Best Buffalo Chicken Pizza in Columbus

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Roosters Sawmill
Roosters Sawmill
91/100 (1031 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Fried Pickles
Traditional Wings
Cold Beer
Dumpster Fries
Chicken Quesadilla
Rooster Salad
Cider
Roosters Spicy Ranch
Rooster Chicken Wrap
Garlic Boneless Wings and House Salad
Nu-Killas with Nashville Hot Chicken Wings
Soft-Baked Pretzels
Big Bob's BBQ Burger
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Draft Beer
Potato Skins
Mac and Cheese Bites
Fried Chicken Salad
Dressing
Tater Tots
American
Dinner
Lunch
Roosters Restaurant & Bar
Roosters Restaurant & Bar
84/100 (144 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
American
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
mozzarella sticks
Cider
Blue Jackets Free Chili Chant Chili
Lemonade
Chili Fried Mushrooms Tater Tots
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Italian Sub Garlic Hot Wings Donkey Wings Steak Fries
Blue Moon Belgian White
Potato Skins
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Fried Chicken Salad
Meat Lovers Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Corn Dogs
Traditional Wings Sweet BBQ
Wings
Plain Bone in Wings
Wine
Rooster Salad
Beer
Sit down
Bar
Pub
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Oh Pizza And Brew
Oh Pizza And Brew
80/100 (5655 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Pizza
American
Italian
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Beer
Awesome Sauce Wings
18 Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza Well Done
Kaua'i Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Thai Chili
Hawaiian Pizza
Baby Bellas
Taco Pizza
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo with Garlic Bread
Funnel Cake
10 Pizza and Onion Rings
Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni Half Mushroom
Pretzel Bites
Chicken Wings
Fried Pickles
Deep Fried Oreos
Salad
Loaded Tots
Wings
Bone in Wings
Café
Pizza
Italian
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"We've been trying to find a decent pizza place downtown and we not only found decent but our go-to pizza place. This pizza is AMAZING, not to..."
Angie Leggett
"Anyone who knows me knows I really do not like pizza but this pizza was crazy good and the breadsticks are absolutely to die for I will drive out of..."
Pamela Diamond
"Easily my favorite pizza place. Every time I'm in Columbus I always stop here every day. Then I get an order to bring back home with me. From all the..."
Trevor Brummitt
"Great service, amazing pizza and fries! The mushroom garlic pizza is awesome and they have the best gluten-free crust I have ever..."
Kelly Archer Tamerlano
"Very courteous employees. Delicious pizza!! We were in town and craving yummy local pizza and had seen great reviews on this place. We called in a..."
Courtney McKinley
"This is the best pizza I have ever had in my life. This was my first order and everything was wonderful. I used to work at pizza hut and I know the..."
Jaya Lee Russell
"Had a dance competition this weekend and the only place open was here. Well it was worth it the wings flavor was amazing. Sat down to eat anothet..."
Holly Henderson
"Best gluten free pizza delivery I've found anywhere and I've never had a cross contamination issue. Great..."
James Douglas
"Spectacular food, great spices, open late night. Too many good things to say about this place! And the customer service is..."
Dylan R Menard
"My buddy and I ordered a Bypass pizza, breadsticks, buffalo chicken tots, and the deep fried PB&J. Some of the best food I've eaten in a long..."
Tyler Simola-Wallingford
"I was visiting Columbus for a conference and ordered a pizza sub. Best sub ever! Went back the next night for philly cheese sub and a beer. Great..."
Andrew Wheelock
"I have to say that this is the absolute BEST pizza place in Columbus, Ohio. Someday I'll branch out and try something else on their menu other than..."
Dave Riley
"AWESOME FOOD! Boneless wings are stiff competition to Roosters. Fried pickles are delicious and funnel cake was better than the fair's with cherry..."
Heather Morrison
"From out of town, working late. Googled food near me. Got the "chicken coop" pizza to go. Excellent pie! Wish I'd had time to sit down and enjoy a..."
Jason Johnson
"The food is stellar! I like the BBQ chicken pizza the best and the Wedgzilla is perfect for bacon lovers!! Bring back text..."
Rob Theisen
"My co-worker suggested to try OH Pizza & Brew so I just ordered a delivery, I got the "Bypass" pizza. Thank you for getting here at a good time & the..."
Jamie Riggle
"This is my go to place for awesome subs, wings and pizza always delicious and fresh!!..."
John Pinna
"I order from here regularly, and they keep getting better. I also enjoy spicy food past the point of normal human enjoyment, and I typically order..."
Lindsey Klun
"We were visiting Columbus for The Dead&Co Show. Fantastic pizza, and great service from the staff. I understand Why it’s named a Top 10 Pizza Joint..."
Tony Rudd
"The best. ..first time won't be the last ..tastes like my hometown pizza jac and do's will spread the word. .the driver was kewt too..."
Robert A Long III
"We were in town for two nights and went to the pizza truck at The Ruckmoor the first night because it was close to the hotel...well, we ended up..."
Tiffany Burchett
"Great food!!! Great service!!! One of my favorite..."
Daryl Reid
"Literally the best pizza me and my family is ever had in our life..."
Dajuan Perrin
"BFC, or a traditional pepperoni are my go to's. So wholesome and delicious. And in my top 3 for wings...."
Samantha Sizemore
"I really like the Grippo's dry rub they have. Asked for a special order and they took great care of me (pause). Cooked perfectly to my liking. Will..."
Michael R. Laughlin
"This place is amazing! My favorite pizza delivery in Columbus. Thank you all for being so..."
Elle Hochron
"We are from out of town and they delivered to our hotel. Service was excellent, fast delivery and tasty food...."
Missy Conard
"Great pizza and appetizers. The service was great and don't forget the..."
Jim Noll
"The food was absolutely phenomenal. I haven't had a pizza that refreshing in a long time. My only complaint is the speed of service there wasn't much..."
Vivian B
"Joy was super-friendly and efficient, considering how busy she was. Jeff and Joe in the kitchen made delicious wings and pizza. Service took some..."
Lorie Dorsey
"INCREDIBLE pizza! We were in town for a conference and stayed at a nearby hotel, and ordered for delivery. The wait was 35 minutes (busy Sunday night..."
Nick S.
"Last night was the first night my family & I ordered from here. We were desperate for pizza and most places close at 11. Luckily I found OH pizza &..."
Makayla Buckner
"After a late night listening to Manchester Orchestra we were starving Baby Girl suggested this place since it was close by. The place was very clean..."
PHILTHY
"Everything was too salty, it was my 1st time there..idk about ever returning. My pizza and onion rings were over the top salty than i ever expected..."
Charli EL Rogers (Acuario)
"This was my second time here and I was not disappointed. I got traditional wings in the spicy garlic sauce. The wings are soooo good. Super crispy..."
Lee Wooding
"Very first visit. I found it to be pleasant, friendly, clean in side and outside. The pizza we ordered was made the way we like it. The wings, made..."
Joyce N
"These are the best wings you will have in Columbus! They are generous with the sauce and if you get all flats there is plenty of meat! We had the..."
Jonathan Carroll
"First time here and I must say the Cajun dusted fried pickles were amazing!! We also had a pineapple pizza and a pepperoni pizza and both were..."
Kaylie Kenney
"Went because someone reviewed the wings as best in Ohio. The wings are dynamite. Salads were good too. I will come back to try more items. The..."
Christopher Lytle
"Right off the bat I’ll say the gluten free pizza is second to none, and in fact you could sell it as a regular thin crust pizza and it would still..."
Will Johnson
"My husband and I love this place! We've been ordering from here for about 3 years now and they never let us down. We used to get delivery (even with..."
Tyler Whitten
Plank's
Plank's
77/100 (1286 ratings)
Restaurants
Bars & Pubs
Bar
Pub
American
Pizza
American
Bar
Pub
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Nachos
Beer
Sauerkraut Balls
Pepperoni Pizza
The Works Pizza
Pierogies
Italian Sub
Fish and Chips
French Fries
Mac and Cheese
Reuben Sandwich
Pesto Chicken Pizza
Burger
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Patty Melt
Short Rib Grilled Cheese
House Salad
BBQ Pork Fries
Califórnia Burger
Cheese Pizza Add Jalapeño
Salad
Boneless Wings
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Pizza
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I love the Rubens before the fire they are still the best Reuben I've ever found great place to go eat nice atmosphere great service can't ask for a..."
Michael Bush
"Love Dan the owner and All of the bartenders. So glad it’s open again! My weekly hangout! Food and drinks are..."
Keeyah Boney Adams
"So fun to visit Planks after such a long absence! The interior looks great and the food was just as good as I remember. So glad that we can add..."
Joan Casto Lloyd
"Best place to watch OSU football games! Amzzzzzing pizza, great fun, and Liz is the best server..."
Alex GD
"Visit Planks whenever I am in town. Everyone feels at home at Planks. My grandfather, father, myself and now my daughters. It's just that kind of..."
Karen Grote
"Food is good. Staff is great. Touch tunes. Drink essentials. Big patio. And it's old and has an English pub - feel to..."
Rick Duckworth
"First time for me and my hubby last night. We loved it! We'll definitely be..."
Natalie Hoyt Edwards
"Great Food and Friendly and Good..."
Bill Smith
"I'm a sucker for old school bars with strong drinks and bar food. Great bar menu from nachos, fried food and pizza that will not disappoint. Dan..."
Rob Asher
"The food was really good and honestly really affordable for what you get. It's a seat-yourself style restaurant, which is fine, but there were no..."
Julia Brewster
"Food was great. Gotta get the Pizza! Awesome atmosphere for watching a few games! Clean..."
J-Kube
"Visited Planks for a quick drink and we were right away impressed with the friendliness of the staff! The beer was cold, suggestions on point and..."
Brandy Kukielka
"Great spot to grab dinner, so many options to choose from. Pizza, burgers, brats. Parking can be a little tricky if they are busy. The service is..."
Joshua Cattrell
"Sat outside on patio, it is enclosed during cooler, colder months. It is a spacious, friendly, clean atmosphere. Service is excellent. There is a..."
k b
"The atmosphere was great for a mid day lunch on a Saturday. Not too many people around 3, although it did start to get busy around 4 as we were..."
Amanda Johns
"Been here a few times and every time has been great. Staff is super authentic (not overly nice, just "real"). Food is super good and a pretty decent..."
T Can
"Beautiful day to sit outside and feast. Food was delicious. Has ballgames on if you wanted to..."
Paula Gorsuch
"Great place! We had such a good time. Great beer selection! And great food and..."
Antonia Marrero