Reviews James Street Pizza Co.

For you out of towners, Amtrack has a station In Columbus, WI. In case you don't drive or don't want to drive there.

Delicious NY-style pizza. Dining room is currently closed due to pandemic, they do a great job of maintaining safety for carryout (pay online and pick-up is safely distanced). Highly recommend.

If I could give 10 stars I would! The pizza / food is awesome. The people are always kind and friendly. Delivery / carry out always goes smoothly. Online ordering is great. Also, the owners recently donated pizza to our local hospital which was very kind. I will continue to support such an awesome local restaurant. THANK YOU.

Fantastic food, my husband and I love their wings, and we have raved about their food to friends and family. My first sad interaction with them came from an order I placed just the other day. I ordered a custom pizza with three toppings. Pepperoni, bacon, and banana peppers. When the pizza arrived, it had only the pepperoni and bacon, no peppers. Normally, if this were a "free" topping, I would have just written this off. But the toppings all cost money, so when I didn't get one that I ordered, I felt disappointed. I sent an email to the address provided on my e-receipt, along with a picture of the pizza, and never got a response. I just would have liked some acknowledgement, anything. But all I got was silence and it feel bummed. I love the food, but being ignored has kinda made me feel bummed. Edit: The owner reached out to me very promptly, and the misunderstanding regarding the email was finally solved! I am content with this simple acknowledgement, and my husband and I look forward to our next date night with the best wings in town!

What a delicious pizza place and extremely wonderful owners thank you for all you do.