Best Pepperoni Pizza in Cary

4 restaurant menus in Cary, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Take 5 Cafe
Take 5 Cafe
100/100 (56 ratings)
Restaurants
Lunch
Breakfast
Peppers
Caprese Pizza
White Pizza
Fatteh
Eclair
Ham and Swiss
Turkey and Provolone
Grilled Veggie Sandwich
Kafta Pizza
Lasagna
Club with Side Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
French Fries & Garlic Whip
cheese pizza
Baba Ghanouj Pizzas
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Seared Tuna
Breakfast
Lunch
"These people Rock! I absolutely loved the food & mood... Sam & Jeanine, you're awesome đź‘Ť thanks for the warm hospitality, welcoming ambiance, &..."
Chadi Dirani
"If you want the ideal lunch experience go here I highly recommend it! The menu has a great variety of options plus a new special item almost..."
cody johnson
"Great little place to grab lunch. American standard fare along with some Lebanese specialties, and the owner sometimes tries out new recipes for the..."
W. Alex Ronke
"This is my third time here and I just love their food!! I’ve had the chicken sandwich, cheese pizza and today the shrimp scampi. Everything was..."
Julie Navarro
"I loved the food at Take 5 Cafe. All homemade & hand crafted! The Kafta pizza was amazing! The zaatar’ pie was so tasty. The Eclair was mouth..."
GLORIA SALIM-BROWN
"Great lunch option if you live in North Cary. Very nice people run this place and the food is delicious and..."
Russell Townshend
"The turkey provolone sandwich is super good but the salad was way too acidic and strong for..."
Genie Shekar
"Always love the lunch when I order. BLT & Turkey Provolone are delicious. OMG what is this again? So..."
Jose Talancha
Pizzeria Faulisi
Pizzeria Faulisi
83/100 (626 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Margharita Pizza
Red wine
Roasted Carrots
Vermouth
TiramisĂş
Lasagne
Cannoli
Cauliflower Salad
Calabrian Sausage
Caesar Cauliflower
Why not Pizza
Salad
Bread with Ricotta and Olive Oil
Wood Fired Cauliflower
Arugula
Neapolitan pizza
Funghi Pizza
Gnocchi
Roasted Cauliflower
Beer
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Tried this place for the first time tonight.. and I have to say, being a complete New York pizza snob, everything was fantastic! Had margherita and..."
Tori Oropello
"First time and it certainly won't be our last. We went basic and just ordered a margarita pizza. It was FANTASTIC. Very tasty and not heavy at..."
Billy McDonald
"Went to the Grand Opening and was impressed!! The pizza was excellent - thin and excellent flavor. A little too much char on the crust but overall..."
Jenny Bengen Albert
"Yesterday I had the pleasure of photographing at Pizzeria Faulisi for Cary Living Magazine! Amber was so sweet! I got a first hand look at how they..."
Ginny Williams
"Delicious pizza, great atmosphere, awesome desserts! Seriously, I could go on and on about this place. It's great and I can't wait to come here even..."
Sara Coburn
"I'm so excited to have these guys right around the corner from Bond Brothers Beer Co. Had a few items off their menu today (tequila included) and it..."
Jay Bond
"This is such a cute restaurant. You can tell it is family owned from the second you walk in. We brought our 2 children (2 & 4) with us and they..."
Stephanie Huhn
"Great food and even better service! We arrived 25 minutes before they closed and were treated like we were the first and only..."
Adam J Grillone
"Went on opening night. The beet antipasti and pizza were wonderful. Service was very good and the waitstaff were very friendly. Looking forward to..."
Laura Weber Turk
"I thoroughly enjoyed meeting this lovely family tonight at Chatham Street Wine Market! We were blessed to try a "sneak peek" (or would it be a "sneak..."
Caitlin Witt
"Wonderful people, wonderful food! Warm inviting atmosphere, so happy to have this in Cary! In addition to the pizza, try the beets and the tiramisu-..."
Bonnie Skiver Gambardella
"Food is fresh and straight forward. Staff is friendly and attentive. Try the beets, burrata with the sauv blanc. Ambiance is warm and bright. Simply..."
Sarah Mackiewicz
"Best food I've had in Cary. Hands down. Great atmosphere, kind people,..."
Lainey Chiarizia
"Really good fresh pizza. The oven really makes a..."
Kenny Finch
"Great pizza. Reminds me of Europe. Seating is limited so be prepared to..."
Doug Harrings
"We love this place. The house bread with ricotta would be enough to keep us coming back. But every menu item is crafted with care. We highly..."
Maria Southard
"This is by far one of the best pizzerias in the area. The Why Not pizza could have used a bit less cheese, but was still delicious. The Pinot Noir..."
Michael Torbert
"Found it to be pricy, but the pie was good! I got the 'Why Not' which the waitress mentioned is one of their most popular ones. I did really enjoy..."
Jeremy Rose
"We stopped here on a busy day in Cary and every employee was stellar. The hostess was SO kind, the waitress was helpful, and people who weren't..."
Shauna Betz
"Absolutely delicious every single time. So unique compared to any other pizza chain. Woodfired dough is amazing, and flavor combinations are out of..."
Corielle “liftUPlift” Laaspere
"Their pizza is good, their location is great, and the facility itself is pretty, but we stopped going because it's just too expensive for what it is...."
Brianna Marcus
"Dam good fired pizza done in a wood oven. Don’t sleep on the cauliflower, it’s such a tasty bite to..."
Mathias L
Brixx Wood Fired Pizza
Brixx Wood Fired Pizza
83/100 (928 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegan Options
Pizza
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Peppers
caesar salad
White Pizza
Iced tea
Mediterranean Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Root Beer Float
cheese pizza
Chicken Wings
Bruschetta
Pear & Gorgonzola
Thai Chicken Pizza
Draft Root Beer
Sausage & Spicy Honey Pizza
Hogue Reisling Wine
Wood Fired Wings
S'Mores Dessert Pizza
Salad
Hummus Trio with Wood Fired Pita Chips
Brixx Stixx
Margarita pizza
Pizza
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I really love this place. One of my favorite places to have a date night. Food is delicious, prices are reasonable and staff are always..."
Ana Channell
"Everything was excellent! The service, the pizza, the wine/beer menu, and the pineapple upside down cake martini was delicious! We will definitely be..."
Christina Ayers-Klose
"Love the people working there. Excellent customer service. Great food and delicious pizza. Love how you can customize your pizza too. Good stuff!..."
Lucretia Newkirk
"Went for first time on Valentine's Day. Pizza was excellent. We will be..."
Kim Kinsey DiGiacomo
"Kudos to Casey for always providing EXCELLENT customer service! Yummy food - the artichoke pizza is super..."
Valerie Tower
"One of my favorite places to eat! Hands down! Always perfect food, great beer and great..."
Charity Lott Adair
"I tried it for the first time and it was great!!! The bruchetta is some of the best have ever..."
Chucky Brown
"The food was great and Jacob the server did a great..."
Marty Goldstein
"Try the pear and Gorgonzola pizza, it is really..."
JacLynn Dabbs
"Brixx always has stand out staff and amazing food!! Can't wait to have one in..."
Nathaniel Lambert
"Great food!! My family had a wonderful meal ! Thanks..."
Joe Bullock
"Staff amazing Food great An awesome atmosphere Great..."
Patti Lynn Wright
"Great food, nice and close to our house! We will be back..."
Chris Soucy Tackett
"First time at Brixx and we really enjoyed it! The bread sticks are great. They taste just like the pizza dough- which is super duper delicious. We..."
Larissa Kim
"My boyfriend and I had a great lunch at Brixx. This was our first visit here and we were delighted. Our service was awesome and the food was served..."
Jazzy Leshay
"Excellent! 9.5 out of 10. Service was great my server was Tim. The food was phenomenal. Pasta, pizza, appetizers, etc. All great tasting food. The..."
Collin Byer
"One of the best restaurant for wood fried pizza.. beer with pizza is a must try in this location.. try Mexican pizza which is best.. you will have a..."
Reddy V
"Places mess up. All of them. The real question is what do they do about it. This place handled it perfectly. They quickly made my daughter another..."
Greg Balfanz
"Amazing experience! Such tasty unique pizza flavors! Great..."
Joshua Reynolds
"Best place in town, they always have great deals going on. My go to place wether its a quick lunch or a dinner..."
Saima Malik
Mellow Mushroom Cary
Mellow Mushroom Cary
74/100 (561 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
American
Vegan Options
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Mighty Meaty Thin
Cheese Bread
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pretzel
Hoagie
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Sweet Tea
Sangria
Vegetable Pizza
caesar salad
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Pepperoni Pizza
Veg Out
Greek salad
Meatballs
cheese pizza
Buffalo Wings
boozer
Pretzels
The RB Margarita
Salad
Holy Shiitake Pie
Wings
Magic Mushroom Soup
Mellow Mushroom
Sit down
Bar
American
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Free Wifi
Television
Accepts Credit Cards
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Outdoor Seating
Accepts American Express
Reservations
Street Parking
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"The customer service here was phenomenal. My boyfriend and I came in today requesting a speciality pizza, The Boozer, from another MM location. When..."
Ashley Henderson
"My dad is a super picky eater, and he likes restaurants one visit and then hates it the next but not with Mellow Mushroom. He loves it every time we..."
Maribeth Case
"Thomas at cary location Best Waiter I’ve ever had their ! Great personality and as a vegan customer he was able to answer my questions well and I..."
Jett Warner Sullivan
"Awesome pizza, good beer variety on tap, plenty of space and great staff. Always a good..."
Bob George
"We were in yesterday, and were very happy with the food and service! Our daughters had pizza, I had a meatball hoagie, hubby had a chicken calzone,..."
Erika Keen
"I very much appreciate the vegan options. I had the Thai dyed pizza with curried tofu and vegan cheese. It was..."
Jennifer Thurman
"Our waitress was wonderful ...pizzas were very good made as we requested .....our granddaughters were brought drink refills without having to ask..."
Annick Nurisso
"Amazing customer service plus even more amazing VEGAN pizza 🍕 🤤 My favorite pizza place so..."
Ayeshah Frj
"Stopped in to use my gift cert after work. Ordered a Greek Salad and gluten free mighty meaty pizza. Everything was..."
Jennifer Hulford
"If you want a great night out with delicious food this is the place to..."
Diane Masters Stellhorn
"I went here tonight with my husband and we we ordered the spinach & artichoke dip, side salad, AND a pizza (we were hungry!) and everything came out..."
Emily Claire Arnott