LOVE this place. We have lived near them for a while....didn't know they delivered for the longest time. Love it even more now. Get the "Special" salad. It's the greatest! Would recommend this place to anyone.
Pizza is a highly contested food. People vary on what they like exactly. I have my favorite pizza place so I was disappointed when I tried this as I expected a lot. It was good but being rated the highest pizza in Columbus on Zomato I was let down.
This is by far the best PIZZA in Columbus! Been going for 28 years!! This is where I'm bringing my family to celebrate my birthday tomorrow! Get ready for us Emelios I'm bringing over 20 people with me! The salad is to die for too!!!
Great Pizza. The pepperoni they use is excellent. Im a huge fan of crispy pepperoni on pizzas, and this place has it!
On that note, the Special Salad that contains crispy baked Pepperoni is awesome!
Amazing. Best pizza is town... well maybe in Ohio. Also the salad is one of the best things on the menu
AMAZING!!. My family is obsessed with Emelio's. We have taken many friends there, and now they crave it just as much as I do. The pepperoni is piled high and super crunchy. Their special salad and subs are a must try also!! We live about 20-25 minutes away but it is worth the drive. We always make sure we order enough so we can take some home for the next day. )
I have been going to emelio's for their pizza since I was about 5 years old. I love this place, and whenever I am back in Columbus visiting, I make it a point to go back there for their amazing pizza and special salad. Best pizza in Columbus!
BEST PIZZA in Columbus!!!!!! If you have never been, go now. I've been going since I was a kid.
Thanks bro-in-law for this.... Thanks bro-in-law for this one! The Cheers of pizza places! Amazing special salad w/ baked pep. best garlic bread. Awesome pizza. THEY know what double cheese means! Worth our drive from Worthington! If u got a place with better salad, garlic bread OR pizza, I wanna know about it!
12/22/2023
Some of the best pizza in Columbus! You have to get the special salad! It has crispy fried pepperoni and the best Italian dressing I've ever had! Love this place!
Delicious. This pep pizza was excellent!
I ate here a few years ago and it was delicious. I was telling a coworker about it today and remembered I never left a review. It was one of the best pizzas and salad I've ever had. Will definitely eat there again someday.
This is one of the best pizza i've ever had in Columbus. Takes a special kind of
je rk to give this place a bad review because they don't like their spicy pizza.
We have been coming to Emilio's for years and the food is always good. We were in yesterday evening to amazing service and had the most delicious pizza and special salad we have had so far! Compliments to the Saturday Evening Staff! Wonderful job!!
Truly the best Pizza in town. The "Special Salad" is exceptional. The staff and owners are truly wonderful. They pour a really good drink too.
We come up from Florida every year and Emelios is our first destination. We dream about their pizza and salad!! Lol BEST EVER. Our waitress was fabulous too.
The pizza is flavorful. Crust is crunchy and good. Pepperoni and cheese are really flavorful and good quality. The sub was just a regular Italian sub and the Special Salad was um, unique.They put cooked pepperonis in it and their Italian dressing is house made. A little to strong of a vinegar taste for me but allot of people love it.
We come to Emelio's every year to watch Ohio State beat Penn State. They were really packed this year, which was enjoyable - more people to cheer with.
Their special salad and pizza are always 100%.
This was our first time visiting Emelio's.
Setting outside on the patio with the umbrella open, 77ﾟ,with just a little bit of sun popping through the fence.
Our visit was a delightful and pleasant atmosphere.
Order a meat pizza and salad, and let me end here by saying YUM!
P.S. the staff was friendly with smiling faces. Make a point to get here soon. 🍽.
Saw a lot of good reviews on this place and decided to check it out. Ordered a half pepperoni/mushroom and mushroom/cheese. Also ordered the garlic/cheese bread. They have it set up for one person at a time in the building. Pizza had a slightly spicy sauce on it with a ton of cheese. The pizza had old world pepperoni that was nice and spicy. Garlic cheese bread also very cheesy but a little burnt around the edge. Staff was very friendly and brought the pizza out to my car. Place was super busy at the time. Will return just to check it out in some normal times.
While DJing today ,my laptop got rained on and malfunctioned Carly and her amazing staff jumped into action and helped me get through the ceremony flawless . I wish I knew the rest of the staffs named they were wonderful....and the food was FANTASTIC !!! Thank you thank you thank you 10 stars !!!
Emelio's has never let me down on quality of food, service, and atmosphere. Maria was extremely sweet. 10/10 will recommend. It's.mine and my sister's favorite.
Absolutely amazing pizza with friendly staff definitely would recommend if you’re in the area. Amy, Brandon & Trent are awesome
This place took me back to when life was simple. Friendly people 1980s vibe excellent food, the meatballs the salad the pizza and especially the pepperoni that's in the salad. You got to try this place.
Square cut pizza, crisp pepperoni, good flavor, great service, didn't get crispy pepperoni in salad, would return
I have never had a bad experience here! Are pepperoni and mushroom pizza has always been right on! Service is amazing! Oh and don't forget if you get to get there freaking amazing salad oh my God you can go anywhere else for salad! Thank you guys!
Old school place. I like their pizza but I will go across town to get their “special salad”. It defeats all of the healthy reasons for eating a salad but it’s good!
We love our real Italian pizza, The service is great also the people are so nice there.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes