"Had dinner at Oyster Bay on Tuesday Aug.8th in the bar, Mike was our server/bartender, he made the best PAMA martini and also recommended the roast..."
Jo Anna Rizzo Saville
"I went with my Mom and sisters to celebrate Mom's birthday.we got the fried tomatoes and crab it was great.My sister and I got the seafood pot pie it..."
Candida Mullen
"Excellent food and service, the Filèt and crab meat were phenomenal, Anne was our server, she treated my 2 friends and I very well even though we..."
Ariel Brown
"We went in the bar for Happy hour, Casual attire, nice atmosphere, bartenders very friendly and attentive, My husband got raw oysters on the half..."
Marian Prettyman Rintchen
"I was there last night for me and my wife's anniversary for the first time. I would recommend this restaurant to everybody I encounter. The bar maid..."
Brian Bush
"I have never had a bad meal here! Service is always excellent and the food never disappoints. I would highly recommend this..."
Kip Johnson
"One of the best spots in Cape May great Happy Hour and a fantastic creative bar menu as well as fine dining as..."
Dale John Steltz
"The overall drinking and dining experience was excellent. We ate in the Bar where we enjoyed superior service with a taste of local hospitality. ..."
Wendy Williams Bettis
"Absolutely phenomenal food and service. Well worth the trip. Will definitely eat here..."
Austin Evans
"Oyster Bay is my favorite restaurant to go and have a nice family dinner. The food is amazing and the staff are very friendly and..."
Sue Sanguinetti
"I have been going to Oyster Creek since I was a little girl. About 50 years. In the summer it’s a great place to come by boat to enjoy the crabs..."
Donna Wright Montana
"My favorite place to dine! Had the best Mothers Day..."
Donna Bortney Boyle
"Had a lovely dinner here with my husband. Service was good, and the server was able to investigate any questions I had about gluten or corn..."
Beth H
"We've been coming here as a family now for two years and every visit has been great. The seafood is always super fresh and more than that they are..."
Violet Alexandre
"We didn't have reservations for dinner but stopped in to get a drink at the bar then decided to stay for dinner. When we went to the hostess she..."
Mary Smith
"We had a much better experience than we did a few years ago. Bartender was on point tonight and food was delicious. Scallops were sauteed perfectly..."
Suzanne Lee
"Great bar area. If they had an outside area, it would be 5 star for..."
Susan Sullivan-Lyons
"Cocktails and food were fantastic. Lots of food options for people with different tastes. Probably the best Manhattan I had during my stay in Cape..."
Eric Himes
"Really 4.75 stars but if the option is between 4-5 stars then it's obviously closer to the 5. Drinks were amazing, had the bramble. The food was..."
Genkai Nashi
"What can I say. Loved the place. Very classy clean and very pleased with the service and food. My husband had the strip steak and I the salmon...."
Susanne S
"Great Seafood and atmosphere
My husband and I were in the area for the afternoon and evening. We called at 4:30 PM on Friday to make a reservation..."
Hilary Levitt
"I haven’t yet to have a bad meal. Just miss the New England Clam bake dish omg that was fantastic plz bring it back. Went down the road to try the..."
Patricia Clevenger
"Very versatile happy. Waitress was experienced, food from apps to dinner was awesome. Can't wait to come back every summer.
Must have reservations..."
Susie Wong
"Alicia is the best bartender! (I hope I remembered your name!) Great happy hour! Dollar oysters and the drinks are amazing. no pre-mixed garbage...."
Melissa P
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes