Bartoli's is a great pizza place that everyone should check out! We had the Chicago Classic deep dish and let me tell you it was delicious! All the ingredients were fresh and the sauce and crust were absolutely amazing. My boyfriend never eats his crust and all I can say is there was nothing left on his plate. Brian has really outdone himself and created an amazing deep dish pizza in a great joint to hang out at. Another plus is that it is BYOB. Can't wait to come back again!
Was in Chicago for an 8 hour lay over. Found this great place online and decided to give a try! So glad me and my fiancé decided to stop in. Not only is the food amazing but the service was great as well. Not everyday does the owner come out, introduce himself and make sure you are enjoying everything! Way to go! If I have time I will definitely be coming back again!
Saw the video on YouTube and since than wanted to visit this place. Finally went there on September 11, 2016 and got vegetarian deep dish pie. Very delicious and crusty. Brought it for my family in New York. Everyone loved it. Will definitely go there again.
My new favorite deep dish pizza!l never thought anything could be better than Lou's, but Bartoli's is better in so many ways. Yummy!!
Shaana LaQuette Shaana
+5
Definitely in my top three places to have deep dish.... Fresh, fast, and feel at home service. My first experience was amazing and I'll be back to enjoy that Italian Beef on Garlic Bread
The pizza was surprizingly delicious. The crust was perfectly crisp and buttery and sauce was perfect! If im ever in the area i will definetly stop in again. But next time doing a fresh whole pizza instead of just a slice.
Awesome pizza and friendly staff. The cornmeal crust on the deep dish is a bite of heaven.
If you like deep dish Chicago style...this is authentic.its not about the ambiance, it's about the PIZZA! We (all seven of us) loved it.
The best pizza that I have ever eaten, plus the staff was very courteous and helpful!
Amazing food and service. Very cool seeing the owner in there as well. Great atmosphere.
We can't stop Raving about Bartoli's. This is the real deal . Everything about it , the sauce, the cheese, the ingredients, the ambiance, the friendly service... definitely will be back
I live down the block the deep dish pizza is delicious and the Southwestern chicken salad is great 2 of my staples
I found Bartoli’s when searching for a unique place to experience deep-dish pizza with my out-of-town friend.
Small cozy place with amazing deep-dish pizza at your service.
We got cheese and pepperoni and it was just as good as we expected!
I was there to try deep dish pizza. I ordered the medium cheese deep dish pizza. I wanted a personal one, but they were unable to make one. That was no problem as I took the left over slices for my airplane ride two days later. I ended up making a pig of myself and ate 4 slices. I had the other two boxes up. The atmosphere was nice, the place was empty, probably due to the Cubs game being played. The neighborhood is very safe and enjoyed my walk back to the L station.
Iconic deep dish pizza for a reasonable price. It was my first experience with this Chicago specialty but I can't imagine it being any better elsewhere. Definitely recommend!
Quite enjoyed my first deep dish pizza in Chicago. The sauce wasn't too sour and nice and chunky.
We had a large delivery order for a bachelorette party. Brian was incredibly helpful in getting our order placed ahead of time. The girls would not stop raving about how good the pizza was - even the next day, all the cold slices were gone! Thin crust is the way to go!!
We did have a mix up with one item in the order but the staff was able to rectify it quickly over the phone and Brian even reached out the following day to apologize. To have the thoughtfulness and care to follow up as he did, is incredibly rare and greatly appreciated.
Highly recommend it if you're in the area!
This has quickly become our favorite pizza in the city. We went from just giving it a chance to ordering it at least once a week with guests and visitors asking us to order when they come over. The ranch is also incredible.
I came to Chicago wishing I could find the BEST authentic deep dish pizza and I did! Bartoli's Pizzeria honestly has the best pizza i have ever had. If you are even close to the area you are going to want to add this to your bucket list!
My girlfriend and I ate here for the first time today, and let me tell you, it was fantastic! We got a Chicago tavern style pizza with fresh sausage, green pepper and just the right amount of cheese. We will definitely be back!
Sauce is slightly sweet and just right. Sausage is perfectly seasoned. Crispy crust but not cracker. Always beats delivery time. Overall the one pie that checks all the boxes for both me and my wife.
Ok moved to Az a few years ago and love it but I do miss Chicago food, especially pizza. Saw the goidbelly app offered pizza and other foods from various cities. I am now no longer pizza deprived. Wish it was little bigger so I could cut it into squares👍🤗💯
One of the best thin crust pizza I tasted in quite a long time .up there with a short list of the best of them.
Had the medium sausage pizza and was enough for two...crisp and very flavorful.
The restaurant was busy with a good wait staff.
Saw this on a list of best deep dish to try in Chicago and didnt disappoint. was the best pizza ive had in my life. Highly recommend to anyone wanting authentic and delicious chicago deep dish. Everything was perfect. the crust was nice and golden and delicious the sauce was flavorful and the ratio of crust to topping to cheese to sauce was ideal. Nothing felt like it was overpowering.
Love this place. Recently discovered this delicious pizza. Living next by and all the time I’m walking by this place it smells soooo good.
Friendly customer service!;)
Great pizza! Their deep dish pepperoni is phenomenal. Their pizza sauce may be the best I’ve ever had, as well. The atmosphere is cozy, and several tables are near a large window that affords good views for people watching. I also appreciate the BYOB policy, and it’s convenient that there is a liquor store across the street with a good variety of (very marked up) alcoholic beverages. I have been thinking about this pizza ever since my visit and look forward to returning to Bartoli’s again!
I can't say for certain how authentic their deep dish Chicago-style pizza is, but it seemed to fit all the criteria I've seen on cooking and travel shows.
And regardless of authenticity, it's totally delicious. We had the spinach and cheese pie, their specialty.
Friendly staff. Small, neighborhoody place. A great stop.
This pizza is legit. I had never heard of them and we ordered a few pizzas for my friends bday… everyone lose their minds. It was so good. I’ve now had it 3 times since then!!! If you love tavern style pizza… order this.
Pretty good pizza! I really liked the ingredients used, and the staff was very friendly! Would totally go again. Though, this might be the tourist in me, but I did like Giordano's slightly better, and mostly because the crust I had at Bartoli's was a bit drier. That said, it could have been sheer luck; maybe the crust I got was a bit different than usual, or the one I got at Giordano's was better than usual (my friend asserts that is the latter). Still, in a vacuum, I like Bartoli's, and would be happy to visit again, and maybe try their other items.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes