Best Cheesecake in Captiva Island

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Old Captiva House
Old Captiva House
91/100 (2347 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
American
Contemporary
Contemporary
Seafood
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Duck
Toasts
Risotto
Bass
Mussels
Escargot
Tuna
Cheesecakes
Carrot Cake
Salmon
Shrimp
Key lime pie
Bouillabaisse
Cakes
Crab Cake
Lobster
Lamb
Cheesecake
Eggplant
Filet Mignon
Pesto
Halibut
Pasta
Fish
Ribs
Salad
Lamb chops
Crab
Scallops
Clams
Polenta
Sit down
Seafood
American
Contemporary
Accepts Visa
Table Service
Private Dining
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts American Express
Serves Alcohol
Live Music
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Waterfront
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Discover
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Reservations
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Tween Waters is a lovely property and the service is exceptional across the board: at the front desk, at the restaurants, to the people who set up..."
Mindy Marshall
"Old Captiva House is a delight with friendly staff and good food. For our starters we had a caprese salad and a deconstructed sushi roll. The sushi..."
Ciarra
"Food and service was good, the large shrimp in the shrimp cocktail were ok. Hubs had the well seasoned blackened snapper with water melon salad, he..."
Evelyn Peterson
"We've had some great meals during our visit and this place is the best. Wedge salad is so common here, but they really kick it up with Catalina..."
Christine Magnuson
"What a treat. We came in town for a short spontaneous vacation and found this phenomenal restaurant. Getting there at sunset by itself was already..."
Daniel Manusis
"Sorry but my man could not wait to eat the lamb chops before me taking a picture. He respectfully apologized stating "excuse me as I'm about to eat..."
Stephanie Woods
"Absolutely fantastic. We we’re staying at the connected Tween Waters resort so it was a no brainer to try the Old Captiva House. Food was..."
Ben R.
"I love this place, Tween Waters does an excellent Halloween Party every year and the food is excellent. Also, there is a ridiculously beautiful..."
Bryan Filson
"This place has good food, and great drinks. It’s also walking distance to the Captiva..."
Zach Silva
"Tricky to find parking.. once in the restaurant staff isn’t super welcoming or attentive. Cocktail shrimp were SO painfully over cooked. Main..."
Lindsey Ramsey
Sunshine Seafood Cafe And Wine Bar
Sunshine Seafood Cafe And Wine Bar
89/100 (830 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegan Options
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Late Night
Drinks
Mussels
Seafood Paella
Tuna
Goat cheese salad
Salmon
Cakes
Burger
Lamb
Pesto
Fish
Crab Cake
Cheesecake
Shrimp
Filet Mignon
Swordfish
Lobster
Bass
Pasta
Cheesecakes
Salad
Carrot Cake
Key lime pie
Crab
Scallops
Paella
Sit down
American
Seafood
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Drinks
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"Great experience! We have been so excited to return to the island and support all the local restaurants and shops. Sunshine Seafood did not..."
Kristie Jones
"Have been dining here for years and have adored every visit. Service and food are superb. Fish is cooked perfectly every single time and the chef..."
Bethany Charlsen
"We found the perfect quaint restaurant in the middle of paradise! We reserved the Sunshine Cafe for my 30th birthday and it was better than we could..."
Sally Gins
"If you want your taste buds wowed with every bite, this is your place. Everything is so fresh and the seafood amazing. The blind pass shrimp..."
Aimee Stoller
"One of my favorite Captiva Island restaurants. The food is prepared well and unique. Tonight was halibut with chipotle sauce. Yummy. Then the..."
Donna Packer
"This restaurant is a true home run. A best kept secret. I’ve been here twice, bringing four friends the second time last night. How can there be..."
Marja Norris
"we sat outside and enjoyed the beautiful weather and music from surrounding venues. the service was great explaining the wines and offering us..."
James Murch Eschert
"Best food and service on Captiva. Good wine selection, staff is friendly and attentive. Went twice on a short stay. Took their time on each course..."
David Motisi
"Amazing food and service. We had the scallop and the Brussels sprouts appetizers and they were both outstanding. Also had the paella which was..."
Fran Eleazer
"Great Restaurant We always return to eat at Sunshine Cafe when we are on the island & we have brought friends here to dine. The food snd service are..."
Mary Fa
"We just love the Sunshine Cafe' Went for New Year's Eve... outstanding food the seFood was so fresh everyone enjoyed themselves. The Key Lime was a..."
H Gunther
"We eat at Sunshine Cafe every time we eat our in Captiva. Some weeks 7 days a week. Have been eating there for years. Best seafood and steaks on the..."
Keith Botsch
"This place is a little gem on Captiva! Best meal we've had on Captiva, hands down. We started the evening by ordering a bottle of prosecco off the..."
Ashley Wade
"Can’t say enough GREAT things about the Chef, Jose and Doug! Such great and caring people! The food was the best food I’ve ever had! They went..."
Chris Crowe
"Growing up in Kamchatka, grand mama would tell tales about the dish she gorged on, of rice and seafood and other treasures, during her travels to..."
Eric Barton
"Visited on June 9, 2018, the first night it was at new location. The food was excellent and the small, but well decorated dining room was a great..."
Christopher Hill
"Had dinner last night. Food was fresh and well prepared and the server was excellent. Very well worth the quality of food and the friendliness and..."
Tim Waters
"Considering this is right near the "infamous" bubble room I must say this place was much better. Little hidden gem - food was great and server was..."
Lindsay LaChance
The Bubble Room Restaurant
The Bubble Room Restaurant
85/100 (9916 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Seafood
American
Vegan Options
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salmon
Prime Rib Weissmuller
New York Cheesecake
Red Velvet Cake and White Christmas Cake
Coconut cake
Frenchy’S Onion Soup
Crab Cake
Sandwiches
S Marvelous She-Crab Soup
Cheesecake
Burger
Jamaican Rum Cake
Filet Mignon
Beignet Goodman
Bloody Mary
Buttercrunch Ice Cream Pie
Carmen Miranda
Hot Tea
Cheesecakes
Shrimp
Chips with Cheese and Bacon
Key lime pie
Burger
Cupcakes
Key Lime Pie
T-Bone Steak
Pasta
Godiva Chocolate Martini
Cakes
Salad
Orange Crunch Cake
Pesto
Pina Colada in a Real Fresh Pineapple It's Hollowed Out Core Is Left Inside
Fish
Crab
Duck
Calypso Salad
Coca cola
Café
American
Seafood
Bar
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Incredibly quirky place. If you really like thematic places and a vintage aesthetic, this is your place. One of a kind. Great bubble bread and sticky..."
Alan Martin
"Such a uniquely different place with amazing food. We had the chips they make there with cheese and bacon, as an appetizer. We brought those home in..."
Victoria Randolph Realtor
"Kitschy is probably the best word to describe this family owned local restaurant. The portions are extremely generous, and they are famous for their..."
Nancy
"The Bubble Room restaurant is a very unique dining experience! Decorated for Christmas year-round. Food is good, but the desserts are to die for! If..."
Jeffrey Melvin
"This is a quirky place with lots of cool things to look at. The food however is even more impressive. Everything we had was great, the only problem..."
Chet Huddleston
"Very eccentric venue! Had been told about this place and it was worth the 2 and half hour drive just to see it! We did of course have lunch and cake..."
Amy Hancock
"We visited Boops for breakfast sandwiches, coffee, and desserts. The staff was super friendly! The croissant breakfast sandwiches are DELICIOUS, and..."
Allison Sexton
"Very fun place to go in and eat. You are surrounded by Christmas decorations, old actors photographs, antique toys and many vintage items. The food..."
B Lipka
"Great food in a very unique atmosphere. Lots of Americana in this place for sure. We ate here right before Ian, and truly hope they will be able to..."
Eric Machac
"This place was so fun to go to! The service was good and food was good! We got the orange crunch cake which is the best seller! I can't remember the..."
Shelley Gentry
Keylime Bistro
Keylime Bistro
84/100 (3357 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Vegan Options
Bar
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Soups
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Breakfast
Brunch
Pesto
Crab
Fish
Scallops
Nachos
Calamari
Eggs Benedict
French Toast
Risotto
Burger
Toasts
Mussels
Alfredo
Tuna
Omelette
Calamares
Shrimp
Corned Beef
Salmon
Beef
Waffles
Cheesecakes
Crab Cake
Lobster
Key lime pie
Cheesecake
Pancakes
Paella
Grouper Sandwich
Filet Mignon
Pasta
Salad
Cakes
Sit down
American
Bar
Seafood
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"We stayed a few doors down on Andy Ross Ln and came here two nights for dessert only and one night for an amazing family dinner 17 people total we..."
Meghan Hall
"Wonderful little gem of a place. The breakfast food, key lime pie, and bloody Mary drinks were outstanding. Nice and relaxed atmosphere with great..."
Jason Meyer
"As a Lee County resident, I am lucky enough to visit regularly and have never been disappointed, such a fun place to bring my northern family and..."
Donna Swanberg Long
"Great place! Atmosphere is electric and staff are friendly food was phenomenal! This will be a place I'll try to visit every time I'm in..."
Glennine Giron Varga
"This is one of our absolute favorite restaurants on Captiva! We go there for lunch a lot while we’re here. Last night, we took a group of 12 for..."
Rita Rice
"Easy to sum up. Great food staff and atmosphere. Fun to do breakfast lunch or..."
James Hamilton
"Casual restaurant on Captiva Island, delicious food and the Key Lime pie is over the top!!! My favorite resturant..."
Tammy Barbur
"We stopped in just for the key lime pie. It has to be good when you are willing to drive from Ft Myers this time of year just for pie. It did not..."
Lori Burrows
"What a fun place with excellent food to boot.. service was awesome. Will definitely..."
Lisa Marie Matulka
"Definitely the best key lime pie I've ever had. Good tropical themed cocktails as well. I haven't eaten here in years though but I recall it was..."
Adam Wilson
"We stopped in only because we heard a Flute being played beautifully and we could tell it was LIVE and just had to see who it was. We followed the..."
Timmy Gibson
"Talk about off the beaten path! I’m so happy we found it … a favorite of the locals … and they did not exaggerate the quality of the pie! We..."
Michael Rusk
"We had a wonderful early dinner here with friends back in December. My husband said his grouper sandwich was one of the best he's had and I had the..."
Susan Peters
"We made the short drive up from Sanibel as this place came recommended from others. There is both indoor and outdoor seating with lots of fans going..."
Mike Parry
"5-Star Key Lime Pie! We came here a few times over our stay in Captiva. First 2 times was for breakfast which was very good. Crab Benedict was fresh..."
Ben R.
"Great experience! The waitress took the time to go over the menu and give her recommendations on everything. We had stuffed grouper and the seafood..."
Maura Parker
"We went for lunch, the music was not overbearing and the service was good. We started with chicken nachos that were very good. I order a Mai Tai and..."
Victor Peralta
"We tried several items. The waitress didn’t really have any recommendations… so it was a stab in the dark. The dessert was very good. I..."
Shauna Miller
"Really yummy food and they arent lying, their key lime pie is the best. Absolute best key lime pie i have ever had. Their service was ok and their..."
Trudy Guerrero Corbitt
"We ate here for lunch and tried to keep it light. We ordered salads and added blackened chicken and blackened grouper. These salads were delicious..."
Yesenia Rybarski
"Fantastic dining experience. Best service, pricing and food. Though I found the key lime pie to be a little too..."
jeff kovatch
"Great getaway! The food is very good and well portioned. This is one of our favorite destinations on the weekend when we can get away. I posted some..."
John Castle
"A very warm, humid Sunday, so cold drinks, a fresh spinach salad and a cheesesteak sandwich for lunch ticked off all the right marks. All accompanied..."
Sally Rettstadt
"Live music. Outdoor seating. Great service. Best drink of any restaurant we visited on the island. Key lime pie is cheese cake style. Very rich,..."
Don C. Railsback O.D.
"Perfect place for a little night life on the island! We came around 9pm for dessert and cocktails. The key lime pie was amazing and the drinks were..."
Sally Dietzenbach
"Another great spot on Captiva island. We had dinner and it was great. The seafood paella was spectacular as it had lots of taste. I enjoyed an..."
Paul Ellison