Reviews Brown Butter Cookie Company

Facebook
Nancy Hastings Nuding
+5
Traveling through. Saw on TripAdvisor because I wanted cookies. A must place to stop and they will mail! Melt in your mouth, delicious, flavored perfectly. Super friendly staff and very helpful! Had samples first. Sold after first bite! �����
Facebook
Meleana Pamplona
+5
I absolutely Love this place! Since we live almost 5 hours away I'm glad I can order them online! Not only are their cookies amazing and the best I've had, their staff is awesome as well! Kristy, you are a gem! My daughter who is autistic talked your ear off yesterday Lol and you just listened and smiled and conversed with her. It really made her day and mine as well! Thank you for being you!
Facebook
Noell Ahern
+5
The cookies were so delicious! The original sea salt are melt in your mouth dreams and the honey flavored cookies are just as delectable! Stopped by while on family vacation in Cayucos and so happy I did! ���
Facebook
Kenny Smith
+5
Amazing cookies, amazing owner and amazing staff. We stayed at the rental house located behind their store and were fortunate enough to get to meet the owner and a lot of their staff. It added to the trip because they were all such a joy. Leon even joined us in the parade once he finished with their entry, so much fun. I can't say enough for them and their cookies, thank you all very much.
Facebook
Kelly Anderson
+5
My co-worker brought some of these cookies. They taste of butter and vanilla and sugar. I am happy to order a box or two for myself as a treat. Highly recommend these cookies.
Facebook
Laurie Chacon
+5
Some of the best cookies I’ve had. Definitely purchase the brown butter sea salt. They melt in your mouth!
Facebook
Libby Dunn
+5
Cookies were amazing, the smell in the shop was heavenly , you could see where all the cookies were made and they make a lot , if we ever go back to California , this will be on my list of places to visit again
Facebook
Anne Yang-McCleary
+5
They are the best cookies. Practically melts in the mouth... ummm... butter�
Facebook
Kelly Samuel
+5
Helpful and kind staff. Scrumptious cookies. Such a great little place.
Facebook
Kira Lowe DeRito
+5
The citrus is my favorite and the exceptionally friendly staff and atmosphere of the beautiful shop could not be better. Thank you for the sample!
Facebook
San Dee
+5
Awesome and the people were amazing giving me samples oh yum I highly recommend
Facebook
Tawnya Zito
+5
Melt in your mouth brown butter goodness. HIGHLY addicting!!! Nice to see they have a gluten free option also!
Facebook
Mary Ann Teixeira
+5
Whoo Hoo! Yum! Crispy, light flavor, subtle salt and sugar. Geez, I thought that I was the Queen of shortbread. Not so!
Facebook
Cindy Snyder
+5
Loved every flavor of these cookies. The snickerdoodles were my favorite. The employees were wonderful. Prompt courteous service. In a great location.
Facebook
Jolianne Hohman
+5
We saw the billboard on Hwy 1 and stopped in Cayucos! Loved the shop the ladies working there and were delighted w the cookies! I can't wait to have some shipped to Ohio for an upcoming birthday!
Facebook
Whitney Autumn Camp
+5
Bumbed that my favorite bourbon cookies weren't available. The original is close but still not the same. So Coco it was.
Facebook
Jamie Eliza Pickens
+5
So so so good! We received a box of your original cookies as a wedding present, they were to die for! My new hubby was a true gentleman and offered me the last cookie. I fell in love even more with him AND your cookies!
5
Shash Khan
+5
The cookies quite pricey but delicious. Love the atmosphere and staff are nice and friend. They sure give few samples to try which one you would like. Ill get some more of them next time.
5
Tara
+5
Though it is a bit pricy, these cookies are definitely worth it! We got Tower Special, with the original, oatmeal raisin, snickerdoodle, lemon, and chocolate chunk. Definitely a thing to try if your in town!
5
Shiv M
+5
The cookies are so yum. They melt in your mouth and are full of flavor. It's in a great location within walking distance of the beach. It was fast and easy. We bought the cookie tower which had 4 different types of cookies: chocolate chunk, oatmeal raisin, snickerdoodle, and sugar. It also included 3 or 4 of their signature brown butter cookies and cocoa.
5
Rich M
+5
Saw this place on an episode on YouTube for Roy's World on Valley PBS (happy plug for the show!). Tiny place, big kitchen. I sampled the original cookie, and although it's not my "jam" it was really good. My daughter bought several 3 and 6 packs for friends. This was our first time here, replacing our normal stop in Solvang. Cookies seemed to be more "premium" than the standard dutch/danish style butter cookie, so my daughter was a bit disappointed in how few you got for the money (in comparison). I'm sure we will be back
5
Kandi BoBandi
+5
I visit this place every time I come out to the Morro Bay area! The cookies are to DIE for, & definitely worth the trip to Cayucos! ❤️
5
Shelly Shi
+5
Great find on our way to Morro Bay. They had free sample tasting and we bought the cocoa and espresso cookies. Very delicious!
5
L. Consoli
+5
This was our first time shopping at Brown Butter Cookie Company. It is a convenient location in downtown Cayucas. There is parking in front of the store and across the street. No masks are required. The gals upfront were very friendly, cheerful and helpful. Daphne at the order counter was excellent. She answered our questions. Placed our selections very carefully into the cellophane bag. The cookies look so yummy. Farron the cashier was excellent as well. It was very unusual to see ladies in back of the cashier at tables hand rolling the cookie dough into balls. Gives it a special touch.
5
John Marschner
+5
Outstanding cookies, staff very friendly and helpful. The only issue is trying to figure out what cookie or cookies to buy since they are all so good
5
James Chou
+5
Good cookies. Expensive but it is inline with cost of everything else in this tourism driven Cayucos. You can sample just about all the flavors before you buy. 4 limited edition flavors rotate every 3 months
4
Lan Khuc
+4
You need to stop by and try their cookies. This place is a legit cookie house. Every cookie is make fresh herre. You can see the worker rolling the cookie dough by hand. The place smell awesome. The workers are really nice, and let you samples their freshly baked cookies.
5
Thomas Webber
+5
Ok these cookies are exceptional. Like there are good cookies and great cookies, and then these cookies. They do something magical in their baking, I'm not sure what ✨. Sweet and buttery with a hint of salty on top. They are kinda small though.. Highly recommend stopping to get a few if you are in the area! There was always a short line and they are super covid-safe! 🍪
5
Joe Seimas (DRE# 02177368)
+5
Best Cookies in the Central Coast
5
T Cabby (Nunya)
+5
The nice lady at the counter offered us a sample even though I was already picking out my order. This was a very great touch. After she rang my order, she asked if I wanted anything else. I replied, “The million dollar recipe.” She giggled as though I was kidding. Sadly, I walked with only my cookies. Happy that she didn’t charge me a million for the joke that fell flat.
5
Chelsea C
+5
Very kind workers! Delicious cookies. Also have a small selection of Gluten Free cookies. Both are delicious.
5
M Allen
+5
A must go! They offer samples for most flavors. Each one has a uniqueness and worth a try. Our favorite is cocoa. I hate shortbread cookies but these are a completely different experience.
5
Paul Malarik Jr
+5
This local cookie company starting with this location and now has at least 3 Central Coast locations so far. One in SLO & one is Paso. As far as cookies go, they are tasty. They do have all sorts of options as per their website...and of course they appear to use browned butter as an ingredient. Here is repost on about them from their website: "... OUR STORY Traci and Christa Hozie were stunned when a small cookie began to dominate their deli business. Amongst a menu of paninis and salads, their “shortbread” cookie, which was offered as a sample to customers, continued to be bought out on a daily basis. With the help of family and friends, the sisters could hardly keep up as the cookies flew off the shelves. After many late nights preparing cookies for the next day, they decided to “listen to the cookie” and founded the Brown Butter Cookie Company in December 2008. What began as an inconspicuous sampler cookie would soon become a Central Coast staple requiring the launch of an online shop to sell the sensationally sweet and salty Original Brown Butter Sea Salt cookie nationwide. Since then, the Cookie Company has been featured in the New York Times, Sunset Magazine, The Today Show, Westways, and more! The passion for these cookies has only continued to grow. In the fall of 2013, the sisters opened their second boutique retail shop on the park in the iconic Acron building, downtown Paso Robles, California. Six years later, in the fall of 2019, they celebrated their 10th year in business with the opening of their third retail location. You’ll find the newest shop in charming San Luis Obispo, California, right in the heart of downtown. The Cookie Company continues to make all cookies here on the Central Coast in their new production facility in Atascadero, and in their flagship Cayucos shop.".... For a special snack for kids on a trip, or as a gift for those who cannot make it to the Central Coast, these cookies should be welcome. You will also be supporting a local business and quite a few local workers [well over two dozen], whom they list on their webpage, along with their favorite cookie. Since at least half seem to be of typical College age, it would be nice to also know their career or hobby interests as well. As with many popular eats on the coast, these are a indulgence, as with local Clam Chowder, Cinnamon Buns, Taffy, Ice cream, and in this case cookies. The nutritional information for the "original cookie" shows sat. fat [ 23% DV], sugar [17%] for 1 oz. of cookie. There are traces of Vit. D, iron, Calcium, and Potassium, which come from the 6+ ingredients which are very basic [the top 3 are flour, butter, sugar], and do not include many unwanted chemicals nor preservatives. These are definitely superior to what one finds in supermarkets and rival those of some of the best local bakeries, which are fantastic as well. Of course, it would be best to serve kids, and some adults, a few of these with a tall glass of nutritious milk [with or without Lactase as needed...and lower fat as well...the supermarkets that do carry real milk, from local Happy CA cows, are just off the highway in Morro Bay or Cambria]. Many milk substitutes have poor nutrition, lack protein/calcium, and are loaded with sugar.
Clicca per espandere