5 restaurant menus in Cicero, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Love this place! This is my son's favorite pizza place and hang out! Great food and great staff! Couldn't ask for a better place to get your pizza!!!..."
Jennifer Repko DelPriore
"Pizza and wings were great! Recently moved to Cicero and have tried all the pizza places around the area. Lakeshore pizza is hands down the best!!..."
Marlayna Catanzarite-Salz
"Definitely the best pizza in the area. The staff is great and the owner is a solid..."
Laurie Burlingame
"Easily the best pizza in cicero. And better than most of..."
AJ Marrone
"Just moved near to this pizza place we had wings and pizzas it as delicious my family enjoyed it its gonna be a regular spot I can even walk to..."
Tanica Greene
"My favorite is pepperoni but the white pizza is great too! Now I'm..."
Bill Nickal
"Delicious! Thanks for letting us sit at your picnic table, it was a beautiful night to eat..."
Tracy Zimmer
"Absolutely amazing service and food! Never disappointed. Great work..."
Stephanie Lynne Warner
"Just had med pizza ... Mushrooms, sausage, onion with extra crispy med wings THE BEST all of it THANK..."
Peggy Hewitt Phinney
"Awesommme Pizza...!
Perfect Wings...!
The Best Staff Ever...!
Top Shelf Home Made at Neighborhood Prices...!
These are Good People making Excellent..."
Damian Roberts
"Really awesome pizza and wings this place is really..."
Jordan Jaeger
"Stopped by there last night for the first time since we moved away from Cicero a few months ago.... it was INCREDIBLE as always. If you live in..."
Laura Nelson
"Great pizza & Fast delivery..."
Laura Hulsizer
"Meat lovers pie was incredible..."
Michael Anderson
"Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had. The staff is great! Only place I will order..."
Jennifer Town
"Great pizza, Great wings, Great place to eat in Cicero..."
Chad
"The best pizza in Cicero. 'nuff..."
Josh
"We went on recommendations from a friend. The owner and staff were very friendly. I was impressed, I called before they even opened. They took my..."
Maryel Briggs
"We moved to Cicero about two and a half years ago. I've known about Lakeshore pizza close to 10 years as my friend has lived in Cicero for many..."
Joshua Dunham
"Delicious....a New York style Pizza local. The crust was perfect, lightly salted and just thin enough to hold up the cheese and toppings. This place..."
Thomas Hayduk
"Excellent pizza and wings. Great service and delivery is..."
tripwire
"One of my favorite pizza joints. I enjoy just about every kind of pizza from here. The wings are also very tasty. I will say that you get what you..."
Noah Poirier
"Pizza was good and unlike any sardos pizzeria near you their chicken wings were cooked PERFECTLY. Had a great special for 3 pizzas and 48 wings for..."
George Samson
"A hidden gem. The pizza is amazing and great service. Prices are also very..."
Regina Petrera-chiarizia
"This place is unreal ! I love to go to Buffalo for pizza logs and I have been trying to find something equivalent to Buffalo and I finally found it!..."
Lourese Davis
"Stopped by and ordered for the first time ever tonight. Definitely will be going back. Great pizza and the wings were cooked perfectly. Wings were..."
Chad Ryan
"Best pizza ever! Order almost every day and been ordering since it..."
SiimplyOcto
"Super friendly, and super yummy! Love that Lakeshore pizza is around the corner...we love it, and are lucky they're so close! My husband loves the..."
Blythe Gaming
"Best pizza in Cicero, hands..."
Rob Colvin
"We order often from Lakeshore...tonight there was a mix up...my order was for a pick up and when I got home I was missing my salad. I called and..."
Michele Perrin
"Have ordered at least half a dozen times now, and we are never disappointed. Theres hardly any grease to this pizza, which is a HUGE plus. Great..."
Daniel Andersen
"We ordered from Lakeshore Pizza tonight, our first time.... and man o man.....this is the best Pizza I have had in a long time!!! We were told the..."
CHERYL MEMORY
"Some of the best pizza in CNY. I order from there on a regular basis and it’s always on point. Every time I call the employees are polite and on..."
brian hammond
"Even though we have lived in the area for years this was our first experience. Great pizza and service. Will definitely order..."
Michele Rochkind
"I grew on Lakeshore road for me ist home no matter how far away I live the pizza is the best feels great to be home and have awsome food to, you will..."
"This is the best pizza in central New York! I have going to the latest location since it opened. Paladino's pizza has been a family must for..."
Todd
"My Go To Pizza Place. Absolutlely love this place! Their pizza is hands down the best pizza in the area. Their customer service is better than..."
Nateman8818
"I adore this pizza. Among all the pizza places in the area, this is the only one I crave, and I'm happy they opened a Cicero location. It's..."
Lindsey
"I love going into Paladino's!! The food is superb and the service couldn't be any better (especially that dashing young counter guy on weekends)...."
SB96
"Always accommodating! If it's not on the menu, ask! I've used Paladino's for a few CNS school events and they have never disappointed! When 30 plus..."
Annette
"So good.... We were in town from ottawa for the weekend and found this spot off Urbanspoon...the reviews were so right! Awesome wings, best pizza and..."
JoBed
"Best pizza..."
Amanda
"Awesome pizza, delicious wings....AND they deliver? Yep. Oh and I hear you're going to be open on Sundays now too...perfect for the games! We order a..."
Casey Heick
"Paladinos is by far the best pizza around! There ingredients are always fresh and there pizzas, wings calzones, salads are awesome! They always put..."
Lindsay Miller
"I have been eating their pizza since they opened in Mattydale over 30 years ago. Best pizza ever! So glad they are now in..."
Kevin
"Awesome food! When I order pizza it's always this place. The wings are the best too! They always make them crispy and..."
Sarah
"Outstanding Food. Paladino's is the place to go when you want great food for a great price. Whether you are going for pizza and wings, or eggplant..."
Cindy A.
"Best New York Style Pizza in CNY. So I grew up on Paladino's in Mattydale and always loved it. When Paladin's Cicero opened I thought, could it be?..."
Jason
"MMMmmmm. My favorite pizza place of all time. You have to try their thin crust extra cheese pizza..."
S. Anderson
"YUMMY YUMMY IN MY TUMMY. Best pizza I've ever tasted..."
Scout
"Yum Yum!. Real New York Style Pizza. Crispy crust that is thin but not to much that it gets soggy. Wonderful sauce , cheese and other ingredients..."
Bill M
"Pie-Licious!. I'm a pizzaholic...I've tried probably a sampling of the majority of pizza parlors in the Upstate NY area and while many of them were..."
AJ Knight
"My family loves Paladino's Cicero Pizza. It's the best pizza in town! We've tried others and no one delivers a consistently great product no matter..."
Monica Byrne
"The best pizza in town!!! The crispy crust can't be beat!!! Love us some..."
Shanna
"Best pizza in Syracuse, hands down! The owner is also very friendly and helpful! Can't go wrong with..."
Jackie
"This is the best pizza in syracuse by a mile I have gone to Paladinos mattydale location for 15 years so happy they are in Cicero now! Dan..."
Dan Mulpagano
"Incredible pizza and wings keep up the good..."
Jeffd
"I’ve gone here for years and never reviewed because I never really think about voicing my opinion but I decided to finally. As a long time customer..."
Caden Dambach
"Best pizza I’ve had in over 40 years! We’re just passing through and the desk clerk at the hotel recommended this for delivery. We were not..."
Bev Nichols
"Today was something really exciting that happened to me as I saw the time was closer to 8 pm and had doubt if they would pick the order, to my..."
Shabu Mathew
"Delicious Pizza, Great Personal service. Very clean and a nice family atmosphere, with plenty of seating.
Myself and my Daughter really enjoyed our..."
Bill Sutorius
"Best chicken wing pizza I have ever tasted. I couldn't resist and took a bite before taking a picture. 2nd time and quality is as good as the 1st..."
Hanny Almagrabi
"Literally my favorite pizza place in Syracuse! This place is clean and the food is amazing. Huge deal to me. This place is usually swamped (great..."
Linda Hawley
"My experience with them was very good. Their pizza is a traditional NY style pizza the crust is good and thin, but not cracker crunchy thin, and the..."
WildBill 1989
"This was our first time ordering their "everything" wing sauce, and will definitely not be our last! The sauce was delicious and the wings were..."
Jackie Woods
"Sooo good!! Pizza was amazing, dough was perfect. Boneless wings - top 5 I’ve ever had. Garlic Knots - fantastic!
Cool inside, great air..."
Andrew Proctor
"Traveling through New York, we stopped here for dinner. Staff was very friendly, even though I had four young children in town. Really made us feel..."
"We ordered tonight after not ordering from there in a while. Everything was Perfect! The fried cauliflower can't be beat, the fried dough was amazing..."
Jennifer George
"Pizza was very good (filling with thick cheese, yet still thin enough overall to be considered New York style) , but what made this a wonderful..."
Jason Borges
"I stopped by myself after shopping at Walmart hadn’t been here in years but I remember it was very good . I came in and was seated quickly the..."
Douglas
"We were in town for a few days for a local event and discovered this restaurant. Pizza was delicious and cooked to perfection , we also ordered a..."
Marco Cannon
"I have NEVER left a review before but after our experience here, I must! Not one part of our experience was less than perfection. Portion sizes..."
Emily DeFazio
"Great food and friendly staff, been going there for a long long time. 1 of the few places that have anchovies. My wife loves the eggplant dinner ..."
michael truax
"Omg..the simple small chef salad was delicious.service was astounding.wings were ok...maybe a bit old..we are making this small business a place to..."
Bob Quinn
"The deep dish pizza is like pizza hut in the 1980s. Only..."
john armstrong
"The very best pizza in the area. Friendly staff and fair prices. I judge other pizzas by comparing with Cicero Country’s. Usually no comparison!..."
George Hotaling
"Phenomenal pizza! We got a pepperoni and garlic pizza. We chose this place because of other reviews and they were definitely right. Amanda was our..."
Amanda Kennedy
"I haven't been here in 10 years, it was even better than I remembered.
I may be a little biased but my family is currently making plans to go again..."
Billy Sotherden
"Best pizza and wings around Syracuse..."
David Wang
"We love Cicero Country so much we had their pizza for our rehearsal dinner years ago. The decor of the dining room is a bit plain Jane but it's a..."
Rachel Vryhof
"The staff is timely and friendly and the food is absolutely..."
Cindy Hanchett
"Simple Italian restaurant that's been serving Pizza for over four decades. Classic style ambiance inside, with homemade style pizza and Italian..."
J. Shaun
"Lost power just as food was delivered to table,but all went..."
Renee H
"Delicious food and a fun atmosphere! We bring our family and friends here all the time! The waitresses are really funny and make everyone feel..."
"Awesome seafood. Seafood platter had fish, crab cakes, and stuffed shrimp. Came with side and salad for $15.95. Nice deal and great..."
Mylene Santos
"Would give em another try. Prime rib was a sub par.,not as thick or juicy as i have had elsewhere., maybe i just had a bad cut. my wife really..."
Feedmegood
"Good Bar Food. Not a high end restaurant, just basic food with a good..."
Tom
"Great place. Awesome deal on streamers on Tuesday! And it server, Deb, was a sweetheart. Mom loved her chowder and shrimp cocktail...."
Diana Liptak
"Got the fish and chips special, was very fresh however it didn’t have much spice or flavor to it. Seemed to have a group of older folks for lunch..."
Amanda
"My boyfriend and I came here after work. The waitress is so nice patient and beautiful. l ordered chicken and broccoli, it was excellent. My..."
Marcheri Williams
"Great food and service. Had my Canadian Thanksgiving meal here. It's off the Interstate a bit and looks like a hole in the wall from the outside but..."
Dwight Fidler
"Great food and great service! My wife had the Hash Brown Haddock and I had one of the specials--Fried Clam Strips with a baked potato and a side of..."
Scott Lawrence
"Friendly waitstaff and the wings are excellent. The food is always amazing, especially the seafood, and it is cooked to perfection. Most of it is..."
Lee Ferenc
"We're looking for a good place to eat. Found this place on Google Maps and they had good reviews. Glad we went there. The food was very good n worth..."
Nanette Trank-Braund
"Frank's is a great value for your money. It is a locally owned and operated restaurant with a nice bar. The clams and homemade clam chowder are out..."
Thomas Hayduk
"Nice comfortable atmosphere. Good prices on great food ! Super friendly staff, Crystal, Sheena and Chase are wonderful and Frank is always welcoming..."
Jamie Pendt
"It was our first time eating here, and we all were very surprised! Steaks were made perfectly, clams tasted delicious, and everyone was very..."
"We ordered from TT....our salad was missing when it was delivered. BUT.............a while later they showed up and delivered the salad! (nothing I..."
Blythe Gaming
"We are never disappointed when we order from Twin Trees. Pizza and wings are always awesome as well as all their menu items. Employees are always..."
Kristin Mingolelli
"We had pizza delivered tonight. I was told delivery would be an hour to an hour and a half. It was a little under an hour when the pizza was..."
Colleen Mozo
"I love two trees pizza. So nothing bad to say. Everyone has there own opinions on taste of..."
Walter Edwin Vanderzee Jr
"There was a mother and small child there and she was yelling and swearing at the child which everyone could hear but no staff asked her yo quiet..."
laurie typhair
"I don't usually do reviews unless it's good...for all you people traveling this place is on pointe ..highly..."
Ronald Shope
"Stopped here for Pizza with friends. Pizza was good, but not great. We had it to go so I can't say much about the atmosphere itself. Service was..."
Roy Smith
"The wing game, though! They aren’t even playing! Get the medium and thank Bella and Alex for their hospitality. I love going here and will be back..."
Tori & Christopher
"bella is the best server and the food is great!! pizza you can always count on being good..."
Tori Recuparo
"Food was great. The pizza was cooked just right along with wings. I gave a rating of 4 because of the high..."
Joseph Paone
"Fine food, prices have gotten a bit..."
Dean Kloss
"Always great pizza and tried the garlic fries appetizer!!! Very good, will get it..."
Lisa Berkery
"Really good pizza, the crust was..."
Amy Del Prete
"Very nice people food is 10/10. pizza is the best in syracuse..."
Cameron Stanley
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes