Best Halibut in Buffalo

6 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Hutch's
Hutch's
88/100 (3724 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Late Night
Lamb chops
Salad
Escargot
Crab
Scallops
Cheesecakes
Oyster
Steak Sandwich
Calamari
Ice Cream
Fish
Risotto
Prosciutto
Mussels
Sandwiches
Gelato
Jambalaya
Tuna
Ceviche
Calamares
Steak Tartare
Salmon
Shrimp
Lamb
Beef
Pesto
Chowder
Cheesecake
Lobster
Halibut
Eggplant
Ribs
Pasta
Sit down
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
"This is one awesome restaurant! We were fortunate during the last night of our vacation in Buffalo to be taken by friends to Hutch's. From the minute..."
Bill Barnett
"I don’t often make a point of saying things like this, but we eat at a lot of wonderful restaurants in Buffalo, but hands down, Hutches is the..."
Erin Kent
"Absolutely love this place! Calamari app is to die for and the seafood risotto is absolutely mouth watering. Wonderful place with amazing staff...."
Anjelica Cmiel
"Great restaurant with a wonderful staff. They are masters at soft shell crab. We like to sit at the bar and always get great..."
Joan Horn
"This was our first trip to Hutch's. Great bar, friendly knowledgeable staff. Excellent service. Our delicious meal was perfect from appetizer to..."
Mary Tortorici- Wujek
"This is by far the best restaurant for red meat. Their tenderloin is the best meal ever. The 5 sipper is the best way to begin your Saturday date..."
Kym Barringer-Weibel
"Amazing food and amazing service! I would recommend this place to..."
Morgan Gibeault
"What a wonderful place to eat. The food was outstanding and the service didn't miss a beat. I would highly recommend..."
Linda Strasser Hale
"Holding onto its supremacy as the leader of the pack in Buffalo restaurants. Impeccable service and the finest menu. New Years Eve could not have..."
Charles Calvello
"The food was amazing. The only "complaint" would be the 45 minute wait even though we had reservations. But considering how good the food was it was..."
Jason Martinelli
"I went to Hutch's for my birthday. The food was absolutely phenomenal and the staff was very friendly, helpful and professional. We had a wonderful..."
Monica Lockhaven
"The fried soft shell crab was great! I loved it! Great staff, and a great atmosphere. I Will be here often! It Was a great way to end my graduation..."
Femi Robinson
"WOW!!! Our experience could not have been better! Excellent in every way, from the moment we arrived until the moment we left! Very accomadating,..."
Dinah LeBleu Laurich
"Fantastic dinner as always. Our family was in from out of town and loved it!!! Our server, Tyler was great !! This will alway be one of our favorite..."
Christine Kunzer Campanelli
"My husband Matt and I enjoyed a wonderful evening at Hutch's. We arrived early and the host offered to take my coat and walk us to the bar where we..."
Penny Goodenough McGuire
"The wait for our food was longer than expected but so worth it! So amazing I didn't have to use ..."
Dea Adams
"Server Michael was outstanding as was the food. Veal chop (per Michael's recommendation) and soft shell crab were beyond all expectations! Will be..."
Molly Camann Gioeli
"It was my first time dining here and it was because I assumed it would be way too expensive. My son who also happens to be a chef there has..."
Linda Rodney Connors
"The food and service are outstanding. Cozy and lovely dining area is also very..."
Catherine Burkhart
"Great food, great atmosphere. Server was very knowledgeable about menu. Definitely a favorite restaurant of..."
Karen Soos
"Great atmosphere and the stars are very friendly. The food is excellent there,one of my favourite places in..."
Barry Kennedy
"The food & the service was excellent, but the restaurant is very loud and the tables are very close to one..."
Carole Novak-Lewis
"Great food, high energy and service! Table position not ideal given overall noise..."
Wende Lyman
"This place never disappoints. Top notch food and service every..."
Erica Ambrose
"The best beef tenderloin au poise ever!! Ordered medium it was..."
Sheila Keenan Nathanson
"Best dining experience in Buffalo. Food is to die for and service was stellar. This is a MUST stop for any..."
Gordon N Amber Levenbaum
"Always enjoy this restaurant. Had a small mistake made with the leftovers. The waiter and staff went above and beyond to correct the issue and send..."
Chuck Basil
"This is a classic establishment which is much bigger than it looks. We had a table of six and were well catered to. They offer a nice wine list and..."
JADlabs
"Hutch's has been, and continues to be, in our top 3 restaurants in Buffalo.  It's consistently great and always makes it into my recommendation for..."
Jenn Nicken
"Excellent Upscale Dining. Hutch's is an overall excellent place, wonderful bar area with tons of character and a very good fine dining restaurant...."
Makefile
"Seafood Pasta. Very good, liked the zucchini and..."
Dmdiblasi
"One of my favorites.... I visited hutchs a few weeks back and had a seafood special and it was great. The service was great we had a nice young man..."
Carlyannla87
"What a wonderful dining experience! It came highly recommended by several "locals" in the area. My husband and I are from the food service industry..."
Lisa McPherson
"Timeless classic of WNY. Never a disappointment. Decor could use a facelift though. Food & service are top..."
S W
"My Top 10... Go there as often as I can, love the menu, service, and usually order whatever Seafood Special they are offering, as I know its as fresh..."
Lesa Cater
"The softshell crabs are the best anywhere! When these are in season, I try to go to hutches at least once a..."
Zina H
"Love it. My husband and I went to hutch's right around the beginning of December and we loved the food. We have been trying to make it to hutchs for..."
Mammabear45
"One of the BEST. FAB FAB FAB..."
Samantha K.
"Delicious Start To Finish. One of my favorite restaurants in Buffalo if not my favorite. You always get a quality meal, drink and the service tends..."
Eating Through Buffalo
"Believe the hype. It is that good. We have been meaning to go there for years, and finally dined there last Friday (get a reservation if you plan on..."
John S.
"I adore Hutch's, and don't think my review will shut the doors, BUT! Please servers, stop ''tbowing'' the specials to me, stop smelling like smoke,..."
Been In The Biz A Long Time
"Mmmm. They used to make THE MOST INCREDIBLE chevre cheese cake... its LOUD and the tables are ridiculously close to strangers but the food is out of..."
Kk
"Very good. Went for valentines day. Very nice dishes and nice feeling in the restaurant. The bar area was comfortable. overall a great..."
LewistonDiner90
"A good steak for the money. I've eaten at Hutch's about 10 times, and each time I went I ordered the Steak Frite, it is an 18oz Angus Ribeye that is..."
Jeremy Lewis
"Best Meal EVER. My girlfriends took me to Hutch's for my birthday- there were 9 of us. All I can say is we had the best meal any of us had ever..."
Rachael
"Service was excellent. Prices were moderate. Food was not the best ever, but decent. First time here so I'll definitely give it another try. Thumbs..."
Jesse Woomer
"Simply the BEST dining in Buffalo, NY!. My wife and I been frequenting Hutch's Restaurant in Buffalo, NY for quite some time now. From our very first..."
Meyerlights85
"Heaven on a plate. I ate at Hutch's the first week it opened. My best friend was visiting from LA (a Buffalo ex-pat) and somehow he had heard of it..."
Molly Quinn
"This place is fantastic. The outside is not much, but inside the chef is rock n the food! Lamb, steak and chicken were super with sauces that took..."
Paul
"This place is an excellent place to go to. The NY strip steak is highly recommended. Get their before your reservation so you can enjoy the bar..."
Banz
"Solid Quality!. Have not been since last fall but wanted to give them a plug. Great Buffalo atmoshere and GREAT food....makes for a nice night..."
Timbuck
"Very Yummy!. I used to live a block away and so I've eaten here quite a few times- every one of those times it has been delicious! This restaurant is..."
Christine
"Awesome. I have never had a bad meal here. Always good..."
Gosabres
"Hutchs is great. Get there jumbalia pasta and there..."
Fudge Dippers
"Another fabulous meal!. We dined @ Hutch's last evening and had yet another fabulous meal! Hutch and his staff have NEVER let us down. Last evening's..."
BW
"Great Value. One of my favorites. Excellent menu and dishes are very well prepared and presented. Not cheap but a bagain for fine dining. Too bad its..."
Bossbob
"Almost 1 month ago, Alli and I enjoyed our other meal of Local Restaurant Week at Hutch's. Since I started Buffalo Eats and started my general "food..."
Buffalo Eats
""Transcendent," explains the American Association of Food Journalists in its definition of a four-star restaurant, "a one-of-a-kind, world-class..."
Jeremy Horwitz
Oliver's Restaurant
Oliver's Restaurant
87/100 (1501 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
International
Contemporary
American
International
Contemporary
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Late Night
Duck
Oyster
Risotto
Tuna
Salmon
Filet Mignon
Shrimp
Halibut
Beef
Pesto
Lobster
Fish
Pork
Pasta
Ragu
Salad
Crab
Scallops
Sit down
American
International
Contemporary
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Wine and Beer
Television
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Mastercard
Full Bar
Accepts Visa
Free Wifi
Accepts American Express
Valet Parking
Reservations
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
"I chose Oliver's for my Birthday dinner last night, having never been there I was anxious to cross it off my list. The food superceded my..."
Kelly Sweeney
"Beautiful eclectic decor with nice original artwork...dark with low lights throughout the place....very romantic. My birthday dinner was one of the..."
Kathy Hall-zientek
"The best dining in the city! This classic restaurant continues to define the food scene in Buffalo. It holds its own against the finest NYC or LA..."
John Kopczynski
"The catering staff did an incredible job on my parents 50th Anniversary. The food was outstanding and staff was incredible. Highly recommend..."
Tom Rosenecker
"It was the most exquisite and outstanding food food in the region! Super highly recommend! It's worth every single..."
Me'chelle Woods-Jones
"Atmosphere is elegant...drinks were perfection.. I recommend the Desert Rose and the service and food was amazing! Great spot for a romantic..."
Brooke Kibrick
"Phenomenal service, Charlie was fantastic. The meal was perfect in every..."
Chris Walters
Sinatra's
Sinatra's
85/100 (734 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegan Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Late Night
Halibut
Meatballs
Lasagne
Pesto
Pork
Shrimp
Caponata
Lobster
Eggplant
Salad
Sit down
Italian
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Private Dining
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
Cattleguard Steakhouse & Saloon
Cattleguard Steakhouse & Saloon
85/100 (1653 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Steakhouse
American
American
Steakhouse
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Drinks
Scallops
Oyster
Salmon
Fish & chips
Fish & Chips
Halibut
Ribs
Surf And Turf
Shrimp
Sirloin Steak
French onion soup
Beef
Fish
Lobster
Pork
Salad
Crab
Sit down
American
Steakhouse
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Seating
Accepts Discover
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Dinner
Drinks
Mid-range
"Fantastic food and service! Friendly bartender that pours a great drink👍 The food was so delicious I forgot to take photos! Managed to take one of..."
Kaycee Gavin
"Our server was over the top professional and was very understanding with our food allergies steaks especially the prime where cooked perfectly to out..."
Matt Brown
"WOW! Great new owners have really stepped it up a notch ... was always a a fine quality dining experience but they beautifully remodeled but kept..."
M L Vanessa Vogel
"The Cattle Guard restaurant gave us what is probably the best meal out, that we’ve had in ages! We had their prime rib and it came at least an inch..."
Linda Rae Campbell
"Dan and Deb have outdone themselves time and time again. Always consistent, phenomenal food and service… hands down the best restaurant in Johnson..."
Margo Ford
"The food was excellent! I'm here in town for work. The staff was super busy but also very kind! We were still served in a timely manner. Will..."
Gabe Perez
"Traveling solo, looking for a good steak. I'll start by saying that if the Owner/Manager was not working I doubt anything would get done - she is..."
Jim Coach Krupke
Lombardo Ristorante
Lombardo Ristorante
85/100 (3886 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Salad
Prosciutto
Scallops
Gelato
Duck
Lamb
Oyster
Bruschette
Calamari
Pesto
Risotto
Fish
Calamares
Pork
Salmon
Shrimp
Halibut
Lobster
Tiramisu
Eggplant
Octopus
Pasta
Sit down
Italian
Validated Parking
Valet Parking
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Reservations
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Seating
Accepts American Express
Table Service
Street Parking
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Dinner
Lunch
Fine Dining
"This is a very special Italian restaurant and if you haven’t eaten there you should try it. If you have eaten there then you know what I am ..."
George Osborne
"Ristorante Lombardo is a beautiful romantic restaurant. The owners and staff pay attention to detail at every turn. Service is impeccable. The wait..."
Michael Franco
"This place is fantastic! The atmosphere is wonderful and I felt like I was in a Manhattan fine dining restaurant! The food was so delicious, fresh,..."
Katie Colligan Lowell
"Lombardo's is truly a five star experience. From the warm welcome you receive as you enter to the last bite of dessert, the staff take wonderful care..."
Shelby Max
"The setting is beautiful, the wait staff is great and there are plenty of them. The food is by far the best food in Buffalo. Great menu. My..."
Nancy Fitzmaurice
"Lombardos's has been a favorite for as long as I can remember. Although changes have been made inside and out, the quality of the food and the..."
Marilyn Snapp Wagner
"Holy moly. The food, the service, the atmosphere. Wow! I took my lady there tonight for her birthday dinner and I was truly blown away. They had such..."
Maddox Sargent
"Celebrated my birthday dinner last night and the food/restaurant/staff was absolutely incredible!! I have been looking for a good veal chop for years..."
Brittany Hyatt
"Another great dinner at Lombardo's last night!!!!!!! Wonderful food, lovely service!! It is indeed a special place!!!!!If you haven't been there,..."
Margot Glick
"We had lunch last Friday as a special Mother's Day gift from our son What a wonderful treat! To begin with We were happy to find a free parking Lot..."
Carmen Seminara
"I have been here a few times the food is always fantastic and the service is impeccable!!! I absolutely would recommend this..."
Andy Di Pietro
"We had a great time at Lombardo’s I would highly suggest sitting at the bar as John the bartender will make your night perfect!!! He made us the..."
Audrey Atwell
"Spectacular, superb, stupendous! We recently had a private event at Lombardo's for 29 people. We started with an assortment of appetizers, followed..."
Phyllis Spears
Bacchus Wine Bar & Restaurant
Bacchus Wine Bar & Restaurant
84/100 (4090 ratings)
Restaurants
Wine Bar
International
American
International
American
Vegan Options
Wine Bar
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Late Night
Cheesecake
Lobster
Crème Brulée
Pasta
Filet Mignon
Salad
Swordfish
Mac and cheese
Bouillabaisse
Halibut
Crab
Lamb
Ribs
Scallops
Pesto
Duck
Fish
Polenta
Calamari
Sandwiches
Tiramisu
Risotto
Bass
Mussels
Tuna
Cheesecakes
Calamares
Shrimp
BLT
Salmon
Beef
Prosciutto
Creme Brulee
Sit down
American
Wine Bar
International
Parking Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Reservations
Private Dining
Accepts American Express
Seating
Street Parking
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Valet Parking
Wine and Beer
Dinner
Fine Dining