Best Dessert in Carlisle

16 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Milton's Donuts
Milton's Donuts
96/100 (179 ratings)
Bakeries
Dessert
American
American
American
"The complement to this place what the most popular donuts are: plain glazed cake and yeast as a testimony to simple can be the best. Large staff and..."
Geuvera Photography
"I can confidently say I have yet to find better donuts! The cherry icing ones taste like Pop Tarts. If you have the opportunity be sure to stop in..."
B SNOW
"Yummy donuts and friendly..."
Victoria Newman
"Always fresh, delicious donuts. Probably the best (and quality is most consistent) I've ever..."
Kara Crawford
"So GOOD !!! Always fresh and always sold out bc they are the..."
Jason Miller
"The best donuts around! If you want to start your day off right head to..."
Mary Kay Cobb
"Don't go here if you love donuts...I think i ate my weight in donuts 🙃. Don't get me wrong, the donuts are THE BEST!!! I'm just..."
Terrie Rose
"Doughnuts are absolutely delicious! Great quality for the price. Definitely..."
Christina Dugan
"The lemon blueberry cookies are amazing. The donuts were all light, fluffy, and yummy. Great service. This will be our go-to place for..."
Chris Archer
"Always good to see someone with a great..."
Patrick Le Vangie Sr
Mummerts Chocolates
92/100 (63 ratings)
Restaurants
Dessert
"Delicious chocolates and exactly what you’d want out of a local chocolate shop: friendly, creative, willing to try new flavors. If I lived closer..."
JG Porter
"Absolutely love this shop and the homemade chocolate is the best chocolate I’ve ever..."
Jassy ?
"A wonderful local find. Light and dark chocolate covered in almost anything you would want...."
James Muldoon
"Love love this shop!! Best chocolate, great variety. I shop here often and will only buy my chocolate from mummert’s if I am gifting to someone. ..."
Kathleen Calvert
"Family of five, one of whom doesn't care for most chocolates, all left extremely happy, even Dad who doesn't care for chocolate and had to pay. The..."
Michael S
"Warm, welcoming and utterly charming. The staff is delightful and attentive. They offer a wide variety of chocolates and chocolate assortments. We..."
Hoot 'N Holler Auctions
"The chocolate here will speak to you. They will say many delicious things. Whisper...sweet...nothings...in your ear. Also, the staff member who..."
Geo East
"Wonderful little shop...had the best chocolate and very reasonable prices!!! Definitely will be..."
Heather Halteman
Fiss'
92/100 (507 ratings)
Dessert
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Kimball Farm
Kimball Farm
92/100 (895 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Ice Cream
Coconut Almond Chip
Coffee Oreo Yogurt
Banana split
Kahlua Crunch
Crunch Ice Cream
Frozen Pudding Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream with Pieces of Candied Fruits
Molasses Cookie Ice Cream Only Available Occasionally and It's so Worth the Wait
Orange Pineapple Caramel Cashew
Sundaes
Mint Chip Ice Cream
Raspberry & Chocolate
Mint Oreo Ice Cream
Mint Choc Chip & Heath Bar Ice Cream
Café
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Delicious ice creams, the texture is so smooth. I had the pumpkin flavor it was really good! Need to go back there to try out other flavors as they..."
Gautier Paux
"Good place to get ice cream during the summer seaon. This branch of the company is not open year round. They have a good variety of ice creams,..."
Wayne Livermore
"I love this place because they have the best homemade ice cream ever and you get more than what you pay for. The treats they serve are so over the..."
Randall Adams
"Kimball's Farm has great ice cream. The price for a small maple walnut in a cup with a sugar cone is only a little more than $5. The young gentleman..."
Suzanne
"This place is open and they are doing and awesome job serving people ice cream during these times. I do think the ice cream here taste better than..."
Jesus Salas
"Delicious flavors, great spot with picnic tables. Great counter service LARGE portions of spectacular flavors. My fave is gingersnap..."
Bonnie Rodgers
"The best ice cream anywhere! Huge selection of flavors, extremely generous portions. They overfill the quarts and pints. Plenty of parking and space..."
Lisa Marquis
"Best ice cream in New England! The quality is awesome and the prices are perfect! Much better than the competition. Highly..."
Jason Bice
Leo's Homemade Ice Cream
Leo's Homemade Ice Cream
91/100 (1055 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
American
Ice Cream
Café
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Mid-range
Massey's Frozen Custard
Massey's Frozen Custard
87/100 (1473 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
American
Chocolate in a Waffle Cone with Sprinkles
Ice Cream
Heath Bar Artic Mount
Vanilla Custard with Cherry Topping
Homemade Chocolate Marshmallow Custard
Banana split
Butterfinger Arctic Mount
Ice Cream
Dog Sundae
Hand Dip Custard Flavors
Soft Serve Chocolate with Chocolate Sprinkles
Vanilla Chocolate Waffle Cone
Café
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"This place was great! We have nothing even close to tasting this good in CT. Glad I stumbled upon it while I was staying close by for one..."
Cheryl Hutchings
"There is no other! The best ice-cream. We go to Carlisle yearly for a reunion at Dickinson and visit Massey’s at least twice while there. We also..."
Sandy Roza-Kushner
"The perfect ice cream for a warm evening. I ordered an Oreo cookie Arctic Mount made with their chocolate frozen custard. It was delicious, as their..."
Denise Wagner
"Large chocolate shakes to die for. Yum yum! Friendly..."
Skip Webster
":) yum this is the best place..."
Caton Phillips
"Literally the best ice cream place in the area! Delicious treats, great and friendly staff, and perfect location. It doesn't get any better than..."
Dustin Pague
"Still a great place for milkshakes and ice cream. New owners have decided to keep it open all year long. Many great memories over the..."
Kevin Young
"Yummy homemade custard! Thank you for being open even when it was freezing outside! :) Can't wait to go again for a second (third, fourth, fifth,..."
Kelly Kearn
"Massey's never disappoints! Everything is always delicious and we'll look forward to our next..."
Erica Lynn Diehl
"Always delicious, never changes....why fix what's not..."
Mike Leitzel
"Local favorite. The quality has remained exceptional. The custard is creamy and delicious. The peanut butter milkshake is delightful!! They sell a..."
jennifer wolf
"Truly one one of the old fashioned ice cream stores left, with all the charm you'd expect from an older building. The menu was so varied it was..."
Janet Richey
"The ice cream here was so good. The sundae I ordered was fantastic and my girlfriend and her son raved about their ice cream as well. This is..."
Nathan Mullin
"Pretty good. Not like years ago it used to be great custard. Now just ice cream but..."
Bill S
"I returned to Carlisle to visit my Mom, we were driving by and I noticed it was open all year now. I don't think it was open all year when I moved to..."
Kari Brooks
"Love their rotation of flavors. The raspberry cheesecake was absolutely delicious. Go there quite a lot and the prices are very..."
Kerry Rittle
"A local Carlisle treat since 1949! A great stop after spending all day at the Spring Carlisle car parts swap meet and car corral. The service by..."
BobKat B
"Good old fashioned frozen custard. I had chocolate with chocolate..."
Susan Prisco Realtor
Sweet Frog Frozen Yogurt
Sweet Frog Frozen Yogurt
87/100 (174 ratings)
Dessert
Frozen Yogurt
Ice Cream
Wheelchair Accessible
Mid-range
"Love Swet Frog! The Carlisle store is my..."
Barry King
"Sweet frog is awesome it's like rafting ice cream but..."
Katie Haymire
"Was Fantastic, but price for one small cup was at least..."
Susan Brown Spidle
"Love love love sweet..."
Denise Branch
"Yumm, and sugar..."
Sharan Snyder
"I love sweey..."
Olive B Sherman
"Ooooh this place is a do-over!! Who can go wrong with a dozen plus kinds of frozen yogurt and who knows how many toppings and syrups to drizzle?!?..."
Rachel Haines
"Great flavors! Delicious. Staff is friendly. Cozy atmosphere. Fun place to cool off after the game. So many flavors to choose from. Sweet toppings...."
Helene
"What a treat! I love that each person can get exactly what they want, including momma (Don't have to "settle" for what the kids want). This store is..."
Jessica St Clair
"Delicious frozen yogurt! The staff also goes above and beyond to be friendly and inviting. My sister and bro-in-law were visiting from SC; we all..."
Jo Jo
"Great selections of frozen yogurt. Nice variety of toppings. The place is clean and refreshing. The price is a bit much. The kids love..."
Brandon Deitch
"Consistently delicious, clean, and well-maintained shop with pleasant staff. As my 4-year-old put it, "Mmmm! Smell the ice cream in the air!" I've..."
Lindsay de Bien
"Everyone I've encountered that works here is super kind! they always seem in a good mood. It's always clean and has a pleasant..."
jade098919
"Best place in Carlisle to get frozen yogurt. All of the fruit toppings are fresh and tons of fresh fruit to choose from as well as delicious candies..."
Jill Henry
Kimberly's Cafe & Creamery
Kimberly's Cafe & Creamery
86/100 (349 ratings)
Dessert
Restaurants
Cafe
American
Diner
Cafe
American
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Ice Cream
Quiche
American
Café
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Excellent service and my greatniece loved it ! The chicken salad wrap was yummy ! Thanks for making it a nice..."
Cheryl Myers Johnson
"Awesome dinner, the kids and I just polished off our curries! Also amazing juices, coffees and breakfasts..."
Jacinta Rose Middleton
"Delicious breakfast in a charming local cafe. I had the ham, asparagus, and Swiss quiche with home fried potatoes. My guest had pancakes and bacon...."
Katie Flynn Hayden
"Best Breakfast! My fresh peach waffle was the best I ever..."
Jeff Winand
"..."
Jeanne Rytter
"Thanks Kim for helping out with the wings for Dogwood Acres Campground. Everyone love..."
Charles Strub
"Best breakfast on the west..."
Jesse Lycett
"My 1st visit , and it was excellent �RECOMMEND IT FOR BREAKFAST I WILL LET you no about..."
Kathleen Flynn Quinn
"One of my faveorite..."
Kim Shunk
"OMBB. Oh my big breakfast. ..."
Joe Reed
Helena's Chocolate Cafe & Creperie
Helena's Chocolate Cafe & Creperie
85/100 (767 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Bakeries
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Cafe
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Macarons
Macaroons
Cakes
Salad
Cheesecake
Waffles & Crepes
Cheesecakes
Waffles & Crepes
Sandwiches
Crepes
Sit down
Café
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
Meadows Frozen Custard Of  Carlisle
Meadows Frozen Custard Of Carlisle
84/100 (508 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Drive Thru
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I stopped by after I won a small cone to finally try this ice cream shop that I always go by but never stop. I ended up getting raspberry frozen..."
Courtney Werner
"This is one of my favorite places to go for a cool treat. The staff is always friendly, and they provide plenty of napkins when I use the drive thru..."
Vicki Brickner
"I love all the flavor options and the drive thru is a wonderful option to pick up a delicious treat to enjoy at home..."
Trisha Elizabeth
"The Meadows is such an amazing ice cream place! Love that they change the flavors up! always something new to try! Had a problem once with one of the..."
Hannah Whitsell
"Love this place. Best milkshakes around town. We always stop in on our way home to get a sweet treat....love the drive thru..."
Cindy Delp
"Best flavors, best customer service, best frozen custard place..."
Kristen Whitfield Killinger
"Always great ice cream for a great price! �we always celebrate my parents birthdays there. What's better ice cream and the love of your..."
Holly Shughart
"Our family loves the meadows some of the best ice cream around. Keep up the good..."
Devin Traverso
"The Meadows has some of the best frozen custard around! Always friendly staff! I love their chocolate peanut..."
Haley Henry
"Every flavor I try is awesome!! Can’t wait to get back and try..."
Lisa Wolf
"Love "Dirty Turtle". ....truly my favorite flavor at the..."
Charlene Houck Black
"We love the milk shakes there! They also have great ice cream cakes to pick from. Nice friendly service! I love the convenience of the drive..."
Jamie Hoffman Bernheimer
"They are the best! I love their black cherry..."
Paula Divens
Dairy Queen
Dairy Queen
82/100 (2055 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Sit down
"My husband and I came in close to closing time and were met with exceptional service from the young men on that night. They were patient and made our..."
Alyssa Hernandez
"It’s a DQ so I can’t say anything too severe. I’ve been here many times over the years. The service and speed thereof does lack just a..."
Marc Charlton
"Place was clean. Very courteous and professional staff. Took our order and made our ice cream treats. Haven't eaten ice cream out in awhile it was..."
Christina Hardy
"Ice cream was great, but service was slow due to lack of..."
Mike Wise
"Ordered a birthday ice cream cake with a specific design. Their artist did a fantastic job. Worth the $4..."
Jennifer Myers
"They always have decent banana splits. My wife gets a new blizzard every time we go but so far, she enjoys any of them that she has..."
Josh Mckinney
"I can't ever remember having a bad blizzard of any..."
Gerald Powell
"My wife and I took our kids to DQ for a special thing just to be together. My girls have never been and they enjoyed their first time experience. We..."
Nathan Mullin
"The Blizzard is the ultimate ice cream treat for me. I like the flavors of the month and the overall flavor selection. The staff of mostly kids is..."
Dedric Dukes
"Always a great spot to stop in with the kids. The prices are very reasonable and the young men and women who work here are always pleasant. They have..."
Nicolas Shreiner
"We came in right before closing bc it said the hours were later online but the manager(I think) was very nice and told us to take our time. He even..."
Michelle Morrow
"I get a Blizzard once in awhile. Very good soft ice cream and toppings. A "mini" is enough for me which costs about ..."
Thomas Pino
"What is not to love about a Blizzard. By far my favorite ice cream treat. I stick with my Snickers but there is always the flavor of the month and..."
Dedric Dukes
"Service with a smile! Good turn over of customers ranging from young to young in spirit. Hot dog and french fries looked and smelled yummy. Our..."
Dorris Thompson
Carlisle Bakery
Carlisle Bakery
78/100 (97 ratings)
Bakeries
Dessert
Cupcakes
"Outstanding cakes. Small shop filled with tasty baked goods at a reasonable price. Will be back for..."
Jen Johns
"So long as I'm in the area, Carlisle Bakery will be my choice for all my baking needs. Eric was FANTASTIC! Very professional. Unbelievably friendly..."
Robert Banks Jr (LoneWulf92)
"The prices are a little steeper than other local bakeries, but the quality is well worth..."
Anne Marie McKillip
"After poor customer service at the only other bakery we were familiar with in the area, Carlisle Bakery was highly recommended to my husband and I by..."
Kristyne Sharpe
"Carlisle bakery on Hanover is awesome. I called for a cake not knowing it was appointment only but the owner made my cake even though it was very..."
Denise Connors
"Carlisle Bakery has always provided the best character cakes for my granddaughters' birthday parties. This year is a Bubble Guppie Cake. We've had..."
Ann Moser
Dairy Queen (treat)
Dairy Queen (treat)
74/100 (1685 ratings)
Dessert
Fast food
Fast Food
Ice Cream
Sit down
Fast food
Wheelchair Accessible
Cheap Eats
"The Blizzard is the ultimate ice cream treat for me. I like the flavors of the month and the overall flavor selection. The staff of mostly kids is..."
Dedric Dukes
"I had my grandchildren here for ice cream this weekend.. having happy memories of when my grandparents took me for ice cream way back in the 1980s!..."
C. Reisinger
"Went in to get a cake. Friendly staff and good collection of cakes to choose..."
Possum0rb
"Great managing, delicious ice cream! Had a great time with my..."
Kyri A Piro