Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in City Island
2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"This place is in city island. Table for 2 spent about $139 total. The food was okay. Rice was a little salty. Drink wasn't bad, not too strong. There..."
Shemika Barker-Daughtry
"A great place to go to. Exceptional service with a great knowledge of the menu. The New York Strip was juicy and tasty. I am not a seafood person..."
Luis Stiller
"We had the Zuppa and fried calamari
The seafood was very fresh. The Zuppa with the lobster, shrimp, muscles, and clams was amazing. I would say the..."
Carlos E. Montoya Jr.
"I could not let this day pass without writing this review. My Fiancé andI had the pleasure of visiting Artie’s today. THE SERVICE WAS PHENOMENAL...."
Evelyn Colon
"Great restaurant with amazing service. Our waiter, Nick was amazing, coming back especially for him! He made our experience top..."
Tahvia Brown
"I had the jerk-seasoned mahi mahi, very tasty and moist.
Friends all had shellfish, mussels or calamari, they all seemed to thoroughly enjoy it..."
Tori Nona
"Ask for Platinum Patty she is absolutely one of the best periodt!!!! Such an amazing service experience. Such a great experience from arrival to..."
Latasha P Lessington
"Wonderful variety of seafood and Italian staples. Portions are generous. We shared oysters and the half shell and the grilled octopus. They were both..."
elalva
"Great place in the city island area! Calamari was very fresh and tender and the veal francés that I tried was exceptional. Atmosphere is good..."
Nick Kogkas
"Everyone of our entrées were cooked to perfection, add to perfectly seasoned, and large portions, attentive staff and great service, our wonderful..."
Dom Jr
"I went to Artie's to meet up with a friend that I haven't seen in 5 years. We started off with mango mojitos which were delicious. We shared cran..."
Michael Dwyer
"Food is good, service is great. We were given clam chowder and bread as an appetizer and forewarned that a large group entered before we did and our..."
Artistiq Renovations
"Went here with my husband.
Appetizers - clam chowder, fried calamari. It was good not the best we’ve had but pretty good.
Drinks - frozen mango..."
D H (Dee)
"I've been coming here for over 20 years.
Found it pretty much by accident then, just driving around City Island on a rainy Saturday night looking for..."
Nick Menendez
"This Restaurant is GREAT. It was my first time dining here and I loved everything about it. I came for lunch and it wasn't too busy at the time. The..."
Jabriel Perez
"This place was great! The portions were large and the food was tasty! The waiters were super too! The raw oysters were so fresh and delicious. ..."
Mei Tam
"The food and staff are beyond at this establishment! We hosted a small baby shower there and everything was phenomenal. Laura was a please to deal..."
"Been here once during the week, it was quite, with one other table seated but service was still great, and the food was good. Staff is attentive and..."
Eugene Harrigan
"My friend and I went because we had a Groupon ticket. Food was delicious and authentic. Think we came early because it was very empty. Drinks were..."
Janese Gabay
"I completely recommend this place for delicious and amazing food with outstanding service. It is a very quiet small restaurant upstairs and the..."
Gisela
"Our wedding reception was November 2018. It was everything I dreamed of and more. Paul the owner was there every step of the way and went above and..."
Anna Lisa Amanini
"I had my graduation party at Scavello’s and I had the greatest experience from start to finish! Paul was a gracious host and executed my vision..."
Mimi Gyamfi
"Had a delicious seafood combo lunch. The lobster bisque soup was great. The waiter named Luis was very attentive and spoke English and Spanish very..."
Sylvia Water
"Good food and service, very friendly staff. We had a birthday dinner here and everyone was happy with their food. Portions were generous enough to..."
Sandy C.
"This restaurant was a super super nice the food was delicious the staff was so humble and nice the restaurant view was espectacular the lights the..."
Yohanna Garcia
"Nice and quiet on a Sunday good service the food is fresh I did not detect any artificial cheese on my eggplant Parm Ihad Lemon butter chicken was..."
Sandra Kc
"The food was GREAT! The service was amazing and the atmosphere was fantastic! We will be back..."
Mitchell A
"I came here for a wedding ceremony. Their service was very professional. they served us with everything that we needed water, drinks, food and in a..."
Prf Gee
"We held our HS prom here last week. The decor was elegant, we did not have to decorate too much. The food was delicious and plentiful and the place..."
Gabriela P
"The restaurant is very comfy. It has a nice decor and relaxing atmosphere. The waiters were so attentive and pleasant. The food definitely Amazing...."
J Soler
"Not bad for a catering hall. Drinks were good. Food not bad either. Hall is really nice and huge. We had a nice time at our End Term..."
Joanna Zdziaszek
"This place was the bomb omg first we got there late and they still let us in, then we get in and they automatically start giving us things to eat,..."
Mortia Walker
"A beautiful well-kept park, a gorgeous view of the river, friendly staff, interesting for all..."
Nadin Gold
"We had a phenomenal retirement party at Scavello's On The Island. The service was superb! We can’t thank the team at Scavello’s enough for a..."
A.R. T
"We had our church anniversary dinner here. It was a good experience. I would definitely recommend this restaurant for future..."
Michael Johnson
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes