This place has served 4 generations of my family. Have never been disappointed. The new owners are great!
Mary De Vincentis Redenbach
+5
Cut my eye teeth on John & Mary's... Remember it when it was just Johnny's... Yes, I'm that old!
John & Mary's is the best! I live on the West Coast and every time I'm in Buffalo, I make sure i swing by and order a chicken fingers & steak sub. Planning on bringing sandwiches back for my family to enjoy!
The cleanest and neatest chicken finger I've had . Very fresh and good quality subs. Would like to explore there menu more . Curly fries is yummy and the prices are very reasonable. Super affordable and high quality . Would recommend to check them out . Packaging is very good also.
This franchise is hometown loving and one I have returned to for decades from my childhood, the subs are better than any I’ve had anywhere in the country, I’ve been back to Buffalo only a few times in 20 years but it’s always my first choice for food and I will never forget the memories I have had in any of their restaurants as a child.
Thanks for always making me feel welcome, you may not know me but I’ll never forget you.
I had a perfect BLT yesterday. Bacon was cooked perfectly. If I didn't devour it I would've taken pics. Def satisfied my craving. 👌🏽
Brought my mom and my aunt while in town they had fond memories of this spot!! The customer service was awesome and the food was great!! Wings.chicken finger sub. Royal sub
I worked at the John & Mary's on Huth & Harlem when I was 18. The two owners (at that time 1968, Mr, Scott and Mr. Gagini) and their families were super!!! Whenever I drive through the area, I stop and buy a Royal Sub...the best of the best. Time to open a diner in Indianapolis!!! Thank you for fantastic subs my whole life (I am 72).
The charbroiled chicken sub is excellent. Paired with onion rings, it's my new go-to for a takeout sandwich on my way home.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes