Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Carle Place
8 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Last night was my second dining experience here. Both times I was completely satisfied. From the minute I walked in the door we were greeted by..."
Maureen Matzen
"In the genre of classic NY Italian restaurants Rialto ranks high. True to that genre the food is a bit heavy, but the execution is very good,..."
Gregg Miller
"I had the Caesar Salad, Osso Buco and the Zuccotto for dessert. The presentation on all the food was a solid 10/10, the hospitality and service were..."
Joe Zollo
"This place is a neighborhood gem! We celebrated my daughter’s 16th birthday here and the staff made the process from start to finish very seamless...."
Riley Rose
"Nice experience. Favorable dishes . Stuffed artichoke ban appetizer very nice to see on the menu. Lemon sole light and prepared just right. Austin..."
E A
"We had our son's wedding rehearsal dinner here. Delicious plentiful food, super attentive staff and very friendly atmosphere. Great..."
Deborah Knapp
"Classic Excellent Italian! From the warm greeting we got at the door to the pizza bread in the bread basket, to the Chicken Scarp and Veal..."
MB Stalter
"Great food and friendly service. Nelson the manager is such a great host. Noel at the bar makes a great..."
"Thank you Jose (server) for an awesome experience. The food was amazing: Spaghetti and Meatballs(2). Chicken Parmesan. The Bread Basket and Garlic..."
Krystal Brown
"Super good with a great atmosphere. The host at the front door (could be the owner) was a character! Waiter was great. Food was delicious, warm,..."
Christopher Whitley
"Unbelievable menu. Everything is absolutely delicious. The staff is super nice. I can’t say one bad thing about our experience. One of the best..."
Joseph Gerasci
"Third time here and consistently great. The owner Emilio came to our table ,told us about a lot of dishes and home made pasta, the cream sauce is..."
Dianne
"My family and I celebrated my grandmother's 80th Birthday at Passione. From the first day that I went to Passione to book the dinner Emilio (Owner)..."
Charlyne Sainrose
"Service was fabulous, atmosphere was amazing and the food was great! Will be..."
JL
"This restaurant is fabulous. From the food, to the wait staff exceptional. Was there for a private party no complaints. I am not from the area and..."
T Lunsford
"This place is great! Had a warm welcome when we walked in and a great lunch! Chicken Parmigan was delicious and Josè was a great..."
John Randall
"This place is fantastic! Everything we tried was delicious! We walked in pretty hungry and Pasione did not disappoint. The place seems so unassuming..."
isabelle jones
"Love this place! Never disappoints. This place has great food in an unpretentious, lovely environment. The servers are amazing and always willing..."
Dolly Hoffman
"I just love Passione. The food and service is amazing. Our waiter Shawn was the best. He was very attentive and made sure that all of our needs were..."
Women Of Integrity Inc.
"Went to Passione for dinner and was seated within a few minutes. The staff was very courteous and friendly. Once we were seated the waiter brought..."
Ruth Sanderson
"I enjoyed coming here with the family. We all liked our food very much. Our waiter Sean was very friendly, attentive and accommodating. They are in..."
"This restaurant is a gem. We have been to all the great restaurants in Long Island and being a foodie, we rank this restaurant one of the best. Food..."
Carla Rosen Jassey Phelps
"I really enjoy this restaurant with their great menu. My daughter is gluten free so their gluten free menu happens to be the best one around! Love..."
Louisa D'Amato Barba
"Happened upon this restaurant last night out of the blue. In Long Island just for the night, and wow my husband and I were completely wowed from the..."
Liz McDonnell Fortugno
"Great food (including an awesome gluten free menu) and great service. Highly recommend! Had our baby shower..."
Karina Elizabeth
"I had a private party yesterday at Cafè Formaggio. I cant brag enough about it. The food was very very fresh and delicious. I often worry..."
Roseanne Z-a
"Great place!! Was there for the second time in a month for family birthday celebrations. I have celiac - so many amazing gluten free options. ..."
Rosemary McCarthy Seplowe
"We ate there today. Excellent service and one of the best gluten free menus I've ever seen. The food was delicious. We all loved..."
Elizabeth Cumming
"Cafe Formaggio is my favorite restaurant for both selfish and altruistic reasons. I know I can have a wide choice of delectable gluten free options..."
Pam Dixon
"Food was amazing! Entire Gluten free menu was spectacular! The service was an A+!! I would highly recommended this place!!!!! Lenny is an awesome..."
Cristina Munda
"As a celiac, I really appreciate the extensive gluten free menu and attention to safety. The food is excellent and I've never had any issues after..."
Donna Ambroso-Padberg
"love, Love, LOVE this place-- The food is decent, the quaint bar area is FULLY stocked-- And the wait staff is friendly! Especially Lenny, who is..."
Stephanie Legare
"I have eaten here before, my sister had her bridal party lunching here. Very good service and friendly . But the food , if you enjoy Italian food ,..."
Lisa M. Lewis
"I first took a friend to lunch here and was blown away with the fact that I was able to eat free of fear from being glutened. Then took my family..."
Rhona Lawrence
"The classic Italian restaurant in the neighbourhood of Long Island in Old Country Road. They specialised in gluten free meals and this is one of the..."
Carl Kleine-Weischede
"Unfortunately we do not make it here nearly enough! Definitely one of my favorite restaurants on Long Island. The food is spectacular the service is..."
joseph gallipoli
"Amazing food. Has tons of gluten free options. Would definitely..."
PJ B
"Excellent food and delicious gluten-free options from the bread basket to the desserts. Walter, our waiter, treated my party of 20 for a birthday..."
George G
"Cafe Formaggio in #CarlePlace was absolutely #delicious! Highly recommend to anyone in the area! The service is wonderful, they have gluten free..."
Ashlee Rose Perez (Ashlee Rose)
"My first choice was the taglatelli ragu, but at 7:30 they were all out, as well as the gluten free bread. I ordered the capollini fra diavolo, which..."
Sal Devita
"Excellent little Italian restaurant in Garden City. Don't fill up on the fabulous bread and olives they bring to your table as you sit down. Save..."
Simone D
"One of the BEST around! Great ambiance, decent food, a quaint but fully stocked bar area... and a really pleasant staff, ESPECIALLY Lenny-- who is..."
Purse Queen61
"The second time I have eaten here. To be back, is itself a statement! The entire stay appears to be attentive to the customer, and servicing them..."
RoBob Naphtali “Naphtali Bob” Hunter
"Outstanding experience... food great, service great.. will def be back.. best Calamari Arrabiata..."
Jeff Eppy
"Came hear with my family for my 70th birthday. We had 10 people and my granddaughter is gluten free. A great selection of gluten and gluten free..."
Iris Kubel
"My son has celiac and this was the first time he'd had gnocchi (gluten free) in years. He was very excited and enjoyed it immensely. They also had..."
Mara Leonardi
"Great place! Food is delicious, but I always over-indulge on the bread basket and can’t finish my meal because they are large portions. Totally..."
gregg Radford
"I have never had a bad meal here. I have a special diet due to multiple sensitivities and they always are willing to work with me. Seriously..."
Margot St Aubin
"Great atmosphere, love the bread and the olives, cheese and hummus they serve with it. Never had a bad meal. Always enough food, usually take home..."
April Pace
"Went here for my uncle's birthday. The place was packed and we were a group of 11. Our server, Frank, was attentive, courteous, and appropriately..."
"My family had lunch a few weeks ago and it was excellent. So I went for dinner with my family and it was better. The portions wether lunch or dinner..."
carl lieberman
"Louie's Pizzeria offers a robust mouthful upon mouthful. You can choose to dine on the casual pizza side and enjoy selecting from an array of pizzas,..."
Jacqueline Vita
"Very good! But...
This place was a nice place to just relax and eat in. The food was delicious and the bread was next level. The only reason it’s..."
Emily Padro
"Pizza is well made without a crazy amount of sauce and cheese. Isn't too oily. Buffalo slice has a nice kick that isn't overly..."
Steven (Steven)
"I stopped by for my lunch break and I have to say that The restaurant was very clean and the people that work there are very kind. I had garlic..."
Melissa Ford
"I thought this was just a pizzeria. What a nice surprise that it was a restaurant as well. Big portions, so bring your appetite. Love the..."
Audra Delfosse
"My family and I just moved into the neighborhood and always in search of awesomeness eateries. Louies Pizzeria totally did not disappoint us. The..."
Kenny Moon
"Great local pizza/Italian place! Nice folks, even called to ask if I was allergic to something when I added additional notes on my to go..."
Victoria
"Love coming here. We moved from Garden City to Queens and still take the drive a couple of times a..."
Thomas Hughes
"Scottish Salmon - great texture and tenderness. Once your fork touches down to the meat, it will separate out to nice fillets automatically. Slightly..."
Jiyun Jiang
"Nice place. The lasagna was delicious. Service was good. I would go..."
Patti K
"Ok I order thier salads almost daily at this point! I havent even tried the pizza yet. The salad ingredients are always fresh and I can be pretty..."
"I loved this place! For $15.95 there were many selections under their lunch specials menu and it came with fresh baked bread, olive oil and spices..."
Toi Barreto
"I was here on a Sunday night. This is a nice family style restaurant. The garlic knot was really big and shareable. The Caesar salad was great one of..."
Amrin Islam
"I would give this place 6 stars if I could. The food was beyond delicious. It was very crowded so make sure you get reservations in advance otherwise..."
Blackout The Rebel
"Vincent’s festive decor put us in a jolly mood. We arrived early for lunch around 12:30 and didn’t hv to wait. They were already a quarter full..."
Hopi W
"It's been a long time since I've felt a vibe like that!! What a greeting! Made you feel right at home. Friendly atmosphere, the service was..."
Georgia Panagiotakos
"What a delicious meal. I love Vincent's and always went to Howard Beach. I had no idea you are here. I saw on Instagram yesterday. I love the fried..."
Annie Pisapia
"Absolutely incredible Italian food. Such a cool vibe inside too. If I lived local I would without a doubt be a regular..."
Doug
"At 5pm, the place is already jam packed. We waited 20 minutes, even we have reservation. Food is delicious, their tomatoe sauce is amazing...."
Anna Yan
"This place came highly recommended so went to check it out. This was by far the best Italian spot I’ve been to in a long time. The atmosphere, the..."
Boss Don
"First time back in about two years and the food is still excellent just as I remembered however the entire meal we felt rushed which is something..."
"Service was great, vodka sauce FABULOUS. ,Sangria delicious. All top quality food ..."
Dianne
"I have been coming here for years but haven’t dined recently since the name change. My father and I stopped by for dinner on a Wednesday night. The..."
K B
"Lovely little hole in the wall restaurant, great food with a range of dishes for any level of appetite. Service folk there are very thoughtful and..."
maryalice costich
"Wonderful Italian food, very helpful waitress. I would highly recommend..."
Jenifer Ostermann
"If I could rate La Bottega in Carle Place a 10 I would. They hosted a party of 14 people celebrating 5 birthdays this past Sunday. Joe, the owner,..."
Judith Pollack
"Love this place. There is such a huge selection of paninis on the menu. The food is delicious. The atmosphere is small and quaint. It is a hidden..."
Debra Stern
"Absolutely fabulous all around. Food was delicious and I loved their..."
Ann Sheridan
"Great food here
Never ending..."
carmine posillico
"Eggplant Parm was a little crispy and light on the cheese 👍..."
Eric M
"LOVE THIS PLACE!!! Had the most freshest, delicious piece of homemade Sicilian pizza and a perfect cappuccino!!! The staff are friendly and the..."
"Excellent Pizza. Angelo's serves excellent Pizza. The crust is very thin and that's just the way I like it. Their Grandma Pie is superb, their..."
Cunife
"Never been on a date with my girl in 3 yrs, this was perfect place for her, quiet, cool, calm n collected. Had us writing this review after her first..."
Smear Uno
"Food was Gold Standard. Perfectly cooked, Made with love. Outstanding food. so much passion on the food they cook.. Definitely..."
Michael Lavayen
"Omg, first time I was ever at this Pizzeria/Restaurant. It is tucked away next to TJ Maxx and Aldi on Glen.Cove Rd in Carle Place. Was with my..."
nancy Goldfarb
"Continue doing an amazing job :) I really enjoyed our dine with my family earlier.
The staff was very nice & accommodating and the food is like no..."
Carmen Hartsu
"Came here on a whim as my wife was craving a chicken roll and this was the first shop that popped up. I have to say I'm SO GLAD we found it. We..."
Ms. Espada
"All of its great. Try the vodka..."
Brian Kjellgren
"They have a great selection of toppings to add to your pizza and its made fresh. The customer service is also very very..."
Lock Jr
"10 out of 10, would recommend! This place was DELICIOUS! The staff are so kind and were even funny when I was joking with them! The pizza was DIVINE!..."
Erica Gunderson
"I stopped by because I was in the area. We grabbed 3 slices 1 margherita and 2 grandma slices. We were shocked how amazing they tasted. The thin..."
Paulie Nixon
"Angelo's Pizza is the very best I've ever had since I was 4 years old and my Sicilian Grandma took me shopping to Bathgate Avenue in the Bronx in the..."
Geraldine Steiner
"I come here to have some awesome pizza at Angelos after a day of snagging some goodies at tjmaxx!. The Sicilian and margherita pizza are my top..."
Rich H
"Amazing pizza! We come here all the time after long shopping hours in Simon Mall. The pizza is outstanding, and we enjoy eating here. The restaurant..."
mimi koljenovic
"Disgusting food and the only thing worse are the idiots who work..."
Mike Haskins
"Thank you for helping with a last minute order to help us help our customers be happy while waiting during their pets emergencies! Always great..."
Chicken Cutlet Parmesan with Spaghetti and Vegetables
Chicken Cutlet Parmesan Hero with French Fries
"Dinner for 15, all orders were correct, one complaint about the proximity of the wall sconces with lit candles which when jostled spills hot wax,..."
Rob Cooke
"Good service and good food. Attached to the Holiday Inn. Located conveniently near all shopping. Would recommend stopping by if you want a nice meal..."
Peter Oissar
"Exceptional food and the event preparation was above what I expected in reference to all accommodations and amenities that were provided. Thank you..."
charlie durso
"Excellent food, High Quality service and affordable prices. The staff seems to be trained by the highest level of hospitality instructors . Please..."
Kirkpatrick Wilson
"First off, it no longer Lillies anymore. The food and service are both..."
James Kelly
"Connected to the hotel. Not open every..."
Biju Varghese
""
Ashley Paro
""
Sydney Flowers Jr
""
XillityFN ' _ '
""
steve m7374
""
S T
""
Samuel Romero cruz
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes