Best Sugar Cream Pie in Columbus

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Ye Olde Fish House
Ye Olde Fish House
86/100 (641 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
American
Seafood
American
Lunch
Side Options
Pasta
Hummingbird Cake
Mac and cheese
Tartar Sauce
Macaroni and Cheese
Filet Mignon
Apple Dumplings
Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
Fish Sandwich
Sugar Cream Pie
Fish Sandwich with Fried Potatoes
Fish
Great Fish Sandwich
Pork
Alaskan White Fish
Fish Basket Combo with Fried Potatoes
Tenderloin Sandwich with Fried Potatoes
Peanut Butter Pie Pecan Pie and Lemon Pie
Fish Dinner Combo with 2 Sides
Fish 3 Piece Sandwich
Sandwiches
Sit down
American
Seating
Parking Available
Takeout
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"What a great find! It's a tiny place, with a limited menu, but what they have is done really well! I got the fish sandwich, and they really loaded..."
Chris Frost
"People always complain about local places with good food and service disappearing, well make sure that doesn't happen and support Ye Olde Fish House...."
Ian Van Camp
"When was the last time you were out to eat and a manager stopped at every table to see if everyone was satisfied. It happened at Ye Olde Fish House..."
Donald Hadley
"Always amazing food and friendly service. Definitely the best fried fish around. They have great sides too! Being someone who regularly gets..."
Reyanna Jackson
"If you're looking for a local, family-owned place for inexpensive, quick lunch, this is it. About $11 gets you a sandwich, side and drink. And the..."
Benton Green
"Just great food, friendly atmosphere and reasonable prices. I usually don’t review things but this place was such a great find. Can’t believe..."
Daniel Livingston
"Local favorite in Columbus! The food is great. Very big fish sandwiches. Tenderloins are delicious. I've tried all their sides at least once. Can't..."
Dustin Buckley