This is a smaller version inside the Loves Gas Station. But is the classic Omaha Pizza. As usual there are a lot of toppings. I ate the thick crust but they do have a new thin crust. I've always enjoyed Godfather's Pizza
Stopped here for pizza and was not disappointed.
Got the classic, and while I am not usually a fan of onions on pizza (they're usually sliced too large and therefore a bit slimy) they were cut pretty small and definitely were not slimy, the entire pizza was great.
The crust is thick, slightly crunchy with what seems to be a garlic butter on it, but it is not too thick where it is hard to eat it.
The ingredients seem to be decent quality - thinking mostly of the meats and cheese here - and generously distributed over the entire pizza. No weird little lumps of one topping, or slices that were missing any of the toppings.
We also got a large order of cheese sticks which turned out to pretty much be a pizza crust loaded with cheese and the same butter with a hint of garlic.
Over all the food was great and we would definitely stop here the next time we head through Buena Vista.
Best pizza!! I wish there were still in Colorado Springs.
It has been many many years since I've had God father's pizza and then it was very good. I didn't expect this to be nearly as good so many years later, am Express location and in a gas station. To my surprise, it was as good as I remembered and maybe even better! The two ladies behind the counter were both very nice and accommodating,
Since my college days, Godfathers has been one of my favorite pizza joints. I couldn't find them for a while. This one is at a Loves fuel stop but tastes great just the same. There are always personal sized pies ready but a larger one will take a while. Order by phone for that. Also Chester's Chicken is here. This is good fast food for a fuel stop. Friendly help, as you would expect for a small, Colorado town. I shall return
Pizza was great! Friendly staff
I love Godfather's Pizza. We used to have it in Colorado Springs but now it's up in Buena Vista Colorado. I was so happy to discover it so when we go to the mountains we make this one of our dinners. The staff is extremely nice.
Not gonna lie, I expected this pizza to suck. 🙈🤣 Imagine my surprise when it turned out to be the best "chain" pizza Ive had in years! We also ordered online and when we showed up to pay, they applied a promo we didnt even know they had and it dropped our bill by half! She didnt have to do that, we never would have known but thats integrity! Thanks for the delish pie! We will order again the next time we visit!
Alpha and Omega Business Solutions
+5
My wife and I try to stop here every time we are in Buena Vista. You can get food, beverages, and order pizza 24 hours a day. we are usually there in the evening or late at night. The staff is pleasant and friendly. The pizza is really delicious too.
This is great! Pizza! We are local and have been here several times. The food rocks and the employees are great at customer service as well. We recommend stopping by when you need some pizza.
The Real Eugene Shepherd
+5
I have not had a slice of godfather's Pizza since the 80s. We were on vacation in the southern sangre the Cristo valley on our way back home and I had to get myself a personal Pizza. And one for the kids to share. This location is attached to a gas station. we found out you can either pay the person that makes the pizza for you or go to the same cashier that you bought your gas from.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes