Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Caldwell
11 restaurant menus in Caldwell, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"great express lunch. happy with portion and food was delicious! Very accommodating and..."
Lindsay Griesbach
"Waitress D is the best. Long hots are so delicious. Great food great service great..."
Stella Caraplis Mannino
"Excellent service and charming staff. Even lovely owner came over on our way out to make sure we were happy. Love love..."
Phyllis Latella
"My hubby loves thin crust pizza and he loved the "thinny thin" pie! Friendly staff and good service. We'll be..."
Mary Anne
"best pizza in the area, tucked away on a side street, with brick charming interior, id say its a no risk..."
Leanore Sparno
"I love this restaurant!!... First time i went with my friend that raved about the food so i figured i try it...best thing ever!!!... I've been there..."
Linda Mia
"Great food! Excellent service. Make sure you try the thin crust pizza and the..."
Jim Morris
"Angeloni's opened to great fanfare because the food was good, but also because Caldwell pizza lovers thought it a great alternative to Star closer to..."
Rick Hadsall
"Very very good.
Got everything half garlic
The grandma's stood out the best to me
And the appetizer meatballs with garlic.
But i switched the cheese..."
Mark Hoff
"Cute place. Very Italianesque. Service was excellent.
Plenty of parking in the area.
We started with the long hots, sausage and potatoes. This..."
Donna Viola
"Amazing pizza great service. Pizza was so good even my 3 year old had 2 full slices and she's not a big eater. We'll def be back..."
"Stopped in as I was nearby looking for a good pizzeria/restaurant. Did not disappoint! A really pretty outdoor seating area on a beautiful day is the..."
Jonathan Collins (Images by Jonathan)
"This place was on my last to try and I was happy that I went there, the staff was friendly. I ordered the dough roni pizza it was on point very..."
Kevin Gillespie
"Dough Artisan Pizzeria makes a thin, light, and crispy pizza. They have a pizza special every week too you can find on Instagram. For appetizers I..."
Jennifer
"Dough is always a favorite, even more so now with outdoor dining restrictions. Their patio is perfect and the staff is always friendly and eager to..."
John & Syl Gonzalez
"The food was good. I enjoyed the gnocchi, and my husband said the wild boar pizza was really good. The zucchini chips were nice and crispy. The..."
Jill Wade
"Full-flavored pizza and Italian fare. First time I've ever had pizza with Fra Diavolo which was delicious. The spot is BYOB and cozy. Fun restaurant..."
Daniel Reinke
"Pizza has a nice chewy texture with flavors of the fire oven. Lunch special prices are reasonable for the quantity of..."
"I've been meaning to check this place out for a long time and finally did. I now wish that I had done it sooner!
I tried a few things from their..."
Robert J Masiello
"Love love love Fresco!! Everything is great- lunch is fantastic! And I can not believe how fast delivery is!!! One would think they are making the..."
Maria Lombardi-Lomuscio
"Great food & very friendly staff!will definitely go..."
Barbara Ciccone
"Create-your-own-salad is the best. Chick peas, roasted brussels sprouts, feta, apples, beets...all on top of organic field greens. Get it chopped!..."
Erika Balestro Desimone
"Best salad I've had in a long time! Ingredients are fresh and high..."
Liz McLaughlin
"Love this..."
Susan Flatow Kruger
"This is a beautiful, delicious addition to the..."
Maria Barona Squilanti
"I really like it! Everyone is friendly and it's well organized. I've only had the salad- I very much like the way the choose your own salad is..."
Gabi DiAngelis
"Great $1.50 slice of pizza š! Convenient location. Friendly staff. Delicious pizza. What more could you ask for..."
Di
"Stopped here for a quick lunch while nearby at Caldwell U. Very nice place. Smelled delicious. Food looked great. Had a ffreshly made Cobb salad...."
Camp Clarke
"Nice place delicious food, the guy who makes pizza is friendly and accommodating. Good daily deals and..."
Jerry Nguyen
"The buffalo wings are amazing and the pizza is very underrated. One of my go to food places in..."
Jude Bazerman
"great place for pizza, sandwiches (cold or hot), calzones, and more! would definitely return. Chris is great - super friendly and personable. the..."
"Saturday night we decided to try a new pizza place in our area. We are fortunate enough to have SO many great ones, that some slip by.
We checked..."
Robert J Masiello
"Excellent!! All our SuperBowl guests were blown away with the veggie and plain pies. Special praise from me on the gluten-free pie! GF is not easy to..."
Sharlene Schmidt Vichness
"First timer for this place. Ordered a cheese pie and a chicken cheese roll. Wow!!!!! Amazing great sauce. We order pizza once a week and I plan on..."
Danielle Marquart
"Really good pizza combinations. I will be going back on my next..."
Peter Agliata
"I went there for the 1st time yesterday. There were 3 specialty pizzas, I had one slice of each. All were excellent, I liked the "Drunken Grandma" (..."
John V. Lytle
"Spectacular pizza, square pie is amazing. Canāt wait to go..."
Barry Geltzeiler
"one of the best pies..."
Ralph Perna
"My favorite Pizza in town. Never disappointed. Always pleasant friendly people at counter. Your the best Tony..."
Joanne Milia
"His pizza is the best in the Caldwell area.A small hidden gem in the..."
Ralph Franco
"The Best Pizza in town! Their Neopolitana is amazing! You owe it to yourself to try..."
Jonathan Fonke
"Tony D's is one of the celebrated pizzeria's in Caldwell. Tucked around the corner from the community pub Cloverleaf Tavern, you might be forgiven..."
Rick Hadsall
"It All Starts with your first interaction behind the counter and this was one of the Best with the pleasant Andrea running the show. She talked shop..."
Chuck Mound
"I was very very impressed!! They had my pie ready for me at exactly 510 when I asked for, the thickness was perfect to me. The taste reallyyyy..."
Kammy Parekh
"Unbelievable Pizza at this place, we called an hour prior to going because the pizza Lina takes an hour, it is well worth waiting for, absolutely..."
Debra Tucci
"A really wholesome pizza slice made to perfection ! You canāt go wrong with a āDrunken..."
Spondon Kundu
"Best pizza in the area. Always go grandma pie. Havenāt had anything else on their menu cause their pizza is so..."
Lorie Continelli
"Great pizza! Definitely on the best in the area. Extremely nice people. Can't go wrong at Tony..."
"So many yummy options to choose.. The cupcakes especially, were delicious.. Restaurant, Bakery, and Lounge, all under one roof.. Service was also..."
Hema K
"This is one of my go to spots for a casual dinner or a grandiose celebration event. The food is excellent; fresh and always plentiful. The service..."
Mary P
"Great atmosphere and great flower. Definitely a must to stop..."
Dior Ostrozubi
"Clean and welcoming location. Friendly and courteous staff. Had the Cozze (pasta and mussels); only one word to describe it...deeelicious. Great..."
Ben Hdez
"place is consistently good, food, wine and service. great for family get togethers and birthday dinners, dining areas have lots of space, you don't..."
Brian Maurer
"Visited for a large group wedding rehearsal dinner. Service and food both first rate. The adjoining shops for pastry and food were overwhelming. ..."
Veal Principessa with Sliced Eggplant Tomato & Mozzarella
Pasta
Malbec
Salad
Sardella
Scallops
Calamari
Calamares
Cheesecake
Cheesecakes
Lasagne
Sit down
Italian
Takeout
BYOB
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Mario and his entire staff are fantastic the food is top notch the veal saltimbocca is excellent and made following traditional recipe, many..."
George Depaul
"My family and I came here for a special occasion and it did not disappoint. We will definitely be back - honestly can't say enough good things about..."
Duane Phillips
"Amazing food & atmosphere! Mario & his staff were..."
Shawn Foley
"Great local restaurant with ample parking. Don't have to drive into Montclair and deal with the..."
chiming tse
"Most underrated Italian restaurant in north Jersey. Chef Mario has smart, Calabrian-influenced menu. Everything is good but shrimp app, Pappardelle..."
"You know how good a place is when you get hit with the smell of great food from the parking lot. Excellent food and service, will be back again......"
Chris Paladino
"First time there and we loved it! Food was fabulous, Patty our server was amazing...so friendly. The chef stopped by and most importantly we..."
Linda Funicelli Schaefer
"All of our dishes were delicious. Our daughters (7 and 5) would have licked their plates clean if we let them.
Atmosphere is very nice and the staff..."
Eric Tropiano
"Had the pleasure of dining here last night ! Rode past this place for 10 years and finally tried it and was very very pleased..."
John J Bassani
"Love Stephanie's. My favorite Italian restaurant. The food is delicious and the waitstaff is super. We have had parties there and they have always..."
Carol Florkowski Muscianesi
"Without a doubt, the BEST Italian restaurant anywhere! Vinnie, Christine and their staff are wonderful, caring and they make sure that everyone is..."
Arlene Lubman Brief
"The best flounder francese ever
I had the rigatoni siciliano. Best around. Highly recommended. Don't forget your bottle of..."
Mike Codella
"The best ristorante . Delicious food. Grate atmosphere .Good..."
Lidiya Zernitsky
"This is an amazing restaurant. The staff, atmosphere and food are just wonderful. We always make this restaurant a priority when we are in town. It's..."
Margaret McWilliams Gregory
"The food is very good. I love the chicken parmigon...."
Lenny Tartaglia
"Great food great service. Went to celebrate my birthday and had a great time. The family style appetizers were great for a larger..."
Teresa Marie
"Love it here!! The pasta stuffed with pear and goat cheese is the..."
Micheline Rozan Nesto
"Stephanie's is my favorite Italian restaurant in the area! The food is always delicious and the perfect al..."
Sherri Cicetti
"One of the best Italian restaurants in the state. Great food, great..."
Jim Fernicola
"Food is great 1st time we where there ...will be going back..."
Michele Stellatella Porcino
"We dined outside which is decorated beautifully. Staff is wonderful. The food is fabulous.. we shared the arugula salad special, I had the lobster..."
Chrystia Woroch
"I decided to go here for my birthday to try their Fiocchi and they did not disappoint! The service was wonderful and the Fiocchi was even more..."
Kristen Gormeley
"Enjoyed the most delicious meal of my life at Stephanieās last night. Appetizer of 3 colors of cauliflower baked with breadcrumbs and grated..."
Laurie Kenselaar
"Just an overall wonderful experience. We made a last minute reservation for 6 and were accommodated immediately. The staff were friendly and..."
Alex Joseph
"We had a party of nine on Mothers Day. Our appetizers, dinners and deserts were excellent and I mean everything. Michelle our waitress and her..."
John Cirasella
"What a wonderful restaurant. Excellent service and the food was top notch. The server was very friendly and helpful. Will be back..."
"All different types of pizza and their famous home made dishes. Pizza is fantastic and that past fagiole is to die for. I drive 45 miles for that..."
Brian Fincken
"The best Italian food I have ever eaten. I miss it so much. Travelled everywhere in this country and have to say, Forte is the..."
Meganack Lanju
"Love Fortes! Great dinner last night, staff pleasant and the owners are great people !Red Snapper with artichoke hearts, mushrooms and cherry..."
Angelina LoRe Markey
"This place is more than a pizzaria.... its great food and its consistently great no matter what you order is..."
Kris Lindblom
"Excellent Italian food. Great service. Great price. Recommended to us by a chef who lives in the area. BYOB. Lovely..."
Dorothy Demarest Donnelly
"Great food ! Best Iāve had recently ! A must try..."
Susan Ford Badalato
"Best pizza I ever had hands down, would strongly recommend costumers and friends to have a basil sun dried tomatoes fresh motzarella and..."
Luis Couto
"The best food in the world!!!!!
Great prices and great..."
Barbara Basilone
"Stopped here because I was hungry while I was working. My first time here. Had the best chicken caesar thin crust pizza. It was awesome and the rest..."
Janet Ford
"Was at a party at Forte's and not only was the food delicious, the waiter who looked like he was in charge of the servers, was amazing. One guest..."
Ann S
"Neighborhood pizzeria , I used to get all pizza delivery when I lived in Caldwell. Other dishes are great. Services are always good. Always busy..."
Eiko Ross
"For my first time here, I did not know what to expect. Having attended for my grandfather's 95th birthday, the party room was incredible with decor..."
N10 Fit
"Very good Italian restaurant with pizza and a full menu of choices. We had a very nice lunch and the Chicken Marsala was delicious! Fresh mushrooms..."
TomQnel
"Went here for my birthday and was very impressed. We sat outside which was very spacious but probly one of the last weekends cause getting colder..."
"Donāt skip this place. The food is over the top! The wait staff is perfect! Want something special or different? Theyāll get it done.
Run,..."
Mike Candarella
"Great place for lunch and dinner. Try it! They have a small buffet at lunch which is very good. A typical day has a chicken dish, meat of fish, a..."
Richard Gibbs
"WOW! If you havenāt been to La Famiglia yet, GO! Just delicious. Great food , great atmosphere, great prices. I highly..."
Kathy Reilly
"Pound for pound some of the best Italian food I've had. They do what I would consider to be the quintessential chicken parm dinner with roasted..."
Branden Garland
"Stopped in to inquire about having a party. The owner was more than helpful. He explained the details regarding booking a party. When we told him we..."
Jennifer Pirone
"PizzaLogDay4ļøā£3ļøā£
Happy Pizza Friday!!!! You crushed another week. Celebrate with š
š @la_famiglia_caldwell_
Thin round 1/2 meatball &..."
ThePizzaHulk
"Reservation at 6pm was for 3 guests. Four of us showed up. As the dining area was open, They were very accommodating. The waitress Took our order..."
Khalilah Sharif
"Square Rosa Grande Pepperoni Pizza
Is absolutely God tire nice well-done bottom nice and charred chrispy around the crust and heap loads of pepperoni..."
"Calandra's Bakery was great to work with. The cake tasting blew my mind. There was a large amount of flavors to choose from, all delicious, which we..."
Kara Licastro
"My husband and I got our wedding cake from Calandra's and we were so happy with our decision. From the moment we arrived for our tasting..."
Gabby Canella
"My husband and I chose Calandra's for our wedding cake and I could not have asked for better! We worked with Aisha who was great. The tasting itself..."
Swata Rodriguez
"Loved my galaxy wedding cake and so did my guests. So many people said this was the best cake they ever had. The chocolate with cannoli cream was..."
Maribel Montanez
"came to install balloons for a bridal shower - stayed for the gelato! best iāve had in the longest time..."
Alexa Heffernan
"Really good pastries and you can get a discount if had dinner at the adjacent restaurant. Just a bit pricey compared to other..."
Luis De Abreu
"I go there every Monday to get their cinnamon bun for my husband. He loves it and says it to be the best cinnamon bun in the world! āŗļø It's..."
Nadia S. Fondren
"Love this place 1 time we coming back..."
Ismael Lozano
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes