2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"This is a Cape May hidden gem!!! It’s right by Congress Hall and the cupcakes are absolutely delicious. I would keep coming back if I lived in..."
Anita Mohan Saha
"Happened upon this shop by accident.
As luck would have it we were in need of some gluten free cupcakes and this place came through with some of the..."
Johnathon (Saint)
"I was looking for a place to get some cupcakes for my daughters 16th birthday and happen to find Pretty Tasty Cupcake Boutique in Cape May. I..."
Dawn Manzolillo
"Cute little pink shop. 🌸
Delicious cupcakes! We had the mint chocolate chip, lemonade and salted caramel. They were all very tasty.
They even had..."
Wendy Cossaboon
"I worked in the mall last year and would frequent this place to buy cupcakes for myself and sometimes my coworkers. Not only were the cupcakes..."
Emily Sollenberger
"These cupcakes are absolutely scrumptious, beautiful with amazing packaging. We came here last year when they first opened and again this year. If..."
Avram Granett
"This is the absolute best cupcake you’ll ever taste and Erica the owner is one amazing person. Do yourself a big favor and stop by to try her..."
Maureen Depaul
"Tasty amazing elegant cupcakes! Spoke with owner who made my birthday with her kindness and the yummy cupcakes. Visit in Cape May &..."
Cynthia Ives
"Amazing cupcakes!! They even assured me the cupcakes had no nuts and gave me a free cupcake due to my peanut..."
Elena Martinez
"The prices are daunting, and this tiny shop doesn't have much product, but what they do have is FANTASTIC! Buying a dozen of these unique little..."
Mercedes Jennings
"Awesome cup cake store that is nut free. Great for people with allergies. The lady that works there is..."
Joseph P. DiFrancesco Jr.
"Absolutely the best cupcakes I’ve ever had !! I am a foodie & this place is heaven on..."
Don Springsteadah
"The best cupcakes!!! Owner is the sweetest..."
Yvette Y
"These were melt-in-your-mouth delicious! Perfect texture and flavor. Glad we wandered..."
Victor King
"Friendly owner. Great cupcakes! Thank you for your..."
Kris B
"The shop owner was so nice:)
It is GREAT that they are peanut..."
"Being from England we don't have much in the way of peanut butter to choose from, so when a friend recommended this place we couldn't wait to get..."
Janette Gurrell
"I love this place the best peanut butter there is. Oh and the peanut butter cannolis omgggggg heavenly. I got my fix today. Thank you for always..."
Theresa Oneill
"Outstanding nut butters! The peanut butter straws are amazing! This place is a must visit unless you have peanut allergies. :)
Edit:
Well, I..."
Deniz Tezcan
"Our first visit and we were not disappointed! We had such a great experience and the peanut butters were delicious!! It is so awesome that you can..."
Teri Bomboy
"Unbelievable spreads and a very friendly staff. If you are a peanut butter lover this is a must place to visit. We bought both the butterscotch and..."
Mike Ciupinski
"Greatest place in the world. Happy staff and the best honey roasted peanut butter..."
Teresa Solano
"My favorite place!! They have so many flavors. The best are butterscotch, honey roast, and cappuccino. They give samples and are..."
Olivia Catherine
"Wow, this place was incredible, I had no clue there could be so many flavors of peanut butter, I tried many samples & all were amazing. Truely a..."
Dennis Noble
"Choc Choc is the best peanut butter ever made. Butterscotch is growing on me and my wife loves the Cappuccino. They have so many goodies in the..."
Michael Smith
"Most definitely the best tasting peanut butter ever to touch my tastebuds! So many varieties to keep peanut butter interesting so you never tire of..."
Kimberly Dawn Luba
"We had such a great experience at this shop!! The lady working was so friendly and welcoming!!! The peanut butter is delicious!!! We will be..."
Mary Eged-Yuhas
"The King is an epic concoction of all foods held sacred in my heart. Peanut butter (yes), bacon (keep going baby), honey (nectar of the gawds),..."
Sandy Nickel
"This is one of the must go to places for my wife and I every time we go to Cape May. Staff is always super friendly and the free samples never hurt..."
Hank Fialkowski
"i visited yesterday for the first time and im in love with this place friendly staff and very helpful peanut butter is awesome. i had a happy camper..."
Stacy Medes
"Happiest place in Cape May (probably all of New Jersey). Peanut butter heaven exists!!! And I'm here loving it. You gained a customer for..."
Barbara Ann
"I enjoyed the lovely backyard waiting for my husband to come out with his peanut butter fix, a PB & J sandwich! He brought me a PB cookie which is..."
Lois Anderson Amos
"Your peanut butter cookies were wonderful!
In addition our dog loved your peanut dog butter dog treats. It is wonderful to find a treat with only..."
Jane Pytleski Howard
"Visited this place over the weekend. Friendly staff and the peanut butter non pariels are sooo..."
Patty Zehner
"Love this peanut butter but we can never find it up here. We ordered on line and it was here 2 days later! Our son is also allergic to peanuts so..."
Jeremiah Hawkins
"Absolutely lovely. The staff was so sweet and friendly! Loved the honey and my dogs enjoyed their peanut butter dog..."
James Leon
"I bought this one to hold me over until my favorite cappuccino peanut butter was back in stocks! As always the Cape May Peanut Butter Company never..."
Tiffany Ann Speakman
"Seems like they have awesome peanut butter and flavors of such. However we just got a cookie and scone here but they were pretty dry so I wouldn’t..."
Kate
"Excellent staff and gourmet peanuts a must stop in Cape May Gourmet tasting of several. Customized peanut butter flavors. Great stop for families and..."
Ryan Reclaim
"My husband loves peanut butter so we quickly went in when we saw it through the alley of the main thoroughfare. The woman inside was very nice and..."
Mrs. McCorry
"Great boutique store specializing in peanut butter and jams. There are free samples available and the staff walks around with samples of the bakery..."
Gabriel Garcia
"I absolutely love this place. Everything I have is delicious. I have had the peanut butter cups, the super large peanut butter cups, The cookies,..."
Rick Broyles
"This place is heaven on earth for anyone with at least an occasional peanut butter craving. You’ll find a broad selection of peanut themed snacks..."
Zachary Herb
"Cute little place in cape may. Absolutely delicious peanut butter. My mom is a crazy peanut butter fan and she absolutely loved this :) she's come in..."
Rohit Nayak
"You’d never think you’d find a specialty peanut butter shop in Cape May, but hey, weirder things have happened. I would eat my weight in this..."
Statler Willand
"This place is both dangerous & magical. A peanut butter lovers heaven. Seriously. 🥜 Love all their hand crafted nut butters (more than just PB!)..."
Heather Boswick
"we have been coming to the peanut butter company easily for 9 years… each year there is something new and exciting, i remember the first year i..."
janet lynn cassetta
"Addicted to the Cappu Cino flavor.
The Honey Roasted is also Fabulous!
If you love Peanut Butter this is a must visit.
The Smithville Store is just..."
Lois Delbert
"Peanut butter lovers paradise! The honey roasted peanut butter and the nonpareils are exquisite. You can sample all of their peanut butters, and they..."
SHANE DAVIS
"Super fun. All sorts of peanut related products along with other great..."
Luke Johnson
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes