American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Cold Spring Harbor
5 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Cutest coziest coffee shop in town. So well decorated and homey. Perfect for a hour or two of work/studying. Coffee - hot and cold - are delicious,..."
Daniella DiMatteo
"Adorable coffee dessert shop .. good coffee was hot almost too hot for a hot day and I loved the size of the donut Boston cream btw.. not too big..."
Belkys Diaz
"Frida Panda loves the Sweetie Pies on Main garden area, I love their teas, and my husband their treats and coffee..."
Priscilla Antunez
"Charming and Adorable place that has something for everyone! Delicious vegan options 😋❤️
Excellent service. Clean. Friendly. Convenient..."
Jeanette Keith
"Such a nice and quiet place, thir coffee and baked goods are nice. It has a warm comfortable..."
Ray
"This place is so cute and tempting! With an assortment of different goodies and coffee, Sweetie Pies has us all pandering, "what treat should I have..."
Joseph Fravola
"Ok, this our favorite Sunday’s coffee stop.
Unlimited things to try, almond croissant is irresistible.
Outside seating is beautiful.
Must try,..."
neville chauhan
"Been dying to try this place and it didn't disappoint. Probably the best cold brew I've had on Long Island so far. The chocolate chip scone was a..."
Katie N.
"Delicious coffee and desserts. A great place to sit and enjoy. The servers also took great care of..."
Abdul Mahmood
"Yummy🤩😍!! This was the BEST warmed vegan blueberry coconut muffin I’ve ever had in my life! I will absolutely be coming back here for more!..."
"You can choose a table which you want and order food at the register.
They serve food in the boxes, and you can enjoy at the Cafe or take it with..."
Galyna Shulimova
"We really loved the place. Friendly, clean and excellent food. We ordered three different types of sandwiches and each was absolutely perfect. The..."
Kate Goldberg
"I was so hungry I could eat a whale, but settled for 2 shrimp tacos instead that were so good! My wife had a grilled chicken sandwich that she..."
Matt Seinberg
"Looked up a brunch spot, found this spot on google maps. Told my wife about it and went for brunch. We ordered the Breakfast B.L.T, Egg Avocado Wrap,..."
Jiovani Rivera
"Love the Whaler!
Go-to place for coffee and muffins, scones, croissants and lots of other breakfast(and lunch) choices. Food always delicious, coffee..."
Harriet Kapner
"Lovely eatery in the heart of town. Denise is delightful and gets to know her customers. Homemade biscuits are out of this world. We ordered a..."
sandeebeech
"Great food and great people. oh, my God, blueberry scones, and chai tea! Highly..."
Ira Spector
"Fantastic place on main Street in Cold spring harbor. We went here before hiking on the Nassau-Suffolk trail, which is right nearby. Loved everything..."
Randy Solomon
"We love the food here and it's super cute, but it is EXPENSIVE. We got a breakfast wrap, a biscuit sandwich with only egg no meat or cheese, and two..."
Jillian Forte
"Wonderful place for a brunch with friends on a fall afternoon. The food was delicious and came out quickly. The baked goods looked so fresh and..."
Kaitlyn Schneider
"The Gourmet Whaler is an exlemplary staple to the Cold Spring Harbor community.
This spot checks every box from delicious food options, great..."
Liv B
"You can tell right away from the moment that you step inside that the owners put their heart and soul into this amazing place. The atmosphere and..."
Kirstie Totter
"@Nick: Best person working there. ReAlly funny and helpful. Really takes care of the customer.👌
-Best lobster rolls on the island/NYS - both in..."
Will Johns
"I love Gourmet Whaler, I have been going here for a long time. The food is fantastic and they people are super sweet. I think that this place is a..."
Emma Tozer
"Delicious food and great people. We had avocado toast and egg&avocado wrap. Soooo tasty. Forgot to mention, the best latte in the area. Love..."
Tatyana Mudraya
"This place has THE BEST salads!!!!! The grilled chicken is wonderful.
I was just there today and it was popping! So many people but the customer..."
B
"Pleasant lunch Cafe. Order and pay first, food served at table. Cuban sandwich and Philly cheese were excellent. Could only eat half of my sandwich...."
"I went for lunch with my family. We ordered the seafood tower, salads, peas fries were fun, tacos were great, shrimp and grits were ok shrimp was..."
Vivian A. Herman
"Had a very nice meal at Sandbar the other night, had the fish and chips and swordfish. For appetizers. We had the duck tacos and shrimp cocktail...."
David Rubin
"I just used the private room at the Sandbar for my mother's surprise birthday party and can't say enough wonderful things about my experience. They..."
Amanda Lapidus
"We had Lunch of Chopped salad (TOPPED GRILLED CHICKEN) ordered take-out, which was very good.
My friend and I enjoyed very much. Made out trip out..."
REBEKAH Mae
"What an amazing experience! Service was incredible, food exceeded our expectations! Highly..."
Michael Maduske
"As an out-of-towner, this is a super cute and cozy spot to try. We ordered a Margarita Pizza with Meatballs, a Lobster Roll and some Fish & Chips;..."
Nicole Velez (Mysticfoodie)
"Excellent atmosphere, exceptional service staff, good food, hit or miss seafood, sometimes Excellent amazing fish and chip, sometimes soggy not..."
Danny Yang
"Been to the sandbar twice now. Went once for lunch and once for brunch. Brunch is Sundays 12pm-4pm only.
The interior design and decor are classy in..."
Nicholas Themelis
"Our dinner experience was spectacular. We were warmly greeted by James and his team. Our server Marco informed us of the new items on the menu. The..."
Marcy Klein
"We had a party of 5 adults celebrating my sister's birthday. I reserved a round table specifically NOT on the left at entrance. We were assured more..."
Nancy Marano Silva
"It's true that there is a popular restaurant down the block, but if you have seen a sunset already and just want a good meal in a really nice place,..."
Steven Gildin
"Great food with service to match. Wonderful..."
David Brensilber
"A wonderful spot in the heart of Cold Spring Harbor.
Aesthetically pleasing and comfortable. Just a really nice atmosphere.
The entire staff was..."
Paul Vetrano
"Great dinner spot. Sat outside, got the Duck tacos, jerk chicken tacos and halibut, all were excellent. Got the chick pea fries as well, a must try..."
Jennifer Kramer
"Beautiful setting with the Long Island Sound in walking distance. I came from Maryland yesterday to have lunch with my mom and sister and drove..."
Nancy Carrico
"Four of us had dinner this week at Sandbar. It was an outstanding experience. Everything from the atmosphere, the service, the presentation, and..."
Daniel Siegel
"Outstanding dinner at Sandbar! Everyone raved about their dishes(lobster roll, fish and chips, risotto and Cacio e Pepe) which were prepared..."
Amy Siegel
"Great place! Food was excellent. Staff was professional, personable and non-instrusive. Downtown Cold Spring Harbor is..."
Garlic Roasted Olive Oil Olive Tapenade and Hummus
Duck
Check Parmesan Che
Arugula
Oyster
Pappardelle
Mussels
Bacon Wrapped Dates
Octopus
Tiramisú
Halibut
Bolognese
Mousse de Chocolate
Bananas Foster
Crème Brûlée
Pesto
Surf and Turf
Fish
Lobster Roll
Espresso
Shrimp
Bananas Foster
Margarita pizza
Roasted Monk Fish
Gnocchi
Lobster
Roasted Lamb Chops
Classic Cioppino
Pasta
Veal Chop Margharita
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Jazz Bar
Reservations
Late Night
Dinner
Brunch
Mid-range
"Always have great quality food, beautiful live music, and a great atmosphere, all in such a beautiful town! This is one of my go-to restaurants..."
Holly Grabowski
"This was a fantastic dining experience. It had great ambiance, really delicious food, wonderful live music, terrific staff and an awesome bar!
Our..."
Paul Vetrano
"First time here. Came for restaurant week. Will definitely be back again! Some of my family has been coming for years.
Top notch food and service..."
Sue Bella
"From the beginning to the end, it was an incredible experience. We received a warm welcome, even on a bustling evening. Brian, our server, provided..."
Elizabeth M.
"I popped in for dinner on a rainy night after I strolled around by the harbor. Lovely little downtown in Cold Spring Harbor. They took great care of..."
Zacharie Stephen
"This restaurant excels in all areas of specialty. The food, the service, the atmosphere… the best of the best. I came here solely for the reason of..."
Kimberly Quinn
"My friends and I decided to have a late lunch after a nice hike at Cold Spring Harbor. We chose Grasso s and we were not dissapointed. The Watermelon..."
Ana Roman
"Brian is the quintessential waiter.
He has the diner's best interest at heart.
A true asset to..."
Mark Schulman
"We enjoyed Sunday Brunch on the patio in front. It was perfect for our toddler to be a little loud and also entertained by the sidewalk traffic.
The..."
Kristen Slevin
"My wife and I dined at Grasso's last night and LOVED it! Would give SIX stars if I could. Kelly and Georgia waited on us and they were fantastic...."
"Second time here and the food was consistently delicious. We had Thai calamari, the crab cake and a burger. The burger wasn’t anything notable but..."
Kristina Centnere
"An amazing restaurant and a great value food. Wonderful service and a great view. Food was delicious and great flavor. We all enjoyed and had fun...."
nikhil sinha
"My friends and I decided to grab brunch before doing a hike right besides this restaurant and didn't expect to stumble into a nice little gem. The..."
Alison W
"Amazing drinks and food. It is right by the water so has an amazing view especially from the second floor by the window. The servers were also..."
hemmy cho
"I love this place! Delicious food, nice staff, beautiful views, and dog friendly! Will def be going back!..."
Danielle
"The food is delicious, the drink menu needs work, there are a lot of bugs flying around the outside sitting area. But other than that amazing. (Also..."
Daniel Georgia
"Wonderful place for a celebration or a regular night out. We've been here many times. The food is always top notch and the service is superb. Love..."
Emily C-G
"One of the finest dining experiences in a long time. Luis and Nico were extraordinary servers. The food and cocktails were amazing. Linguini with..."
John C
"Arrived on a Saturday afternoon around 230p and was seated outside under a tent, they gave us a menu w just bfast items. We asked if they were..."
AClayton
"The best thing about this restaurant is the view of the harbor. Service is pretty good too. Food was okay depending on what you get. Scallops and..."
Ukiyo
"Such a cute restaurant! Great views and excellent service. We had a bunch of appetizer and split a salad for lunch and it was very good! Highly..."
Jessica Baylis
"Upstairs is a better setup than on the 1st floor. Needs reservations. Saturday had many people. The food was simple, expected but very well prepared...."
Nata
"Thoroughly enjoyed my experience at Harbor Mist. Attentive staff, gorgeous view and great portions. Their seafood is fresh and their lamb chops were..."
nicole pourgol
"Nice restaurant. Went during off hours for a quick bite. The servers were very..."
Alan S
"Food was good service excellent very attentive been there several times pretty consistent cannot..."
Rick Woods
"We were in the area and looking for a spot by the water and found this. The restaurant is in a great quiet spot.
They give you complimentary bread..."
NYCBuddha
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes