Reviews Five Star Pizza

We are not from the area and thought it was a restaurant with beer, when we realized it wasn't we decided to take the pizza to go, so we placed our order as a carryout and waited for it. Definitely a mistake not calling it in ahead of time, they are busy before 4pm! Good for them! We love to see businesses thriving! Despite being busy, service was great. The friendly cashier took our order right away and got it in the line of orders. My kids loved their soda selection. Great local brands! Nice to see this! While waiting, we admired their amazing selection of homemade cheesecake slices that all looked like heaven. I wish I would have gotten one. We waited a while for the pizza to be ready but again, it was totally our fault for not calling ahead. But even after a long wait, it was worth it! Absolutely fantastic pizza! Everything about it was awesome. Perfect ratio of crust-to-sauce-to-cheese. The sauce is super good, lots of flavor but not overpowering and it wasn't dripping off the edges. We are not a fan of overly-saucy pizzas. Pepperoni was crispy on the edges. Cheese had a nice light browning but not burnt. Its the kind of pizza that is so good you even enjoy the crust. It's not a thin crust but it's not thick. It's a great hand-tossed style slightly on the thinner side. It was also cooked just right. I don't think there is any way that it could have been better than what we got. I wish there was one of their locations closer to me because I would absolutely order it again. My children both said they like it better than our local places back home and I agreed. The bread was a little doughy but the place isn't called "Five Star Bread", so I'll let them pass on that. :) if I was at home I would have thrown them in the air fryer for a minute and I guarantee they would have been outstanding. But the bread didnt matter because the pizza stole the show and honestly, if we were staying in Colon a few more days we would have stopped back in for another! Thanks for the fantastic lunch! One day when we are back on that side of the state we will call ahead and place a pickup order!

Stopped in after a Bball game with 20 people. They took us all in and we had great service and great food.

I always stop in for a yummy pizza when I'm back home.

Always hit this place up every year! The crust is best I've ever had!!! Sauce could be a bit sweeter but still was great! Pepperoni had so much flavor again best I've had! I would give this a 8.5/10. Fix the sauce add a tiny bit sweeter easily 10/10 🍕

I make special trips to Colon just for their pizza and subs!

The owner accommodated our bridal party this weekend. We were across the street and Five Star Pizza started our pizzas early for us and were so helpful. We even got a tour of the new renovations. The pizza was fantastic and we couldn't have been more pleased. Thank you, Five Star!

We come from Florida even year to vacation an see family. We always make sure to get five star, 20 inch pizzas. We get at least 8 pizzas in 2 weeks. Very loyal, long time, happy customers 😁