which are excellent but decided to try the pizza. Nice crisp..."
Jackie Johnson
"Just like old times! My boyfriend, myself and his son came from Bladensburg on a whim to see the lake and get some pizza from the original Pizza..."
Tricia Capadona
"Always the best BLT Pizza in the world! OMG!!! I wish I lived closer or that you'd all open up a Cottage here in Cincinnati. We are in dire need..."
Connie Fix
"We love your place it rocks !!! Food is always fantastic and we wouldn't know what to do if we didn't have Frankie there to baby sit us!!! Lol!!! We..."
Shane T. Perkins
"Always the best!Great food!Very friendly staff!Band was..."
Judi Bradley
"We have been going here for many years. Excellent pizza, bread sticks , subs, salad and spaghetti. We have NEVER been disappointed with anything..."
Dorothy Holdcroft
"5 minutes right now in wait for food, understandable. Straws can be quite “. Expensive “ maybe. But mine broke with barely and rotation of it...."
Parker Flowers
"We were a party of 10 on Friday night this past weekend. I have never really been a fan of the Pizza Cottage, But I am highly impressed with their..."
Bre Dolan
"The staff here is great and the food is consistently good. The current owner has yet to restore the last two of the six beers that were originally on..."
Kathleen Severance
"It wasn't crowed we just went in and found a seat. The order takers were right there "fast" my italian sub was super. Had a side of fries crisp..."
scott combs
"Always A Great Place To Eat! Servers Were..."
Tonya Beish